"This is as
eclectic a collection of essays as I've ever encountered - boyhood reminiscences, the San
Patricios, horrifying depredations of rats, natural themes, global capitalism, liberation
theology, you name it. Yet Hogan brings it off successfully and you never get the
impression that he spreads himself too thin. What holds these themes together is the
author's sensitivity to multiculturalism, his astonishingly wide range of interests, and a
spirit which is tolerant, humanistic and at the same time pragmatic."
- Jim Tuck, author of The Holy War In Los Altos: Mexico's Cristero Rebellion
"Hogan's work is compelling, fascinating. His books should be
required reading for serious American students who aspire to be educated in a
multicultural world."
- William Geogiades, Executive Director, Office of International Education, University of
Houston.
"Hogan is a master craftsman, quiet, gentle, with a positive,
uplifting humor."
- Katherine Ames, Library Journal.
JUDAS BURNING
Here in Guadalajara the roses bloom all year, even in
the dry season when the dust tastes of burning carcasses and excrement. Purple jacaranda
blossoms appear in the trees, and bougainvillea covers the broken glass of the high walls
of the wealthy houses in Colonia Seattle. What we depend upon is not illusion but the
generous paradox of dry arroyos and night-blooming acacia, the fresh fruit and flowers
sold by local women, the blanketed Indians in the tropical heat, a place where Christ
bleeds darkly and the Virgin is bright with victory candles.
I have left Barrio Padre for the long walk up the cobblestone streets to
the Basilica. It is not exactly a holiday or a fiesta. It is merely Thursday of Holy Week
and yet the square is crowded with Huichol Indians dressed in blues, oranges, startling
pinks and purples. There are stands selling roasted corn on the cob, hot corn tortillas,
baked empañadas filled with strawberry, or the tuna fruit of the cactus. I have come here
thinking of attending Mass (there is one every hour) and yet the Basilica is packed at ten
o'clock and again at eleven after I've made my leisurely circuit of the square .
There are Judas dolls for sale, ugly little things with straw
bodies. Their faces remind me of Miss Piggy, although none are as cute. There is something
unholy about these dolls, like those used in witchcraft or voodoo.
A priest has come out of the side door of the Basilica and the crowd
gathers around him as he reads from the Bible. The noise of the hawkers and buyers,
children and dogs, has quieted mysteriously. One has the feeling of being in two worlds
here. The ancient Basilica with its wooden floors and bleeding Christ, its crumbling wall
and footworn stone steps seems to belong to another Church more ancient and terrible than
that indicated by the modern sculpture in front which depicts mild Pope John visiting
Mexico and blessing Zapopan.
Someone begins shaking seeds in a hollow gourd and others join in with
wooden rattles (which are for sale) as the priest read from the Bible. "Because Judas
knew the place, and brought a band of men and officers from the chief priests, with
lanterns, torches and weapons..."
And now Judas comes, carried by two Huicholes with bleached white cotton
pants held up by ropes for belts, their naked chests gleaming wetly bronze in the noonday
sun. Their Judas is a straw man in a costume of colored feathers with a gruesome pig's
face. He looks through the trees for the Savior. He looks through the crowd and the people
raise their hands to block his view. To the side of the crowd are some white and red
oleander bushes. This is where the figure of Christ has been hidden all along.
More Huichol men stand in front of the bushes very quietly. They could
be anywhere. Outside an adobe hut in Puebla, in front of a liquor store in Tucson. They
look like they have been here in this spot forever. They do not wish to attract attention.
They are as part of the landscape. Horseman, pass by! But it is precisely this spot that
Judas approaches. He is interested in what is behind those bushes. The sound of the seeds
in the gourd and the sound of the rattles increase in volume.
The ugly pigfaced Judas is carried through the poisonous oleander bushes
to where the statue of Christ is hidden. The priest intones: "He has given them the
sign that whosoever he shall kiss, that is the Savior." And the straw effigy of Judas
is borne by the two barechested Indians to the Christ statue. The priest reads on:
"And Jesus says to the soldiers, 'Whom do you seek?' They reply, 'Jesus of Nazareth.'
And the Savior says, 'I am He whom thou seeketh.'"
Then the effigy of Judas is carried to a side street. It is strung up
with the help of some young boys and suspended from an ash tree. And, if Jesus is to have
his hand-painted sign "Jesus of Nazareth, King of the Jews" at the hour of his
crucifixion, Judas also will be acknowledged. Hastily-written signs appear on his chest
and back: "Foreign Debt," names of dishonest politicians, "Yanquis
Asesinos." Judas is more than a symbol. He is the embodiment of all the betrayals
suffered and those still to be suffered. A young woman hangs a sign with the name of a
lover who abandoned her. On a whitewashed wall nearby are faded red letters: "PUTO
BUSH CREE QUE UN LITRO DE GASOLINA VALE UN MUNDO DE SANGRE." A not-so-subtle
reference to the Gulf War which was not so popular here as it appeared to be further
North.
Then someone approaches with a burning stick soaked in kerosene and
proceeds to set fire to the effigy of Judas. It burns for a moment or two and then
explodes with a startling POOM! scattering cloth, straw and colored paper over the crowd.
