Lethal carbon monoxide levels in N.W.T. man who died in sweat lodge: coroner

Source: CBC News

A Lutselk'e, N.W.T., man who was found dead in his sweat lodge last week had lethal amounts of carbon monoxide in his system, according to preliminary autopsy results. Deputy chief coroner Cathy Menard told CBC News Thursday that she won't know for sure if the carbon monoxide was what killed Lawrence Catholique, 52, until the full autopsy is finished in three to four months. A well-known former band leader, drug and alcohol counsellor, and spiritual healer in Lutselk'e, Catholique will be buried Saturday in a family plot in Fort Reliance, N.W.T. Family members told CBC News earlier this week that they believed Catholique had accidentally poisoned himself while burning charcoal in his air-tight sweat lodge.

"I know that he wasn't ready for this and his family's not ready for it. It was just a really, really bad accident," Ray Griffith said in an interview earlier this week. Catholique had been using a sweat lodge for about 15 years, and believed strongly in its healing abilities, said Griffith, a close family friend. Catholique had hosted many gatherings in the lodge, even entertaining aboriginal groups from Arizona, Griffith said.

"I'm going to miss him a lot … as will everyone in the community," Griffith said. "He was well respected." Speaking in Chipewyan, Catholique's father, Pierre, said his son would usually say when he was going somewhere. When the family did not hear from Catholique for a couple of days, the elder Catholique said they called RCMP. Catholique was eventually found frozen in his sweat lodge.

Other links to the incident:

Circimpolar Blog: Man Dies in Sweat Lodge February, 2009

The Windsor Star February 2009

CBC Canada February 19, 2009

This death has caused a Northwest Territories Coroner to issue a warning to First Nations communities.

Canwest News Service
February 24, 2009


N.W.T. Coroner to Issue Warning on Sweat Lodges After Man Found Dead.

DATELINE: YELLOWKNIFE
YELLOWKNIFE
- The coroner's office in the Northwest Territories is raising the alarm about traditional First Nations sweat lodges after a 52-year- old man from a remote fly-in Chipewyan community was found dead in his sweat lodge. Preliminary autopsy results showed carbon-monoxide levels in Lawrence Catholique's system had reached the toxic range, said Garth Eggenberger, the N. W.T.coroner investigating the case. Eggenberger said Catholique had used wood coals to heat the sweat lodge, which was built in his Lutselk'e backyard from tree branches bent to create a dome covered by sleeping bags and blankets. Lutselk'e sits on the East Arm of Great Slave Lake, about 200 kilometres east of Yellowknife. Eggenberger said he would be warning people against burning anything inside the enclosed space of a sweat lodge in recommendations included in his planned report on the death expected within the next four to six months. "If you are using a sweat lodge, you shouldn't be using burning material there," said Eggenberger. Eggenberger said Catholique mentioned his plans to use wood coals with at least two people in the Chipewyan community who cautioned him not to try it. River stones heated by fire are traditionally used inside sweat lodges. Water is usually poured over the hot stones to create steam while participants chant and pass around a pipe full of tobacco. RCMPsaid they had ruled out foul play in the death. Catholique was found Feb. 12 by the RCMP after his family reported him missing.





Canwest News Service

February 24, 2009 Tuesday 03:58 PM EST



Coroner warns after sweat lodge death

DATELINE: YELLOWKNIFE
The coroner's office in the Northwest Territories is raising the alarm about traditional First Nations sweat lodges after a 52-year-old man from a remote fly-in Chipewyan community was found dead in his sweat lodge. Preliminary autopsy results showed carbon-monoxide levels in Lawrence Catholique's system had reached the toxic range, said Garth Eggenberger, the N.W.T.coroner investigating the case. Eggenberger said Catholique had used wood coals to heat the sweat lodge, which was built in his Lutselk'e backyard from tree branches bent to create a dome covered by sleeping bags and blankets.




