Generation X – Considerations for Ministry

 

This paper was written and presented for the Costas Consultation: The Coming Church! The neXt Generation and Global Christianity sponsored by the Boston Theological Institute.  It serves as an introductory review of some of the basic issues and complications in young adult ministry.  It is by no means exhaustive.

           

 

Introduction.  “Generation X” and “young adults” are terms used to identify the generation born after the Baby Boomers, born between 1965-1979: 18-35 year olds.  They are not flocking to churches—especially liberal, white denominations like the United Church of Christ (UCC). 

The usual approach to motivate churches to outreach to this generation is: “If your congregation is alive in the year 2025, most of its governing board members will be [Generation X].”1  This speculation fails to recognize that young adults have needs that are not being met by the current 1950’s style church.  It manipulates young adults into perpetuating the church system that they already are fed up with and are not attending.

Generation X is unique.  And the average church in the United States today has done little to address the issues and concerns of the young adults who have been shaped in this new era.

 

Community/Diversity.  Among all young adults I’ve met, universally the number one reason to go to church is not God; it is community.2  When in the workplace, and often times in a campus setting, there is a real sense of isolation and distance from peers—making friends is hard.  Outside of the clubs and bars, there are few structured places for people to meet their peers.

“Communities that are formed based on common interests and background are effortless to create.  However, with increased diversity of the population and the mobility of the people in this country, the ‘natural’ communities are harder to either find or form, resulting in many individuals feeling isolated and alone.”3

Those who have returned to or stayed in the church have found a place where intentional community is being developed.  On the other hand, many young adults have left the church, because it fails to be an intentional community, or fails to be the right kind of intentional community in their eyes. The church does not foster or address the issues of difference and diversity that are common in the experiences of younger generations.

 

Empowerment.  Young adults share a sense of overwhelming stress.  Whether it is the pressure of standardized testing, college applications, or finding a decent job, we have learned that we are responsible for our futures.  But despite that responsibility, young adults have never been empowered to take the controls.  Generation W—our parent’s generation—runs the political system of the United States.4  Without agency, without being empowered, young adults have had to find other ways to seek fulfillment and independence. We are skeptical of authority figures that attempt to control us.

 

Authority/Truth.  Generation X is a skeptical group.  We appreciate a space that allows us to wrestle with our own relationship to the divine.5  The old methodology of being told what to think is outdated and ineffective.6  “We naturally question the authority and guidance of our elders and of society in general, which in our past have born little but false promises.”7  As a result, Generation X is not looking for a new authority, or even a correct and reliable authority.  We are looking for a place that honors and lifts up the personal experiences of each community member.  Meaning is derived from the expression and conversation about individual experiences and perspectives.

 

Fulfillment.  For the Baby Boomers, fulfillment came via the perfect career, the pursuit thereof, or financial independence (which sometimes is the criteria for the perfect career).8  Gen X children saw their parents grasp frantically at these goals and fail to find fulfillment.  We saw our parents or our friends’ parents divorce; our perspective on “true love” has been affected accordingly.  Generation X seeks fulfillment in new places: relationships (romantic and friendship), spirituality (often over and against organized religion) and in the combination of multiple pursuits (jobs, hobbies, social activities and activism).  We are attempting to break away from the old paths of fulfillment, which we have seen fail for the generation before us.

 

Technology.  Pam Fickenscher claims the computer is the biggest dividing factor between the generations.9  Generation X knows how to use a computer, Generation W is still figuring out how to program the VCR.  The computer has transformed communication and the workplace.  Young adults are a more employable and also more expendable labor force.  With email, chat rooms and the internet, young adults can communicate across cultural, national and political boundaries.  With the added level of anonymity, Generation X has begun to talk frankly and honestly about topics their parents never could.

 

Sex/Relationships/Sexuality.  Of the many topics that create stress for young adults, arguably the most salient is sex and sexual relationships.  The Fox show Temptation Island, is adequate proof of that.  After free love in the 60s and 70s, the Gay Rights Movement beginning in 1969 and HIV/AIDS of the 80s, the new sexual landscape is daunting.  Climbing divorce rates only increase the levels of uncertainty.  What are the rules?  Who are the role models?  With a market-driven-emphasis on sexual pleasure, where is the place for emotional connection?  Spiritual energy and sexual energy are both powerful forces; the structures that have guided both (the church and the institution of marriage) have lost their authority.10  This overwhelming freedom is too much for one person to navigate alone.  But the church remains a place where spiritual exploration (outside the bounds of the tradition or denomination) is not encouraged.  And sexual exploration and discussion rarely enters a church setting in any meaningful way.

 

Racial Bias.  It is important for me to place the disclaimer on the present analysis.  All of the books that I have reviewed, all the information that has shaped my thoughts are coming from a middle-class, white perspective.  Most of the books come from evangelical, fundamentalist traditions.  As a consequence this analysis fails to take into consideration the obvious differences of a minority/oppressed status.  Non-white persons in the U.S. and lower-class people will have a drastically different take on the present discussions, especially on the topics of empowerment, fulfillment and community/diversity.  Women will also have a different relationship to the present analysis, as will gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people.  This broad analysis fails to take into meaningful account any of these or other types of difference.

It is important to remember that the rather young experiment of desegregation in the United States has yet to meaningfully impact the church.  Most churches remain highly segregated institutions and communities.

 

Conclusion.  The present analysis also fails to take into more serious consideration the theological and ministerial applications of this new generation.  The first step in applying these ideas to ministry is to uncover the ways in which the current church community perpetuates the division among the generations.  Second, the local church must not rely exclusively on the research of books and reports, which by necessity utilize broad, sweeping generalizations.  Local clergy and community members must reach out and talk with the people in their communities, young and old alike.  A dialogue must be initiated, and the young must be empowered to shape and control what their community will look like.

Notes

1 Net Results: “Involving More Young Adults,” a resource packet from 1995.

2 This observation comes from interviews with area students, church members and other contacts.  One-on-ones were conducted by Gregory Morisse, October 2000 continuing through May, 2001.

3 Law, Eric, H. E. (1996).  The Bush Was Blazing But Not Consumed.  Chalice Press.

4 Cox, Kristoffer (1998).  Gen X and God.  Tekna Books.

5 Morisse, One-on-ones.

6 This observation comes from Pam Fickenscher in her presentation on The Spirit Garage, a Gen X church in Minneapolis, MN.  The workshop was given at Evangelism Connections 2000, in St. Paul, MN; November 2000.

7 Cox, Gen X and God.

8 Cox, Gen X and God.

9 Fickenscher, Evangelism Connections 2000.

10 Morisse, One-on-ones.

 

Table of Contents.