Setlists

11/27/04 - The Reader's Cafe
 
Set I:  Tragedy Impending --> Return, Say It Ain't So --> Hits From the Bong# --> Water From Your Hands, Alive Tonight, 9-Ball Monkey, Magic Carpet Ride --> Way Down North --> Ole'

Set II:  I Want A New Drug --> Ghostbusters Theme --> I Want A New Drug --> Fifty Reasons, Johnny's Favorite Island, Slow Is the Night --> House Party, Scratch 'Dat Belly, Just What I Needed*^, Jeff's Song --> Take Me Out*$ --> Jeff's Song, Float
 
 
 *First time played
#with Dave Toner on vocals
 ^The Cars cover
 $Franz Ferdinand cover

7/17/04 - Private Party (All Acoustic)
 
Set I:  Casey Jones, Admiration, Psycho Killer, Softcore Frog Porn II, Return, 9-Ball Monkey, Hey Johnny Park!, Receding Edge of the Sun, Magic Carpet Ride# --> Water From Your Hands --> Magic Carpet Ride, Wish You Were Here --> Haley's Eyes, Say It Ain't So, 50 Reasons

Set II:  Raphael --> Float, Farmhouse, Russian Song, Slow is the Night --> Blue Haiku, Ole', Sample In a Jar*^
 
 
 *First time played
#with "Smoke on the Water" and "The Beautiful People" teases
 ^Phish cover
 

7/10/04 - The Reader's Cafe' (w/ opening act Anna Christie)
 
Set I (acoustic):  Return, Everything Undone Intro --> Water From Your Hands, Rocky Racoon, Farmhouse, Dustpan & Broom --> I Could Have Lied*#, Float, Wish You Were Here*^--> Haley's Eyes, 50 Reasons, Hey Johnny Park!

Set II:  Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band*^^ --> Way Down North, 9-Ball Monkey, Casey Jones*$, Russian Song --> A Day in the Life*^^
 
 
 *First time played
#Red Hot Chili Peppers cover
 ^Pink Floyd cover
 ^^The Beatles cover
 $Grateful Dead cover

1/10/04 - The Reader's Cafe'
 
Set I:  Admiration, 50 Reasons, Softcore Frog Porn--> Molecular Hoagie II#-->Softcore Frog Porn, Psycho Killer, Return --> Monster In My Closet* --> Rock & Roll part II^ --> Johnny's Favorite Island, 9-Ball Monkey, A Maj. Jam, Scratch 'Dat Belly*, Alive Tonight

Set II:  Sunlight^^--> Hey Ya*$ --> Why Don't We Do It In The Road, Everything Undone, Softcore Frog Porn II, Float, Two Steps Behind## --> She Came In Through The Bathroom Window, Way Down North, Tragedy Impending, House Party
 
 
 *First time played
#Last played 1/21/00
 ^Last played 6/9/00
 ^^Last played 1/12/01
 $Outkast cover
 ##Last played 7/28/00

12/27/03 - The Ho Jo Ho Christmas Show (with "In The Light" and "The Sessions")
 
Set I:  Johnny's Favorite Island, Way Down North, Slow Is the Night --> Return, Jeff's Song# --> Legend of Zelda Theme --> Jeff's Song --> Tetris Theme*--> Jeff's Song --> Super Mario Bros. Theme --> Jeff's Song, House Party, 9-Ball Monkey, Interstate Love Song, Receding Edge of the Sun, Tragedy Impending*, Float, Russian Song, Alive Tonight, 50 Reasons --> Ole'
 
 
 *First time played
 #Upon hearing the keyword, "rifle", the crowd shouted "Holy Schnikies!" because Adam was planning to kill Jeff

12/20/03 - The Reader's Cafe - All Acoustic Show
 
Set I:  Farmhouse*#, Water From Your Hands, Return, Verse Chorus Verse*$, Rocky Racoon*%, 9-Ball Monkey, Interstate Love Song*^, Legend of Zelda Theme --> Raphael, Slow is the Night, Receding Edge of the Sun*##, I'm So Tired*% --> A Maj. Jam, Amber*$$, Haley's Eyes, Warning Sign*^^, Cardoor Blues*, Billy Breathes*#, Dustpan & Broom, Hey, Johnny Park!*@, House Party, 50 Reasons
 
 
 *First time played
#Phish cover
 $Nirvana cover
 %Beatles cover
 ^Stone Temple Pilots cover
 ##Opal cover
 $$311 cover
 ^^Coldplay cover
 @Foo Fighters cover

11/28/03 - Plymouth Rockshow
 
Set I:  Cock-knocker, Way Down North, 9-Ball Monkey--> Float, Water From Your Hands, Ole'--> Hits From the Bong#--> Johnny's Favorite Island, Slow Is the Night --> Syphilitic Iguana, Alive Tonight

