PROCEEDING
OF THE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON EUROPEAN
ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY AND THE CASE OF CYPRUS MINES
|
AFFECTS OF CMC MINNING ON NATURAL RESOURCES IN LEFKE |
¹ prof.dr. Ünal ALTINBAŞ, ²prof.dr. Ümİt
ERDEM and ² N. Ozan VERYERİ
¹ Ege University, Faculty of Agriculture, Department of
Soil Science,Turkey
²
Ege University, Centre for Environmental Studies, Turkey
SUMMARY
All
forms of life surrounding us are dependent on the natural sources like soil,
water and air that they find life on, within strong bounds of harmony.
Unbroken and constant existence of natural life is the result of these healthy
and delicately balanced interrelations. Any kind of material introduced in
natural life or an ecosystem resulting with natural life fragmentation is
determined as “a pollutant”. Pollutants may be the reasons of chemical
and/or physical change in ecosystems in a stretch of time or may exist in a
stable form for relatively longer time periods, in environment.
Copper
mine plantations located around Gemikonağı Harbour of Lefke Region in Cyprus
have a history of 5000 years. The name of the island “Cyprus” is generated
over the terms of Cyprium, Cuprum, and finally Cyprus that all mean
“copper”. Cyprus is known to be the place where copper is produced in form
of metal for the first time on world.
Crude
gem of the reserve plantations, an uncovered one at Lefke, a covered one at
Karadağ and chemical wastes, accumulated wastes, wastes of copper process
with cyanide, mayor wastes of copper flotation establishment, waste pools with
pyrite consisting 25-30 % sulphur at Gemikonağı harbour at the region of
Karadağ, south west of Lefke, north part of Trodos magmatic solid are
the sources of soil, vegetation, underwater and sea water pollution and beside
all, air pollution by particles of mine
and sulphur gasses relevant to high temperatures at summer times.
By
Gemikonağı puddle where has been constructed over Maden (Mine) Stream as
soil filled dam we see areas of mine. Likewise at these locations, iron,
coppered sulphur and tailing carried to surface waters are the source of
acidic environment for drinking and irrigation waters relevant to condensation
of heavy metals.
In
pools for wastes, mean soil reaction (pH) 2.35 and extremely acidic, total
soluble salt 1.29% and strongly
saline, total sulphur (S) 9.18 %, total copper (Cu) 672.46 ppm, total iron
(Fe) 8.15 % total manganese (Mn) 232.06 ppm, total cobalt (Co) 60.34 ppm,
total lead (Pb) 34.75 ppm, total chrome (Cr) 32.19 ppm, electrical
permeability in some of the waters 1350 mmhos/cm, pH 6.13 (weak acid) are the
measured values whereas C3S1 represents the quality of the irrigation water.
On the samples of vegetation, Fe, Pb, Cu in bean leaves, Cu in orange, cabbage
and mandarin, and Cr in the leaves of orange are definite pollutants.
It
is vital to have below precautions urgently for the natural resources under
pollution of sulphur and some heavy metals at the region;
1.
Preventing the penetration of tailing and mine accumulations in the
drainage basin to Gemikonağı Puddle at Lefke Mine stream. Periodic
controlling of the puddle waters and the wells that the puddle is the
foundation of and preventing the use of these waters for the serve of drinking
and irrigation.
2.
Accumulated wastes of mine, wastes of chemicals, wastes of scraps left
behind after the completion of establishments at Gemikonağıı are also the
sources of visual pollution beside natural resource pollution at soil,
vegetation, and waters. Thus observing the sources of pollution continuously in order to define the chemical functions so taking samples
from the depths 0-1 m, 1-2.5 m, 2.5-4 m, 4-5.5 m, 5.5-7 m, 7-8.5 m to be
analysed, for this aim.
3.
Preventing the access of human and any animal to the area by green
fence convenient to ecology of the region or by wire fence. Putting emphasis
on creating the green fence and making use of its resistance and acceptable
impermeability to storms that will help in decreasing the level of pollutants
spreading around.
4.
Preventing the penetration of rain waters to the area of waste at the
south part of the region by constructing circulation channels at the above
parts of the basin is vital and urgent to prevent the decharge of the heavy
metals soluble, beside very acidic reactions, in these waters.
Copper mines that are
located around Gemikonağı Harbour in Lefke, North Cyprus Turkish
Republic, have a history of 5000 years.
The
region is in Trodos magmatic
complex and located in Trodos
lava pads of iron (pyrite), and copper (calcopyrite). As a natural result of
long term history of copper production, the name of the island “Cyprus” is
generated over the terms of "Cyprium”
and “Cuprum” that finally combined together in the word “Cyprus”
meaning “copper”.