Then children with their doll-sized Judases dance around. And young men
holding other Judases on long poles stuffed with fireworks set them on fire. The crowd
shouts and chants, the seeds in the gourds rattle like evil snakes, and everywhere the
dogs are barking and howling.
Frances Calderón de la Barca, witnessing a scene similar to this in
Mexico City in the last century, was appalled at the "ugly misshapen monsters"
representing Judas which filled the Semana Santa streets. "Poor Judas," she
wrote. "Did he ever dream then that in the lapse of ages his effigies should be held
up to the desecration of an unknown people in an undiscovered country beyond the sea. A
secret bargain, perhaps made whisperingly in a darkened chamber with fierce Jewish rulers;
but now shouted forth in the ears of the descendants of Montezuma and Cortés."
I am reminded of another Holy Week when, broke and living in a cheap
hotel in San Francisco, I read the Chekhov story in which a young man hears again the
story of Simon Peter's denial of Christ during a reading of the Passion at his local
church. So moved is he that he relates it to a peasant woman he meets in the village on
his way home. And, as he retells the story with "the enthusiasm of one who has
understood it clearly for the first time," the peasant woman begins to weep. The
young man weeps as well.
The young man is struck suddenly by the durability of the story and its
accessibility. It has moved both him, an educated youth, and this unlettered peasant.
Separated from each other by an enormous gulf, distanced by culture and the ages from the
Jewish fisherman, they are still able to weep in empathy for Peter as he denies knowledge
of his Lord not once, but "three times before the cock crowed."
What grief he must have felt, this Simon! What remorse must have filled
his heart; how heavy and empty his life must have seemed then. He, like Judas, had clearly
betrayed his master ("I do not know the man!").
So, why is Simon, now Peter, the "rock" of the Church, while
Judas is a figure of universal condemnation? One a saint and the other buried in
unhallowed ground? Why is one enshrined and the other vilified if they both committed the
same crime: betrayal of a friend and teacher?
Peter, hearing the cock crow, "went out and wept bitterly."
Judas "repented himself and...cast down the thirty pieces of silver saying, 'I have
sinned in that I have betrayed innocent blood.'" Clearly they both felt remorse.
Clearly they both acknowledged their crimes and repented. Moreover, Judas actually went
and made amends, returning the money he had received.
If there is any difference in these men it would seem only to have been
Judas' despair. For Simon lived with his shame, his remorse, hoping against hope. Judas,
on the other hand, "having cast down the silver pieces, departed, and went and hanged
himself."
One of my favorite stories is when Christ returns from the dead and
appears to the Apostles. He called Peter to him. "Simon," he says, "lovest
thou Me?" "Yea, Lord," says Peter. "You know I love You." Jesus
says, "Feed my sheep. A second time Jesus asks, "Lovest thou Me?" Again
Peter replies, "You know I do, Lord." "Feed my sheep," says Jesus.
A third time Jesus asks, "Simon, lovest thou Me." "Yea,
Lord," says Peter, who by now must have gotten the point. "You know I love
You." Jesus says to him, "Feed my lambs."
Denied by his friend three times in succession, Jesus forgives him three
times, contingent on an affirmation of love also made three consecutive times. Some divine
humor there! But also an echo of his own teaching to forgive "even unto seventy times
seven times."
Then finally he says to Simon: "I say unto thee thou art Peter and
upon this rock I will build my Church." A pun on petrus (more humor) and
another echo, for Jesus had promised earlier that in his kingdom "the last shall be
first." Peter thus receives an unearned promotion from the ranks of the twelve
apostles. Unearned grace. Unearned forgiveness. Exactly what Judas in his materialistic
mind-set refused. Return of the thirty pieces of silver, yes. But he followed that by a
negation of hope. Refusing to believe in forgiveness, he took his life.
Peter gave nothing but his persistent "Yea!" in the face of
Jesus's questions. But these "yeas" were extensions of the earlier affirmation
when, full of remorse, self-pity, self-hatred and angst, he did not give in to despair but
held on when there was little to hope for except "the belief in things unseen,"
the power of love which would eventually redeem him.
When Judas is taken in effigy from the Zapopan plaza, he is more than a
symbol. He is the dry straw of all the betrayals we have suffered which clogs the drainage
of our hearts, which fills our mouth with the taste of rancid wine and the dust of tombs.
All the betrayals, the bitterness, the resentments which must be burned away if we are
ever truly to live again, ever to be reborn.
A few months ago Texas executed still another convicted felon. After the
execution reporters asked the mother of the murder's victim if, now that the man was dead,
she could forgive him. "Never," she said. I will never forgive him as long as I
live." I wish she could have been here today.
The sibilant strains of the Miserere in the evening echo among the
emptying fruit stands and the stalls of the vendors. I buy a cup of cut melon and begin
walking home. There has not been a single church bell rung in all of Mexico today. And
there will not be until Easter morning. It had not occurred to me how much I would miss
that. The deep and unutterable sadness of someone used to being lulled to sleep by the
sound of foghorns or the lapping of waves now alone in the silent night of the high
plateau of Jalisco. Hard to believe that the Resurrection is less than three days away. A
small taste perhaps of what Judas felt.
|