Set II:  Return, Jeff's Song --> 7.5*^ --> Jeff's Song--> A Maj. Jam --> Psycho Killer*$, Softcore Frog Porn, Everything Undone, Russian Song, Say It Ain't So, House Party
 
 
 *First time played
#Dave Toner on vocals
 ^Opal cover (members of Opal took the stage to perform)
 $Talking Heads cover

8/19/03 - Private Party
 
Set I:  House Party, Admiration, 9-Ball Monkey--> Float, Say It Ain't So, Way Down North, Johnny's Favorite Island, Slow Is The Night--> Water From Your Hands, A Maj. Jam--> Softcore Frog Porn, Why Don't We Do It In The Road#, Russian Song, Haley's Eyes, I Want A New Drug--> Ghostbusters Theme --> I Want A New Drug --> Return, Magic Carpet Ride, Alive Tonight, Smarty Shark*^, Hot In Herre, Jeff's Song, Ole'
 
 
 *First time played
#Justin on drums/Trox on guitar
 ^Mammoth T6 song/ performed only by Jeff & Tim

8/01/03 - The Reader's Cafe
 
Set I:  Slow Is the Night, Space Oddity*# --> Johnny's Favorite Island, Alive Tonight --> 9-Ball Monkey --> Brain Damage##--> Float, Way Down North

Set II:  House Party, I Want A New Drug% --> Ghostbusters Theme* --> I Want A New Drug --> A Maj. Jam --> Dazed and Confused*^ --> Return --> Dustpan & Broom* --> Jeff's Song --> She Hates Me --> Jeff's Song --> Russian Song --> Ole'
 
 
 *First time played
#David Bowie cover
 ##Pink Floyd cover
 %Huey Lewis & The News cover
 ^Led Zeppelin cover

5/30/03 - The Reader's Cafe
 
Set I:  Return, Admiration, Johnny's Favorite Island*, Raphael* --> Legend of Zelda Theme*, Water From Your Hands --> Why Don't We Do It In The Road*# --> Water From Your Hands, Float, Jeff's Song

Set II:  Say It Ain't So*^, House Party* --> Alive Tonight, Slow is the Night --> 50 Reasons, 9-Ball Monkey --> Softcore Frog Porn##
 
 
 *First time played
#Beatles cover
 ^Weezer cover
 ##Justin played drums for solo/Trox on guitar


5/17/03 - Hanover Spring Fling
 
Set I:  Hanover Alma Mater*, 9-Ball Monkey, Alive Tonight, Slow Is The Night, Water From Your Hands --> Mean Mr. Mustard --> Float --> Warning: This Song May Cause Seizures#, Ole', Everything Undone, Return^
 
 *First time played
#Last played 1/21/00
 ^With Eric Yowaiski on acoustic guitar
 

3/22/03 - The Reader's Cafe
 
Set I:  Blue Haiku, Admiration, Slow Is The Night, Way Down North^, 9-Ball Monkey$ --> Float, Hot In Herre, Haley's Eyes, Magic Carpet Ride --> Hits From The Bong^^
 
Set II:  Softcore Frog Porn#, She Hates Me##, Return, 50 Reasons, Blitzkreig Bop, Ole', Syphilitic Iguana, Alive Tonight, Russian Song
 
 ^with a Jeff rap
$ended with a vocal jam into Float
  ^^With Dave Toner on vocals
 #all members played blindfolded
##lyrics changed from 'she hates me' to 'the reader's cafe'

1/3/03 - Private Party
 
Set I:  Magic Carpet Ride --> Ole', Slow is the Night, Russian Song, 50 Reasons, Jeff's Song* -->Hits FromThe Bong$ -->Jeff's Song**-->Hot In Herre^ --> Jeff's Song
 
Set II:  She Hates Me, Float, Softcore Frog Porn, Alive Tonight, Greensleeves, Return --> Way Down North, Syphilitic Iguana
 
 *Jeff tells a story about a camping trip involving the smoking of a bong, which leads into 'Hits'
**Jeff's story continues and he talks about how incredibly hot it is..in herre...prompts Nelly's "Hot in Herre"
  $With Dave Toner on vocals
 ^ With Justin on bass, Jeff on vocals only

12/27/02 - HMS Auditorium
 
Set I:  Hot In Herre*&, Way Down North, Slow is the Night, Water From Your Hands^, Ole'#, Haley's Eyes#, Return, She Hates Me, 50 Reasons*, 9-Ball Monkey, Softcore Frog Porn, Alive Tonight, Russian Song, Float
 