Trodos
solid is an area where ocean sheet has reached to earth surface. Mines rich of
sulphur involving pyrite, calcopyrite, marcasit, sfalarid, galen, bornit, with
copper, zinc, iron and sulphur
lairs. These lairs mostly occur at the base or upper part of the lava pads in
upper levels of the Trodos solid.
Sources of pollutants that have
threatened the livelihood of soil,
underground waters and sea ecosystems where as air pollution caused by sulphur
gases and mine particles due to the high temperatures of summer time have been
the crude gem reservoirs -
an uncovered one at Lefke, and a covered one at Karadağ - and chemical
wastes, accumulated wastes, wastes of gold process with cyanide (Figure 1),
major wastes of copper flotation plants, waste pools with pyrite consisting
25-30 % sulphur at Gemikonağı harbour in the region of
Karadağ, south west of Lefke, and north part of
Trodos magmatic solid ( Figure 2,3). There are mines as well at
Gemikonağı puddle which have been constructed over Maden (Mine) Stream as a
soil filled dam. Like the reservoirs mentioned above, this dam carries iron
and coppered sulphur and tailings to the surface waters causing acidic
environment for drinking and irrigation waters because of the condensation of
heavy metals.
|
Figure 1. The little
wastes hill containing cynanide
|
Figure
2. Waste pools in CMC area
|
|
|
Figure 3. Waste pools in CMC area |
Figure 4. The CMC plant process |
Figure 5. The CMC plant process |
Lefke-
Gemikonağı gem plantation is intensively operated by Cyprus Mine Company (CMC) since 1913 till year 1974 of
end of the activities (Figure 4), leaving back all the wastes produced
in this activity term their fate in form of a valley of death (Figure
5,6,7,8).
![]() |
|
|
Figure 6. The wastes of CMC in area |
Figure 7. The CMC plant process wastes |
Figure 8. The wastes of CMC in area |
Local
pollution caused and left after the mine plantation indicates four distinctive
level of image from sea level to
mountain areas.
These
are:
1.
Wastes of gold having the possibility consisting in cyanide at the
entrance area of Gemikonağı plantations,
2.
Eastes of copper flotation at the entrance areas of
Gemikonağı plantations,
3.
Waste pools consisting in condensed pyrite mineral having 30 % sulphur
in, separated to uprising 6 branches of waste pools,
4.
Low copper accumulations
and also wastes of trailing in apparent streams at Karadağ region due to mine
production extractions. At the regions of copper plantations and near areas of uncovered inactive gem production
plantations, at areas of stock for gem and gem wastes, have the tendency of
penetrating to sea ecosystem due to rain waters and land inclinations
by surface flow. Beside, wastes founded on the surface like calcopyrite (CuFe2),pyrite
( FeS2 ), and mineral
rich of sulphur getting in reaction with rain waters and free oxygen and
rising the condensation of the wastes and acid level of waters thus give
pollution parameters in surface waters, surrounding soils, coastline and sea
water. Also a coastline of 5 km length and 800 m width, the
Mediterranean sea marine
band is observed to get in an abnormal color where color condensation
increases after precipitation (Figure 9). Increase in the amounts of Fe, Cu, Pb ions is the result of condensation in acidity.
Sulphuric ions and complexes, condensation of
H ion pollution, diminish the natural qualities of soil and water.
The
source of the blue color that we observe at the upper parts of Gemikonağı
puddle and direct connection points of Maden
stream with the same puddle is the copper element (Figure 10). Gem wastes,
chemical material wastes, solid wastes left after the gem plantation observed
from sea level to upper areas at Gemikonağı, enlarged the environmental
problems.
|
|
|
Figure 9. Mediterranean waters by the coastline |
Figure 10. It’s another waste pools and It has blue colour from copper, and reddish from iron |
Figure 11. Researchers group in 1999 at CMC area |
Sample
materials that are used in pollution analyses are taken from mine wastes,
soil, water and plant under influence of CMC in Lefke Region, Cyprus, at dates
25.03.1999 and 9.10.1999 (Figure 11). Physical, chemical and heavy metal
analyses completed with these samples within the principles defined in the
nearby presented literature (Slavin,1968;Merck,1973;Chen,1991).
RESULT
AND DISCUSSION
Below
diagram gives data on some laboratory analyses of the 4 different samples
taken from the waste pools 1,3,5,6. These pools are among the ones which are
by the previous mine plantation waste area, located in gradually different
heights down to sea level giving an image of
set.
