UNIT TITLE: Learning from History-Success Arises From Defeat


Tacoma bridge swayingTacoma bridge falling


Author:  Jennifer Jordan
E-Mail Address: liftupthelord3@yahoo.com
School: Nathan Hale Middle School : Crestwood, Illinois
School Home Page URL: http://www.district130.org

THEME : Bridges in the Past and Future

BROAD CONCEPT:  Resourcefulness, Creativity, Perserverance, Wisdom,

GRADES:  6-8

INTEGRATED SUBJECTS:  Science, Mathematics, Writing, Reading, Social Science

UNIT GOALS AND PURPOSE:
Students will use prior knowledge and revise it to increase their understanding of bridges in today's society.  They will use technology and available print resources to determine how the structure of the bridge shows man's willingness to use available resources, while yet expanding their horizons to create stronger and more versatile structures.  Students will use their revised knowledge to create a book for intermediate level students.  

Evaluation will occur on an on-going basis with the review of the K-W-L with focus questions chart.  The completion of the five paragraph essay comparing two types of bridges will provide summative evaluative information, and the completion of a book and model bridge will provide performance-based evaluative information. 

TIME FRAME:

Activity One - Day 1                   Activity Two -Days 2 and 3        Activity Three - Day 4
Activity Four - Day 5                  Activity Five - Day 6             Activity Six - Day 7
Activity Seven - Day 8                 Activity Eight - Day 9            Activity Nine - Days 10 and 11
Acitivity Ten - Days 12 through 16     Activity Eleven - Days 17 and 18  Activity Tweleve - Days 19 through 24


OBJECTIVES:
In this lesson, students will:
MATERIALS:           paper fasteners (small) - 11 for each student
          scissors
          index cards (3" x 5") - 3 for each student
          single-hole punch
          K-W-L with focus questions chart (students will create during Activity One)
          graph paper (for scaled-drawing of model bridge)
          Computer
          Printer


STATE STANDARDS ADDRESSED BY THIS UNIT: Writing
3.A.3  Write compositions that contain complete sentences and effective paragraphs using English conven­tions.

3.C.3b  Using available technology, produce compositions and multimedia works for specified audiences.

Research
5.A.3a  Identify appropriate resources to solve problems or answer questions through research.

5.A.3b  Design a project related to contemporary issues (e.g., real-world math, career development, community service) using multiple sources.

5.B.3b  Identify, evaluate and cite primary sources. 

5.C.3b  Prepare and orally present original work (e.g., poems, monologues, reports, plays, stories) supported by research.

5.C.3c  Take notes, conduct interviews, organize and report information in oral, visual and electronic formats.   

Math
ESTIMATION AND MEASUREMENT

7.A.3b  Apply the concepts and attributes of length, capacity, weight/mass, perimeter, area, volume, time, temperature and angle measures in practical situations.

7.C.3a  Construct a simple scale drawing for a given situation.  

GEOMETRY

9.B.3  Identify, describe, classify and compare two- and three- dimensional geometric figures and models according to their properties.

9.C.3a  Construct, develop and communicate logical arguments (informal proofs) about geometric figures and patterns.

9.C.3b  Develop and solve problems using geometric relationships and models, with and without the use of technology. 

DATA ANALYSIS AND PROBABILITY

10.A.3a   Construct, read and interpret tables, graphs (including circle graphs) and charts to organize and represent data.

10.B.3  Formulate questions (e.g., relationships between car age and mileage, average incomes and years of schooling), devise and conduct experiments or simulations, gather data, draw conclusions and communicate results to an audience using traditional methods and contemporary technologies.

Science
INQUIRY AND DESIGN

11.B.3c  Select the most appropriate design and build a prototype or simulation.  

11.B.3d  Test the prototype using available materials, instruments and technology and record the data.

11.B.3e  Evaluate the test results based on established criteria, note sources of error and recommend improvements.

11.B.3f  Using available technology, report the relative success of the design based on the test results and criteria.

CONCEPTS AND PRINCIPLES

12.D.3a  Explain and demonstrate how forces affect motion (e.g., action/reaction, equilibrium conditions, free-falling objects). 

SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY

13.A.3b  Analyze historical and contemporary cases in which the work of science has been affected by both valid and biased scientific practices.

13.B.3b  Identify important contributions to science and technology that have been made by individuals and groups from various cultures.

Technology
TECHNOLOGY PRODUCTIVITY TOOLS

Students use technology tools to enhance learning, increase productivity, and promote creativity.

Students use productivity tools to collaborate in construcuting technology-enhanced models, prepare publications, and produce other creative works.

TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH TOOLS

Students use technology to locate, evaluate, and collect information from a variety of sources.

Students use technology tools to process data and report results.

Students evaluate and select new information resources and technological innovations based on the appropriatenes for specific tasks.

N.C.T.M. STANDARDS ADDRESSED BY THIS UNIT:

Number and Operations
Compute fluently and make reasonable estimates

develop, analyze, and explain methods for solving problems involving proportions, such as scaling and finding equivalent ratios

Geometry
Use visualization, spatial reasoning, and geometric modeling to solve problems

recognize and apply geometric ideas and relationships in areas outside the mathematics classroom, such as art, science, and everyday life


Measurement
Understand measurable attributes of objects and the units, systems, and processes of measurement

understand both metric and customary systems of measurement

Apply appropriate techniques, tools, and formulas to determine measurements

select and apply techniques and tools to accurately find length, area, volume, and angle measures to appropriate levels of precision

solve problems involving scale factors, using ratio and proportion

Data Analysis and Probability
Formulate questions that can be addressed with data and collect, organize, and display relevant data to answer them

formulate questions, design studies, and collect data about a characteristic shared by two populations or different characteristics within one population

select, create, and use appropriate graphical representations of data, including histograms, box plots, and scatterplots


Problem Solving
build new mathematical knowledge through problem solving

solve problems that arise in mathematics and in other contexts

apply and adapt a variety of appropriate strategies to solve problems

monitor and reflect on the process of mathematical problem solving

STUDENT ACTIVITIES WHICH WILL PROMOTE ENGAGED LEARNING:

Activity One
Students will respond in their journal to the quote, "success arises from defeat".  The class will discuss what was written in the journals.  Using the overhead students will read the poem "The Tay Bridge Disaster" by William McGonagall (http://www.mcgonagall-online.org.uk/poems/pgdisaster.htm) and make connections between the quote and the poem.  The unit on bridges will be introduced.  In groups of two (which will remain the same when paired groups are required) the students will create and complete a K-W-L with focus questions chart about bridges using Microsoft Word.  They will respond to the following focus questions:

After the paired students have completed the chart, they will each print a copy of the chart, revise it during each activity of the unit, and finalize the chart at the end of the unit. 

Activity Two
As a class the students will watch two videos, "Big Cable Bridges" and "Awesome Bridges".  After viewing each video, the students will revise their K-W-L with focus questions chart.  Working in the same pairs as in activity one, students will visit the sites, "Building Big" (http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/buildingbig/bridge) and "Super Bridge" (http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bridge) , and complete the interactive activities ("Bridge Challenge" and "Build a Bridge", respectively).  After completing the activities the groups will revise their charts as needed.


Activity Three
Student pairs will use search engines and find information about bridge disasters and create a spreadsheet using Excel that includes the name of the bridge, the bridge's location, date of disaster, reason for disaster, and number of fatalities.  Then the students will compare the disasters in relation to the number of fatalities using a graph.

Activity Four
Using supplies, the internet, and the book titled Bridges by Etta Kaner (p. 18-19) student pairs will determine which basic geometric shape is stronger.  Using Microsoft Word they will write a brief write-up regarding their reasoning.  Students shuold look for examples of the determined stronger shape in the real world and cite several examples.

Activity Five
Student pairs will create a chart using Microsoft Word in which they list each bridge type, the descriptions of how forces act upon it (compression and tension), its general span (length), building materials, and its structure.  Each group will also create a chart using Microsoft Word relating each type of bridge, its advantages and its disadvantages. 

Activity Six
Using KidPix, paired students will create a glossary of bridge vocabulary.  The glossary must include the term, picture and definition. 

