Under Construction

Cards | USB Flash drives
Type Size Compatibiity
SD Secure Digital 128MB-4GB Canon PowerShot, Pentax, Nikon, Palm (newer)
SDHC SD High Capacity 4-32GB
mini SD miniSecure Digital 128MB-2GB Cell Phones
micro SD microSecure Digital 128MB-2GB Cell Phones
MMC Multi Media Card   Canon PowerShot
CF-I CompactFlash I 128MB-8GB Canon EOS & Digital Rebel, Olympus, old Nikon, old Palm and Pocket PCs
CF-II CompactFlash II 128MB-8GB Microdrive, Olympus
xD xD Picture Card 64M-1GB Fuji, Olympus
MS Memory Stick Pro 512MB-4GB Sony
Memory Stick Duo Pro 256MB-2GB Sony
SM Smart Media 128MB Fuji, old Olympus
Other types of cards:
SIM - Subscriber Identity Module for mobil phones
Smart card or or integrated circuit card (ICC) (ISO 7810 and 7816 Card Standard)
  Credit Card with imbedded ICC.
PC Card - PCMCIA - 85.6 mm long and 54.0 mm wide

Type Size TransferRate Price
SanDisk Secure Digital
Extreme III 1GB 20MB/sec $140
Extreme III 12GB 20MB/sec $780
Extreme III 16GB 20MB/sec $1050
Ultra II 1GB 10MB/sec $80
Standard 1GB 2MB/sec $50
Ultra II 2GB 10MB/sec $120
Standard 2GB 2MB/sec $100
Transend Secure Digital
High Speed 4GB 22MB/sec $220
Note: Above types are SanDisk names; other manufactures use terms like High Speed or Extreme Performance for faster cards.
There is a brand name Ultra who's basic card is a 40X write speed. Price a/o Mar. 2006

Transfer Rate
13X 2MB/sec
60X 9MB/sec
66X 10MB/sec
133X 20MB/sec
150X 22.5MB/sec
These speed notations may not be consistent among manufactures.
Write speeds are slower than read speeds.

Most camera manuals don't tell you what speed of flash card you should buy, usually recommending a type and maybe a manufacturer (who has often paid to be included in their recommended list). If your camera has resolution under five mega pixels, the speed rating of the flash card won't matter much. In fact many cameras will not work well with ultra high speed cards of 133X and 150X speeds because of the special formatting used to achieve these high speeds. The improvement you are likely to see in a higher rated card will be minimal and undetectable.

Professional photographers using professional-grade cameras should use high-speed flash (40X - 150X). If your camera has a pixel rate more than five mega pixels, you will benefit from a flash card with a higher speed rating. If your camera has a resolution less than five mega pixels, simply use cards rated less than 40X, this way you can ensure compatibility and not spend money unnecessarily on higher rated cards.

Secure Digital:
Secure digital cards or SD card for short, is a derivative of the now widely used Multi media (MM) cards. The SD's data transfer rate is up to 10MB/sec, which is four times faster than the MM cards.
The outstanding feature of SD cards is that, it is in compliance with SDMI or Secure Digital Music Initiative. This feature of the card will not allow for example, a copyrighted music to be downloaded from any source. Almost all electronic manufacturers are coming up with products, which support the SD cards hoping this would be the next big thing in memory cards. Products, which support SD cards, are almost backward compatible with MM Cards but not the other way around.

SanDisk Ultra II Plus SD Card can be folded to fit directly in a USB port. 1G = $90

CompactFlash (CF) cards provide complete PCMCIA-ATA functionality and compatibility and can be used in a PCMCIA slot with an adapter.
A Microdrive is a CF Type II card and can go up to 4GB.
CF Type I thickness is 3.3 mm; CF Type II thickness is 5 mm
The CompactFlash card specification version 3.0 supports data rates up to 66MB/sec and capacities up to 137GB.

32GB USB flash memory sticks (thumb drives), now available at $120, are an alternative for backup.
Listed Data Transfer Rate are 19MBps Read 13MBps Write
Actual for a 32GB flash stick are:

	               Sequential Read       Write
32 GB Corsair Flash Voyager 22 MB/sec  10 MB/sec
32 GB OCZ Rally 2           30 MB/sec  22 MB/sec
32 GB Patriot Xporter XT    31 MB/sec  17 MB/sec
Actual report on Amazon for OCZ OCZUSBATV32G 32GB ATV USB:
2.5MBps write (3-5 hrs for 25GB) for a lot of small files. Large files copy faster.
When I formated it as a DOS (Fat32) disk it wrote at about 1.5 MB/sec
When I formated it as Mac OS Extended (Journaled) and was about 2 MB/sec.
A 2GHz dual processer Mac Pro gave 4 MB/sec
When I partitioned a 32GB OCZ ATV into 2 FAT32 partitions and copied from a Mac PowerBook G4 wuih USB 2.0 it 2 hrs to copy 350 MB. 0.05 Mb/sec.
On a PC witn Win 2K: Read Write OCZ 32G 0.97 MB/s 0.59 MB/s Cruzer 4G 0.97 MB/s 0.94M B/s Windows will not read more than one partition on a removable drive.
You can get software to flip the removable drive bit so it will work.

USB 2 was reported to be slower on Macs (may be improved in panther OS X 10.3)
See: X-Bit Labs rreview of 32 GB USB flash drives:

See:
Flash USB (thumb) drives
Speed Tests at MobileTechReview.com
TigerDirect.com/
Reviews and FAQ: Memory Cards at MobileTechreview.com
SDcard.org


Return to Products

last updated 3 Nov 2006