Don't drink and drive.
O'Toole's
Reviewed by Brian and Matt 02-22-03.
Where
5728 Pickwick Road
Centreville, VA 20121
703.222.5171
Homepage

Along US-29, just north of the VA-28 intersection, just south of West Ox Road.

Summary
What if someone built a good bar and nobody came? And then they had to adopt the bar to the needs of a bunch of fucknuts?
Specialties
O'Toole's specializes in the worst the area has to offer, from the Northern bob-tailed Skank to to nocturnal Whooping Jock-hole. Actually, the only reason to come here is the pool.

I used to live in Centreville, in that landfill of bachelor apartments that rings the 28/29 intersection. So I’ve spent whole happy hours in the Shade Tree, I’ve walked in a semi-controlled fashion down the hill from Sweetwater Tavern, I’ve given a dejected finger to the Shark Club bouncer when their cover was too high. Generally, I was excited to move to parts east, because it was pretty clear how barren Centreville was. O’Toole's is an embodiment of that social scorched earth policy… I hated it then, and the three years I gave it to improve were not used productively by the staff. I’m starting to think that my congressman doesn’t pass on all the suggestions I send him to all the various people I have problems with. Did you know that Borders books still won’t refill my coffee for free? Why the hell did I vote for Tom Davis then?

Anyway, walk into O’Toole's and in five minutes you’ll either have my reaction (“Can we just go to the convenience store and drink beer in the parking lot?”) or you’re excited about the chance to dance and mingle with the successful singles of Centreville’s Whore Corridor. In which case you’ve long ago realized this isn’t the site for you, possibly around the time we made our fiftieth Robocop reference. O’Toole's is totally bifurcated, on the south side people are packed in head-to-tailfin, a deejay is putting out the kind of crappy dance music that makes me light q-tips on fire, and oh, did I mention that you’ll have to wade through all of this in order to get a drink? To the north, things get more functional, this is where we spent 99% of our visit. O’Toole's has an arcade section lifted from a bowling alley (I know I saw a claw game) and about ten pool tables. Granted, this section isn’t overly crowded, if it was you’d never be able to use a cue properly… but it is drawing a population of frustrated never-againers from the dance bar half, so it’s always full to capacity.

And here’s where I have to give credit, O’Toole's has well-oiled machinery keeping the tables in efficient rotation. A dedicated monitor station maintains a waitlist, and darkens the light above tables as soon as they go unused. So, while we were initially turned away (and forced to lean against the railing, waiting and enjoying our relative ability to converse away from the dancetorium), it wasn’t too long before our name queued up. I figure most people sign up and move on to an area where they’ll never here themselves being called, so just being around the booth means you’ll likely get the next table. Pool here is in a midrange price, about $8 an hour… I’ve seen worse, I’ve seen better, and the tables are pretty well maintained. But aside from billiards, where’s the love?

And more than that, where’s the atmosphere implicitly promised by the sign outside? The name reads: “O’Toole’s Roadhouse Restaurant”; someone long ago raped all the Irish out of this place. Look at all the dancing going on, all that’s left of the pub atmosphere is some green paint and a Guinness tap. Although the roadhouse bit kind of fits, I can imagine Patrick Swayze throwing me out of here. It’s my way or the highway, every one! The staff seems to perform admirably for being in the middle of a feeding frenzy every night, but also didn’t distinguish themselves. I dunno, this just wasn’t our thing, maybe it’s yours. I can’t possibly see into the mind of a dancer or a mingler to tell why people would like this kind of place, but I’ve been bitching about the crowds for a while, so maybe they do.

Or maybe there’s another explanation. I’ve been doing a grid-by-grid deconstruction of Centreville, trying to find the places we might have missed, holes in the wall that are sitting pristine to the west… and I’m coming up blank. Additionally, the total list of non-restaurants in Centreville/Chantilly is barely cresting ten. Density isn’t big around here, there’s sprawl without urbanity, there’s no old growth; and thus you get a choking sensation when a place does try to bring a little oxygen to the atmosphere… it will inevitably suffer from too many people, anxious to breathe. Kind of against the thesis of this sight, but oh well. We love McLean, Vienna has some highlights, Springfield looks promising on paper, I’m itching to work into the corners of Reston/Herndon, but Centreville seems to be a labor to explore. O’Toole's… feh.

Ah, O'tooles . . .

It really is less of an Irish bar and more of a Dance-Dance-Revolution with a hint of the blarney. I mean, yeah, its got paddy green walls with dark wood paneling (and the paddy wagon parked out front hints at a good 'ol fashioned Irish bar brawl), and maybe at one point it was an Irish joint but not anymore. Check the pictures below and what do you have? A dance floor, lightning bolt shaped bar, license plates on the walls, a pool hall and an arcade. When did 80's bubble gum music become Irish?

But let's focus on good things for now. The arcade was replete with old favorites and an air hockey table (air hockey rules). That's a big plus, even if you have to pay a dollar to play Ms. Pac Man. As Brian stated, the pool hall had many many tables and was very well run - not quite as appealing as coin operated tables, but better then Carpool or Shark Club. It was in this very pool hall that Brian and I displayed our domination over the game of pool destroying Eddie and Alex (see below). No, we're not that white, that is the light of glory we are basking in.

Who are they kidding?  They are some WHITE mo-fo's.
New co-champions of the universe!

Another plus is the drinks. Yeah, it is nearly impossible for someone without a size C or better rack to get to the bar, but once you do the beer is good and reasonably priced - one of the niceties of getting away from DC or similar locales. I heard claims of $4 for 22 oz which made Brian swoon.

As far as the clientele, Eddie put it well when he said, "there isn't a chick here who isn't trying to show off their boobs". This is definitely a singles bar, and most of the ladies took liberties with that notion. I'm not a fan of the bouncers either - cold and emotionless, bouncing is a job to them, not a passion. Not what I prefer. Now bouncers at strip clubs - those guys are class and they love their jobs. Plus, the last time I was here the bouncers were dicks to me and I never forget a slight.

But I'm off topic again.

I hate how Brian and I always end up playing good cop / bad cop on these reviews (especially since I end up being good cop which is . . . odd), but I just can't bring myself to properly hate this place - the pool tables were too well run and the beer too reasonable and that makes a compelling argument for a thumbs up. I did have a very fun time here, and not just because Brian and I are now Grand Pool Champions of the Universe. However, I still have to give it a thumbs down though - one cool corner of a bad place can't quite salvage the reputation.


Yes, we're taking a picture of you.

Things Nearby Photos
Nothing within true spitting distance, but travel south down Rt. 29 for a tad and you'll be in Suburban Mini-mall heaven! No, wait, heaven's not the word I want here...
Others' Comments

"And can I tell you that Matthew, dear Matthew - aka 5.0 on the Tag-Board, has amazing clarity when he drinks. Al and I hooked up with him and some peeps at O'Toole's. Sounds like an Irish pub, but it's a, uhm... well, let's just say it's not. More of a college-type bar with people trying to get seen and whatnot. Funny stuff, but the 22 oz $4 beers aren't something to laugh about. A review should be posted on Matt and Brian's site shortly."

- from Eddie's page

Submit Comments


The cool corner.

Dancing monkeys...