LAWRENCE BAPTISTE CATHOLIQUE;
1956-2009

BYLINE: BY NANCY MACDONALD

HIGHLIGHT: Raised as a Dene hunter in the North, he found spirituality in the Native American Church

Lawrence Baptiste Catholique was born on May 22, 1956, to Pierre, a Dene chief and hunter, and his wife, Judith, in Lutsel K'e, a treeline community of 400 on the east arm of Great Slave Lake in the Northwest Territories. He was the eldest of six children; until he was eight, the family lived year-round in a canvas tent, says his sister Mary Jane, two years his junior. The floor was insulated with caribou hides piled atop spruce branches, she says. With the wood stove roaring, "it was as comfortable as a house." Up until 1964, the Catholiques--a previous generation had been so named by missionaries unwilling to use the family's actual surname, Ghadele--ranged through forest and tundra from Fort Reliance to Taltheilei Narrows, fishing, trapping and hunting caribou. After being hired as a caretaker and fishing guide at Plummer's Lodge on Great Slave Lake, however, Pierre built a cabin near the resort. Lawrence attended the two-room Lutsel K'e Dene School, around which the community had "coalesced" in the decade following its construction in 1960, says Ray Griffith, a close friend of the family. When, in 1968, Pierre became chief, they settled in Lutsel K'e permanently.

Lutsel K'e (formerly Snowdrift--the name was changed in 1992) had 26 houses, a co-op store, a Catholic church and a residence for the visiting priest. Lawrence's family didn't have a car--"Lutsel K'e's roads aren't connected to anything," Ray explains--but they had a boat and dog team. The community soon faced a tuberculosis epidemic, which Lawrence managed to avoid. His family, however, spent more than two years at the Charles Camsell Hospital in Edmonton, while his grandfather Jean-Baptiste took Lawrence under his wing. When Lawrence's family returned from Edmonton, they resumed Dene traditions, even though more than half of the band had dropped the fall caribou hunt. Pierre hunted, skinned and butchered animals while Judith did the tanning and cooking--boiling, roasting, frying the caribou, lake trout and whitefish--and sewing mitts and moccasins made of smoke-cured caribou, says Mary Jane. By his teens, Lawrence was feeding and driving the dogs, tracking animals, laying cotton gillnets and navigating the boat through the big waves of Great Slave Lake--the continent's deepest lake. But he left school at 17, unable to read or write even after nine years. "All parents wanted their children to be educated," says Ray. "But they didn't realize that meant having the kids at school at 9 a.m., five days a week." Mid-semester, Lawrence's family would leave for a three-week hunt, "interrupting his education," Ray explains. As a young man, Lawrence worked as a fishing guide, and in the mines. "Never long-term employment," adds Ray. Autonomous and self-reliant, he was far more interested in trapping wolverine, fox, martin and beaver. Often, he'd spend the entire winter on the trap-line--sometimes by himself, says Ray. "He had no problem being alone: he would take along a drum, and sing to himself, and play the harmonica." He'd also pack a dictionary and books. With practice, he eventually taught himself to read and write, says Ray.

While most of Lutsel K'e lived in single-storey government prefabs, Lawrence built a two-storey log cabin--he even hewed its logs. A flawless outdoorsman, he "wasn't perfect," says his partner, Agnes Carlson, a Dene language teacher from Lac Brochet, Man. For a time, he "drank and drank and drank," a gruelling cycle of sobriety, treatment, relapse--which wrecked several relationships--until he kicked it once and for all 15 years ago, with the help of the Native American Church. (Because he'd split up with their mothers, he didn't raise any of his three children, Ramona, Clifford and Cory, though he kept in close touch, says Ray.) His recovery was remarkable. He became a drug and alcohol counsellor, band leader and business owner, relying heavily on the sweat lodge--a tradition that had only recently reappeared in Lutsel K'e--and its ability to heal. Five years ago, he even built one beside his house. Eight feet wide and five feet tall, it was made of willow branches bent in a dome shape and layered in canvas and blankets until it was airtight and pitch-black, says Ray. "In the middle of the floor, there's a pit for hot rocks, which you splash with water, then pray and sing. When the door is closed, it's completely sealed." On Feb. 9, Lawrence, who'd begun experimenting with wood embers in the lodge, went in by himself. "It's unusual to take a sweat alone--but not terribly unusual considering it was Lawrence," says Ray. "Sitting cross-legged in the prayer position, he fell asleep, and fell sideways." Preliminary autopsy results showed the level of carbon monoxide in his system was in the lethal range. Lawrence Catholique was 52.



Source: Nanaimo Daily News (British Columbia)

February 25, 2009 Wednesday







The preceding article was originally published in in 1995 It is reproduced here under Fair Use guidelines.

This site may contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in an effort to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. we believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml

If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use’, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.