*First time played
&Nelly cover.  Justin on bass, Jeff on vocals
^Justin breaks a string, switches to acoustic
#w/ Justin on acoustic

11/30/02 - Bada Bing's Pool Hall
 
Set I:  Ole', Syphilitic Iguana --> 9 Ball Monkey, Admiration, She Hates Me*% --> Way Down North --> Water From Your Hands**
               
Set II:  Return, Alive Tonight, Slow Is the Night, Naked In the Rain*^, Float, Softcore Frog Porn --> Big Wheel# --> Drums --> Softcore Frog Porn, Plane Crash*&, Blitzkreig Bop*~, Russian Song, Jeff's Song --> Hits From the Bong --> Jeff's Song
 
E:  Magic Carpet Ride --> Blue Haiku
 
 *First time played
**Technical difficulties/had to end set early
 %Puddle of Mudd cover
 ^Red Hot Chili Peppers cover
 #Justin left stage, Andrew Betlyon played guitar
 &moe. cover
 ~Ramones cover
^^Dave Toner on vocals
***First show with Adam Jarrett as a member of the band***

8/16/02 - The Reader's Cafe
 
Set I:  Russian Song, Slow is the Night^, Softcore Frog Porn II, Admiration, 9-Ball Monkey, Float^, Amaj. Jam^ --> Magic Carpet Ride^, Ole'**
 
Set II:  Alive Tonight, Everything Undone, Way Down North, Softcore Frog Porn, You Never Give Me Your Money*# --> Mean Mr. Mustard*# --> Polythene Pam*# --> She Came In Through The Bathroom Window *# --> Golden Slumbers*# --> Carry That Weight*# --> The End*#, Cock-knocker, Everybody ##, Water From Your Hands, Return, Syphilitic Iguana%
 
* First time played
** The input on Jeff's bass screwed up, had to take a setbreak while Jeff ran home to get Chakatana
 ^ Let crowd decide song
 # Beatles' song cover
## Changed the lyrics from "everybody shut the fuck up" to "everybody hug your neighbor". During Jeff's solo, Tim went
   into the crowd to hug everyone, and Jimmy O' Connor jumped on the keyboards for a short solo.
 % Jam ended with an improvised "Stand By Me" vocal jam, and the song ended with Justin screaming in orgasm.

7/20/02 - Bada Bing's Pool Hall (Mark Lawrence Opened)
 
Set I:  Slow Is the Night, Magic Carpet Ride^, Ole', Return, Jeff's Song^^#, Cock-knocker, Admiration, 9-Ball Monkey, Float
 
Set II:  Alive Tonight, Russian Song, Water From Your Hands, Everybody, Softcore Frog Porn, Everything Undone, When I Awoke*, Way Down North##$, Syphilitic Iguana##
 
 ^With "That's Odd" jam
^^Jeff tells a story of swimming to a Codorus island and 'someone' drowning...somewhere mentions ordering chinese food which  
   prompts a 'chinese jam'
 #"Hits From the Bong" tease
 *First time played
##Justin breaks a string and has to take time out to string another one up...which prompts a Jeff & Tim jam
 $Jam segues into The Turtles' "So Happy Together"

7/13/02 - Bada Bing's Pool Hall
 
Set I:  Russian Song --> Cock-knocker*, Admiration, Ole',, Jeff's Song -> Water From Your Hands, Everything Undone*, Bathtub Gin, Haley's Eyes, Alive Tonight*, Syphilitic Iguana, 9-Ball Monkey
 
Set II:  Slow Is the Night*, Magic Carpet Ride, Everybody*, Return*, Softcore Frog Porn, Undone (The Sweater Song)*#, Sunlight, Float, Amaj. Jam, Blue Haiku, Way Down North
 
E: Expires Tuesday
 
*First time played
#Weezer song cover

12/28/01 - McSherrystown Fire Hall (opened for Devolver)
 
Set I:  Way Down North, A Maj. Jam --> Float, Admiration, Magic Carpet Ride, Water From Your Hands, Gone*^, Bathtub Gin, Softcore Frog Porn, 9-Ball Monkey, Russian Song, Ole'

*First time played
^Ben Folds cover

11/24/01 - The Reader's Cafe (Off-White Opened)
 
Set I:  Ole' --> Syphilitic Iguana, Admiration, Magic Carpet Ride, Haley's Eyes, 9-Ball Monkey*, Russian Song, Expires Tuesday, Mexico*^#, Softcore Frog Porn, Float, Bathtub Gin, Water From Your Hands, Jeff's Song --> Way Down North

*First time played
^w/ Adam Jarrett on acoustic & Justin on vocals
#Incubus cover

