| 1992 | - | Miami | Tulane | Florida | ||
| 1993 | - | Miami | Notre Dame | Kansas | Florida | |
| 1994 | - | Miami | Notre Dame | Florida | ||
| 1995 | - | Miami | UCF | Florida | ||
| 1996 | - | Miami | Southern Miss | Florida | ||
| 1997 | - | Miami | USC | Florida | ||
| 1998 | - | Miami | USC | Texas A&M | Florida | |
| 1999 | - | Miami | La Tech | Florida | ||
| 2000 | - | Miami | BYU | Louisville | Florida | |
| 2001 | - | Miami | UAB | Florida | ||
| 2002 | - | Miami | Notre Dame | Louisville | Florida | Iowa State |
| 2003 | - | Miami | Notre Dame | Colorado | Florida | |
| 2004 | - | Syracuse | UAB | Florida | ||
| 2005 | - | Syracuse | The Citadel | Florida | ||
| 2006 | - | Rice | Troy | W. Michigan | Florida | |
| 2007 | - | Colorado | Alabama | UAB | Florida | |
| 2008 | - | Colorado | Nevada | Florida | ||
| 2009 | - | BYU | Florida | |||
| 2010 | - | BYU | Oklahoma | Florida | ||
| 2011 | - | Air Force | Oklahoma | Florida | ||
| 2012 | - | Air Force | West Virginia | Florida | ||
| 2013 | - | West Virginia | Florida |