Table
1. Waste Analyse Results (Waste pools are given number considering their
locations from upper to lower in altitude, that is a numeric order
from Karadağ to Gemikonağı)
|
Reaction
of saturation percentage ( pH) is ultra acid, total soluble salt in water,
strongly saline. Data on potential microelements and heavy metals, are
maintained from the HClO4 + HF solution which wastes are fragmented
in. According to these data; sulphur (S) 4.85-16.82% ; iron (Fe),
3.8713-14.7719 %, manganese (Mn) 0.0051-0.0209 %; zinc (Zn) 0.0043-0.0110 %,
copper (Cu) 0.0281-0.1103 %; cadmium (Cd) , 0.0001-0.00015 %; cobalt
(Co) 0.0023-0.0099 %; lead (Pb) 0.0012-0.0083 %; chrome (Cr)
0.0010-0.0060 %; molybdaen ( Mo)
0.0018-0.0296 % in dispersion levels (Figure 12).
|
Figure 12. Reddish colour from iron, yellowish from sulpfur |
According
to maintained research data, the gem plantation kept active economically by
CMC consisted in 1.3 % Cu and more than 45 % S up to 1974 and before years
till they are exhausted. Following this phase
the same firm researched for new potential areas of reservoirs and
determined and calculated that at Lefke A1 reserve 0.35 % Cu, Lefke A2 0.56 %
Cu, where as Lefke A3 0.36 % Cu
are potential mines in these reservoirs.
In waste pools Cu gem is in concentration of
0.0281-0.1103 % levels. Thus we understand that the gem plantation has
drained 1/20 percentage of the potential Cu into the waste pools and this
caused concentration of Cu in
these pools 10 times higher than the percentages of lithosphere. We observe
that in 3th and 5th pools
zinc (Zn), copper (Cu), manganese (Mn) and chrome (Cr), in 1st
and 6th pools iron (Fe), cadmium (Cd), cobalt (Co), lead (Pb) and
molybdean (Mo) are concentrated according to analyse data.
Dispersion
of sulphur is at maximum level of concentration at 1. waste pool and this
datum reaches up to 16.82 % . Considering the level of sulphur dispersal as
0.08 % in lithosphere, percentage of wastes are calculated to be 200 times
more. Current intense data of high accumulation percentages indicate the
dimensions of sulphur pollution at the area.
Reactions
(pH) in the waste pools are very acidic. This concentrates the chemical
defragmentations and at the end the heavy metals are freed. This last phase
leads penetration of heavy metals into underground waters, surface waters ,
sea water and nearby lands causing an increase in environmental pollution
every passing day. At the sampling
phase from the upper sections it is realised that the surrounding is in
intense odour of sulphur. Due to condensation of very high acid in solution of
sulphureos and sulphuric acid, while taking samples in touch with the
surrounding material it is observed that our skin is effected from this acidic
condition very negatively (Figure 13). Beside all clay+silt particles
spreading around up to 70-80 % extend by the help of surrounding winds in form
of dust clouds create environmental pollution rich of heavy metals and sulphur
(Figure 14).
![]() |
||
Figure 13. An affected leg of a man from CMC wastes |
|
|
Figure 14. Clay deposit as hexagonal in CMC area |
Samples
are taken from the soil, plant and water under the influence of copper
plantation Gemikonagi, Lefke, North Cyprus Turkish Republic at date 09.10.1999
and analysed (Table 2,3,4). The garden of Mehmet Ozakdenizli is found to be
very acidic and consisting in very high levels of salt which are the
indications of intense affection from CMC wastes (Figure 15).
Table 2. Some physical
and chemical analyse results of soils
|
Heavy
metal distribution as Iron (Fe) 2.08-6.10 %, copper (Cu) 24-504 ppm, manganese
(Mn) 687.3-1099.8 ppm., zinc (Zn) 55.0-217.5 ppm, cadmium (Cd) 0.78-1.85 ppm,
cobalt (Co) 14.0-38.0 ppm., lead (Pb) 11.3-45.0 ppm, chrome (Cr) 2.3-25.9 ppm,
aluminium (Al) 0.18-5.18 % are the dispersion levels that generally increase
along the depths of surface soil (Table 3).
Table 3. Soil samples observed to consist in above heavy metal measurements
|
Referring
to analyse results given above, element of iron is relatively in high levels
in garden of Mehmet Özakdenizli and this data indicated, 6.10 % maximum level
of condensation. Iron element is founded to be increasing in condensation
through under surface horizons indicating 1.surface wash of soil, 2. mine
plantation as the source of this character of condensation . In general iron
concentration at this type of soil is found to be at 2.00-3.50 % dispersal
levels. In previously covered research studies at the direct mine wastes, iron
concentration is founded to be 14.77 %.
The
level of copper on the researched soil is definitely in higher concentration
than the accepted average values 5-110 ppm of
this kind of soil. Accept the garden of
Özdemir Şamlıdağ there is a definite copper pollution of soil.
