The Casts in Basel
Premiere Cast (October 12, 95 - September 1, 96)
| Phantom | Florian Schneider |
| Phantom (alternate) | David Gaschen |
| Christine | Ute Baum |
| Christine (alternate) | Kimilee Bryant |
| Raoul, Vicomte de Chagny | Björn Olsson |
| Carlotta Giudicelli | Leigh Munro |
| Meg Giry | Natasha Knight |
| Madame Giry | Sally Williams |
| Monsieur André | Niklaus Rüegg |
| Monsieur Firmin | Thomas Bayer/Wolfgang Beigel |
| Ubaldo Piangi | Hans Dornbusch |
| Joseph Buquet | Craig A. Benham |
| Don Attilio/Passarino | Kenneth J. Church |
| Hairdresser "Il Muto"/Porter/Sniper | Christopher Lynn |
| Auctioneer/Monsieur Reyer | John Kuether |
| Lefèvre | Charles Huddleston |
| Innkeeper "Don Juan Triumphant" | Larry Morbitt |
| Monk "Don Juan Triumphant" | Kenneth Posey |
| Fireman | Peter Floch |
| Slavemaster | Christopher Lee Wright |
| Porter/Stagehand | Philip Hogan |
| Confidante/Dresser | Gertrude Spitzer |
| Madame Firmin | Catherine Forbes |
| Princess | Dana Peterson |
| Innkeeper's wife "Don Juan Triumphant" | Maya Wirz |
| Page "Don Juan Triumphant" | Susan Cook |
| Page "Don Juan Triumphant" | Maureen Dodson |
| Swings | Linda Bruske, David Gaschen, Lynette Knapp, Gene Roberts, Maureen Taylor, Craig Lemont Walters |
| Ballet of the Opéra populaire | Julie Boath, Hayley Franks, Lisa Salmoria, Angie Savage, Annette Wimmer, Kate Wray |
| Dance Captain/Swing | Leslie Wiesner |
Cast from September 3, 96 to July 27, 97:
| Phantom | Florian Schneider |
| Phantom (alternate) | David Gaschen |
| Christine | Ute Baum |
| Christine (alternate) | Beverley Worboys |
| Raoul, Vicomte de Chagny | Björn Olsson |
| Carlotta Giudicelli | Leigh Munro |
| Meg Giry | Julie Boath |
| Madame Giry | Joanna-Maria Rueffer |
| Monsieur André | Robin Buck |
| Monsieur Firmin | Eberhard Storz |
| Ubaldo Piangi | Hans Dornbusch |
| Joseph Buquet | György Mozsàr |
| Don Attilio/Passarino | Andreas Mitschke |
| Hairdresser "Il Muto"/Porter/Sniper | Christopher Lynn |
| Auctioneer/Monsieur Reyer | Gene Roberts |
| Lefèvre | Charles Huddleston |
| Innkeeper "Don Juan Triumphant" | Larry Morbitt |
| Monk "Don Juan Triumphant" | David L. Oliver |
| Fireman | Wolfgang Höltzel |
| Slavemaster | Manoel Francisco |
| Porter/Stagehand | Philip Hogan |
| Confidante/Dresser | Gertrude Spitzer |
| Madame Firmin | Catherine Forbes |
| Princess | Lynette Knapp |
| Innkeeper's wife "Don Juan Triumphant" | Maya Wirz |
| Page "Don Juan Triumphant" | Shelley Karson |
| Page "Don Juan Triumphant" | Bonnie Thorpe |
| Swings | Bardo Bayvertian, Linda Bruske, Kathleen Michaels, Andreas Ortwein, Brigitte Schweizer, Craig Lemont Walters, Wade Wilson |
| Ballet of the Opéra populaire | Hayley Franks, Susan Kaufmann, Maria Pedreira, Lisa Salmoria, Angie Savage, Annette Wimmer, Kate Wray |
| Dance Captain/Swing | Leslie Wiesner |