| Issue | Comment | Reprinted in |
| Batman #63 | 1st Appearance, vs. Batman and Robin, identical cases appear for both GA and SA Batmen | |
| Detective #173 | vs. Batman and Robin | |
| Justice League of America #35 | Behind the scenes only | |
| Batman #200 | (cameo) | |
| Detective #359 | vs. Batman, Robin and Batgirl, 1st unambiguous Silver Age appearance | Batman #208 |
| Batman Family #10 | vs. Batgirl and Batwoman | |
| Batman Family #15 | vs Batgirl and Robin | |
| Secret Society of Super-Villains #16-17 | never published, w/ SSOSV, vs the Freedom Fighters | Cancelled Comics Cavalcade #2 |
| Detective #526 | w/ many Bat-villains, vs Batman |