8/17/01 - The Reader's Cafe
 
Set I:  Ole', Jeff's Song, Water From Your Hands, Admiration, Bathtub Gin, Float, Haley's Eyes, Russian Song, All Mixed Up, Softcore Frog Porn, Magic Carpet Ride, Way Down North, Syphilitic Iguana


8/2/01 - Private Party
 
Setlist Unknown

7/15/01 - Hanover Battle of the Bands*
 
Setlist Unknown
*Took 1st place

7/14/01 - The Moose Lodge
 
Setlist Unknown

5/27/01 -  Delone Battle of the Bands
 
Set I:  Fun & Games* --> Way Down North* --> Magic Carpet Ride, Water From Your Hands, Float, Admiration, Russian Song, Ole'
 
Set II (encore presentation):  Softcore Frog Porn, Bathtub Gin, Craig Lillich Jam*, Jeff's Song,
 
E:  Blue Haiku^
 
*First time played
^w/ Sesame St. jam

3/27/01 - The 8x10 Club  (opened for The Speed Kings)
 
Set I:  Ole' --> Magic Carpet Ride, Admiration, Water From Your Hands, Russian Song, Softcore Frog Porn, Float, Haley's Eyes, Jeff's Song --> Ole' Reprise
 

1/12/01 - The Reader's Cafe
 
Set I:  Happy Birthday^, Ole'*, Magic Carpet Ride, Admiration, Softcore Frog Porn, Haley's Eyes, Russian Song --> Ole' Reprise*, Water From Your Hands, Syphilitic Iguana
 
Set II:  Sunlight* --> Bathtub Gin, All Mixed Up*^^ --> Ole' Reprise, Float, Blue Haiku, The Man Who Sold The World, Softcore Frog Porn II, Jeff's Song# --> Ole' Reprise
 
*First time played
^Ann Kincaid (Miss Hanover) announces Josh's birthday
^^311 Cover
#With "elbow" teases

11/25/00 - McAllister Inn, Hanover
 
Setlist Unknown

7/28/00 - Hanover Battle of the Bands
 
Set I:  Admiration, Bathtub Gin, Water From Your Hands, Haley's Eyes, Jeff's Song
 
Set II:  Softcore Frog Porn II --> Two Steps Behind --> Softcoree Frog Porn, Blue Haiku
 

6/10/00 - Private Party
 
Setlist Unknown

6/9/00 - The Reader's Cafe (opened for Opal)
 
Set I:  Rock & Roll (part II)*# --> Admiration, Light My Fire, Two Steps Behind, Bathtub Gin, Haley's Eyes, Simpsons Jam* --> Softcore Frog Porn, Syphilitic Iguana^, Water From Your Hands*, Jeff's Song, Blue Haiku**
 
* First time performed
#Gary Glitter cover
^With 'Come Out and Play' tease
**Played with Opal, somewhat of an 'african' jam

5/27/00 - HHS Bandfest
 
Set I:  Optimus, Light My Fire*#, Two Steps Behind, Syphilitic Iguana, Bathtub Gin, Haley's Eyes*, Softcore Frog Porn, Blue Haiku^, Jeff's Song*
 
*First time played
#The Doors cover
^w/ Sesame St. jam

1/21/00 - The Reader's Cafe
 
Set I:  Blue Haiku, Longview*#, Smob, Foxy Lady*##$, Meeting of the Nighttime Sloths, Two Steps Behind, Expires Tuesday, Warning: This Song May Cause Seizures
 
Set II:  Optimus, The Man Who Sold the World, Pinhead*^, Admiration*, Bathtub Gin, Softcore Frog Porn, Molecular Hoagie II*, Indubitably*, Syphilitic Iguana --> Blue Haiku Reprise
 
*First time played
#Green Day cover
##Jimi Hendrix cover
 $ w/ Adam Jarrett
 ^Ramones cover

12/3/99 - Mark Hansford's
 
Set I:  Optimus*, Molecular Hoagie, Smob, The Man Who Sold the World*^, Expires Tuesday
 
Setbreak:  Wild Thing*#
 
Set II:  Softcore Frog Porn*, Two Steps Behind*, Meeting of the Nighttime Sloths, Bathtub Gin *##, Warning: This Song May Cause Seizures, Syphilitic Iguana
 
*First time played
^David Bowie cover
#w/ Steve Musser on guitar
##Phish cover

8/20/99 - The Reader's Cafe (opened for Opal)
 
Set I:  Smob*# , Molecular Hoagie* --> Expires Tuesday*, Warning: This Song May Cause Seizures*, Syphilitic Iguana*, Blue Haiku
 
*First time played
#With Mario Bros. Jam

5/27/99 - HHS Talent Show(won 2nd place)
 
Set I:  Blue Haiku*
 
*First time played