Home



Work in progress This is a work in progress

Rationality: not a strong trait in humans

The hole in the ozone layer and more importantly, climate change, have shown that humanity has great power to change our environment and the Earth's systems; our failure to respond appropriately to the latter, in spite of knowing that inaction will be disastrous, demonstrates, yet again, that we are largely irrational beings.

Written 2009/06/02
Contact: email daveclarkecb@yahoo.com
Home


Many human traits are manifestly irrational.
  • You need only observe the traffic on any road to see irrational behaviour; few people drive in a way that is efficient in fuel use, conservative in wear on their vehicle and its components, and maximises safety.
  • Our use of tobacco and many illicit drugs is harmful to our health, often damaging to society, and produces no net benefits to anyone (apart from the tobacco companies and organised crime).
  • Poker machines are designed to make money for their owners and for the owners of the premises that house the machines; it is absolutely impossible for regular players to do anything other than loose a substantial part of the money that they put into the machines; yet there are many who love to 'play' the pokies. It would make as much sense to take the money from your bank account and burn every fifth note.
  • Economists and governments refuse to recognise that growth cannot continue for ever; both believe that the economy must grow if a nation is to be 'successful'.
  • Religion is perhaps the most widespread and important human irrationality; the majority of the world's people subscribe to one or another conflicting and disparate sets of beliefs on which they largely base their lives, but for which there is absolutely no evidence.
The great pity is that humans have, by our science and technology (products of our intelligence and rationality – we can behave rationally at some times and as individuals) become very powerful. We have – primarily by our mining and burning of fossil fuels – changed the composition of 'our' planet's atmosphere to the point where the climate is changing, generally in ways that are disadvantageous to, not only ourselves, but most higher species. We have the intelligence to see this, to be able to understand the ways in which the Earth is changing, the consequences of our actions and our inactions, but not the rationality to make the necessary changes to our behaviours.

Our greatest irrationalities seem often to be associated with short-sighted thinking. Climate change is a long-term threat, driving (rather than walking or riding a bicycle) to the shop is a short-term activity. We seem unable, individually or collectively, to change our short-term behaviour for the sake of our long-term survival. Many of our day-to-day activities need to change for us to control climate change.

Our use of antibiotics is another example of short-sited thinking harming our long-term welfare. Our farmers feed antibiotics to their animals because it slightly increases the growth rates – at the same time as training bacteria to live successfully in the presence of antibiotics.

Intelligent life on Earth has been one of nature's greatest experiments in this wonderful Universe. It seems a shame that it appears to have failed because of an insufficiency of rationality.

Top
Home
Top
Home