The
level of manganese concentration
is in higher values than the 200-600 ppmlevels of this kind of soil.
Likewise,
cobalt level is in higher concentration according to analyse results
considering the expected 15 ppm level at
surface soil.
Average
dispersal concentration of lead at the lithosphere is 16.0 ppm but analyse
results indicate a general higher level. An accumulation of lead at the
surface soil is definitely existing as sample analyse from the garden of Altan
Öksüz is giving the result of 45.0 ppm lead element. This is because of
organic material holding the lead in surface soil.
Like
lead element chrome has a tendency to accumulate at biologically rich humus
soil and indicates a concentration at the surface soil that is 25.90 ppm at
some surface layers.
Referring
to analyse results on water sample reactions (PH) it is slight acidic at
Gemikonagi and slight alcaline at upper
parts of the same area. Electrical permeability specifications determined by
cation and anion dispersal, there
is a concentration of Na+ cation and relevantly SO4 and
CI ions concentration in waters used by Altan Oksuz, Rayif Altıner and Mehmet
Ozakdenizli. Likewise in all these three samples there is a pollution of
evaporation remnant. The seawater indicates a very profound pollution with all
specifications. (Table 4).
Table 4.
(Continuing). Some chemical analyse results in water samples
![]() |
In
water samples from the bottom sluice at the very low section of Gemikonagi
puddle, iron (Fe) 0.17ppm, copper (Cu) 0.282 ppm, manganese (Mn) 0.168
ppm.,zinc (Zn) 0.200 ppm., cadmium (Cd)
0.0029 ppm., cobalt (Co) 0.033 ppm., aluminium (Al ) 0.407 ppm. data is
maintained as analyse results while very low concentration of lead and chrome
is defined. According to these analyse results there is a pollution of copper
from CMC wastes in water (Figure 16).
|
|
|
Figure 15. View of CMC wastes area |
Figure 16. Reddish colour from iron, yellowish from sulphur in CMC area |
According to heavy elements concentration dispersal results maintained
from the leaves of particular plants, boran is found to be most condense in
the orange leaves and 31.1 ppm; magnesium in bean leaves and 0.66 ppm; iron in
bean leaves and 175.0 ppm, manganese in cabbage leaves 141.0 ppm, zinc is bean
leaves and 27.0 ppm, copper in bean leaves 24.2 ppm, molybdean at level of
microamount in all samples, cobalt in cabbage leaves 4.95 ppm, chrome in
orange leave 26.0 ppm, nicel in mandarin and bean leaves and 5.3 ppm are the
identified data (Table 6).
According to above data there is a condensed accumulation of iron in
bean leaves. Consentration of copper in cabbage and mandarin leaves are nearly
reaching the level of toxic while exceeding in orange and bean. Chrome is
found to be 26 ppm in leaves of orange and as this level is higher than the
5-20 ppm criteria, chrome exceeds the acceptable level. When we consider lead
dispersal in plants, lead in cabbage is lower but in bean is higher than 5-20
ppm criteria while the lead in other plants are in this spectrum. So there is
lead pollution in plants also.
![]() |
CONCLUSION
Lefke as a harbour city and its' nearby inland areas. Mediterranean
coastlines loose visual and functional qualities due to CMC mine wastes
pollution .This problem extends the boarders of Lefke, North Cyprus Turkish
Republic or another part of Cyprus but reaches up to region wide level
consisting in the Mediterranean coastline boarders. Likewise a global approach
rather than a local seeking for financial and logistic support at the
international arena would be the most intelligent and professional attitude in
handing this problem. Thus, referring to "polluter pays" environment
ethic principle, intense international enforcement to activate regulations for
pressures on CMC must be the urgent and prior duty. This problem should also be
transferred to international civil initiative and court in order to reach long
term results and not to encounter such kind of experiences further more.
REFERENCES
1.
A. & M. Engineering and Environmental Services, Inc., 1997. Report of
Preliminary Investigation and Recommendations, Gemikonağı Processing and
Mining Area Gemikonağı, Northern Cyprus. Oklahoma, U. S. A.
2.
Black, C. A., 1965. Methods of Soil
Analysis. Part 2. American Society of Agronomy, Inc., Publisher, Madison, U. S.
A.
3. Chen, Z. S., 1991. Water, Air and soil Pollution. 1991, Metals in Soils, Water, Plants and Animals. Proceedings of an International Conference, Orlando, Florida April 30 - May 3, 1990. Deparment of Agricultural Chemistry National Taiwan University Taipei, 10764. Taiwan.
4.
Merck, 1973. Die Untersuchung von Wasser. E. Merck. Darmsadt.
5.
Slavin, W., 1968. Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy. Interscience
Publishers. Newyork, London, Sydney.