| Individual Records | ||||
| Record | Player | Total | Opponent | Year |
| Most Points Career | Mark Vander Jagt | 1904 | 1958-61 | |
| Most Points Season | Mark Vander Jagt | 691 | 1960-61 | |
| Most Points Game | Nate Pomeday | 50 | Random Lake | 1994-95 |
| Most Points One Half | T.J. Teunissen | 32 | Stockbridge | 1990-91 |
| Most Points One Quarter | Ron Huibregtse | 22 | Grafton | 1954-55 |
| Highest Season Average | Mark Vander Jagt | 28.79 | 1960-61 | |
| Most Field Goals Career | Mark Vander Jagt | 799 | 1958-61 | |
| Most Field Goals Season | Mark Vander Jagt | 288 | 1960-61 | |
| Most Field Goals Game | Mark Vander Jagt | 19 | Sheboygan Falls | 1960-61 |
| Most Free Throws Career | T.J. Teunissen | 379 | 1989-91 | |
| Most Free Throws Season | T.J. Teunissen | 188 | 1990-91 | |
| Most Free Throws Game | Ken Ver Gowe | 16 | Elkhart Lake | 1965-66 |
| T.J. Teunissen | 16 | Howards Grove | 1990-91 | |
| Most FT Attempts Game | Cory Lawson | 27 | Howards Grove | 1988-89 |
| Most 3 Pointers Career | Nate Pomeday | 216 | 1992-95 | |
| Most 3 Pointers Season | Nate Pomeday | 84 | 1994-95 | |
| Most 3 Pointers Game | Nate Pomeday | 11 | Random Lake | 1994-95 |
| Most Fouls Career | Nate Pomeday | 283 | 1992-95 | |
| Most Fouls Season | Don Harmeling | 81 | 1957-58 | |
| Craig De Ruyter | 81 | 1986-87 | ||
| Jamie Eernisse | 81 | 1988-89 | ||