LAYOUT: Splash page layout is cute, simple, but not very original. The main layout is very cute and easy to navigate, however toward the right edge of the frame (where the text is) the text is hard to read, especially where the text is coloured or where there are links (in purple). On your awards page, the width of one of the columns does not match the rest of the table and looks a bit odd. The text on the pages looks just a tad sloppy due to so much being in bold, but if it were not, it would be almost impossible to read the text. Finally, having a site that will not allow Netscape or AOL does limit the people who can view it by quite a bit. You may want to make another version that people can go to if they have Netscape or AOL. I am not quite sure why you have so many links pages (3 in total), especially since many of them are repeated. It is nice that the lyric pages open in a new window. On your MIDIs page, it might look better if all the tables were centered in the middle of the page.
CONTENT: you have a decent amount of content. However, to keep people coming back, you really need more content, things that change often (and let people know they change often…incentive to come back!), or both! You have quiz results! Oi! Some of them are ones that I have not taken! Yay you!
ORIGINALITY: I really like the fact that the music plays on the lyrics page. That is something that I have yet to see! It would be better if you had an originally designed layout rather than a pre-made one. I really appreciate the work that people go through to create layouts. I know from experience how time consuming and difficult it can be.
EFFORT: The effort is there. The site needs a few adjustments, is all. Your points for effort would have been higher had you created your own layout, however.
RANDOM: I definitely like the fact that you gave credit to all the review sites! Kudos for that!
TOTAL: 148 of 200
GRADE: B-