THE Duke of Westminster has become
embroiled in a row over a decision to reroute a proposed
motorway around his private hunting grounds in southern
Spain.
The decision, which will add up to £80 million to the
construction costs, was taken by the Minister of Public
Works, who was a guest on the 36,000-acre estate last
year. Other recent visitors have included King Juan
Carlos, bankers, industrialists and members of the
European nobility.
Local people and environmentalists are furious and
flatly dismiss the ministry’s claim that the rerouting
is to protect the endangered imperial eagle and two
other rare birds. That, they say, is merely an excuse
for preserving “the hunting estate of a feudal lord”.
The duke, Britain’s richest man with an estimated
fortune of £4.75 billion, spent £2 million two years ago
on buying a ten-year lease for La Garganta, Spain’s
largest private sporting estate, from the Duke of
Bavaria.
The estate straddles the Castilla La Mancha-Andalucia
border and is regarded as one of Western Europe’s last
truly wild landscapes, a harsh but beautiful area of
forests and mountains where guests can hunt deer, wild
boar and red-legged partridge.
As an addition to his portfolio — which includes 300
prime acres of Belgravia and Mayfair, estates in
Lancashire, Cheshire and Scotland and land and property
in America, Canada, Australia and France — it cannot be
beaten.
But there is a drawback. The AVE, the high-speed
railway linking Madrid, the capital, with Seville, runs
through the centre of La Garganta. Admittedly, the
bullet-like trains do so in the blink of an eye, but the
prospect of a much noisier intruder emerged last year
when the Ministry of Public Works announced the
construction of a toll motorway linking Toledo with
Córdoba. The logical route was beside the AVE, where the
greatest environmental consequences had already been
incurred. The respected Spanish Society of Ornithology
and the Centre for the Conservation of Nature both
concurred.
The alternative route provisionally approved by the
ministry will still shadow the AVE, but, when it arrives
in the vicinity of the Duke of Westminster’s estate, it
will make a sudden detour eastwards, skirting La
Garganta and passing through the town of Fuencaliente,
before curving west again to rejoin the railway line.
Residents and property-owners along the proposed detour
have joined local environmentalists in denouncing the
decision, which will bring no benefits to the region as
there will be no exit.
They observed pointedly that Francisco Álvarez
Cascos, the Public Works Minister, enjoys a spot of
shooting and was a guest at La Garganta last year.
Sources on the estate say that the minister is expected
again next month for the partridge season.
The ministry insists that its decision was made
“solely for environmental reasons” to avoid disturbing
the nesting areas of the imperial eagle, black stork and
black vulture.
Opponents note that the new and longer route via
Fuencarral passes through equally sensitive countryside
that, three years ago, under European legislation, was
given the twin status of specially protected zone for
birds and area of community interest.
They also point out that four months after the
Spanish Society of Ornithology had recommended that the
motorway should run parallel with the AVE railway line,
it had a change of heart, having learnt that the duke’s
estate was home to “two pairs of black stork, 20 black
vultures and three imperial eagles”. For groups such as
the Association of the Sierra Madrona and Ecologists in
Action, the presence of these protected species is no
more than “an excuse”.
Francisco Diaz Buenestado, a vocal opponent, told
The Times: “It doesn’t make sense and anyone
would agree just by looking at the map of the two
routes. Creating a new corridor which would be only 12km
(7.5 miles) at its widest will produce a barrier effect
for species already on their way to extinction, such as
the lynx and the wolf.
“It will affect one of Europe’s most important bat
refuges and endanger at least 12 rare plant species.
What’s more, country rangers have found the nests of all
three types of rare birds in this area, the same ones
that the ministry has based its decision upon for not
going through La Garganta. A lot of things do not add up
and you have to conclude that this decision has been
influenced by unknown pressures.”