Activity Seven
Student pairs should go to the "Better Roads" (http://www.betterroads.com/articles/bridgeinv04.htm) site and use Excel to creat a spreadsheet and graph of the states comparing their number of total bridges.  Then the groups should create a graph of the states comparing their percentages of obsolete or deficient bridges.

Activity Eight
Students pairs will go to http://www.factophile.com/show.content?action=browse&catid=99 and create a spreadsheet of different bridge types with the longest span lengths.  Using real world examples, provide an estimate of what these span lengths are similar to.  For instance, if the longest beam bridge is 900 feet, then that would be about 3 football fields if the length of one is 300 feet.

Activity Nine
In pairs, students will determine two bridges they would like to compare and they will decide how they are going to conduct their individual research.  Students should individually use at least one tradebook, Encarta or the World Book Encyclopedia, and two web sites for each of the bridges.   Students should use search engines to search for their web sites.  During their research each student should be revising their charts.  When they have completed their research, the students should reconvene in their paired groups and complete a Venn Diagram comparing the two bridges.  They should complete the Venn Diagram using Inspiration.  Paired students will write a five paragraph paper using Microsoft Word in which they compare these two bridges.  They will use information from their Venn Diagram to complete this paper.

Activity Ten
The class will come together and be separated into six groups.  The class will decide how the students will be grouped.  Each group will be responsible for a specific bridge type: beam bridge, arch bridge, suspension bridge, cantilever bridge, cable-stayed bridge, and moveable bridge.  Each group has to create a book about the specific bridge using Powerpoint, KidPix, or Microsoft Word.  The book has to include a table of contents, glossary, pictures (photographs), visual explanations, and an index.  The content of the book should include the information from the focus quetions of the K-W-L chart.

Activity Eleven
Using tradebooks, Encarta, and web sites, student groups should create a timeline of their specific bridge type.  They should include its early history to present day.  Use the Time Liner 5.0 software.

Activity Twelve
Students will create a scaled-drawing of their specific bridge in relation to the model they will build using graph paper.  They can visit the following website for assistance, http://www.regentsprep.org/Regents/math/scale/Lscale.htm.  They will build a model of their bridge and choose their own materials (spaghetti, toothpicks, etc.).


SHARE YOUR IDEAS:

Student groups will create a book on a specific bridge type for the intermediate grades indicating what they have learned about the importance of bridges in our society.  They will include information relevant to their focus questions on their K-W-L chart, and have the opportunity to choose other information to include in the book.  Students must make sure that the book is written so that the younger students will understand it.  They must include a table of contents, pictures (photographs), visual explanation, glossary and index.  Along with a creative book, students will create a scaled-drawing of the bridge and a model.  Student groups will share their book, scaled-drawing and model with the class in a Powerpoint presentation.

POWERPOINT PRESENTATION RUBRIC
                                                Total Possible Points        Your Points
Creativity                                              25
Adequate participation in presentation                  25
Adequately depicted:
Book
Table of Contents                                       10
Content (includes information relevant to focus questions)              60
Glossary                                                10
Index                                                   10
Pictures/Photographs (minimum of 3)                     10
Visual explanations of terms/concepts                   10
Scaled-drawing
Correct ratios and proportions used                     15
Model
Discuss how model was made                              25
Discuss materials used                                  10
Discuss time taken to create                            10

TOTAL                                                  220                                   

STUDENT AND TEACHER ROLES:

Students will be explorers.  They will be conducting extensive research in which they will locate sites conducive to their inquiries.  By working in groups of two they will share information with one another, and when they come together as a class, they will serve as teachers to those who did not previously have that information.  Using the K-W-L with focus questions chart, students will continually reflect upon their discoveries.  They will integrate and share the knowledge that they have gleaned by creating a book for younger students.


The teacher will serve as a guide by providing suggestions and direction to the student groups as needed, such as key words to use when performing research with search engines.  For the essay the teacher will ask broad questions concerning the bridges so the students can receive minimum guidance as they construct their own knowledge.  The teacher will serve as a facilitator by encouraging the student groups to try other interactive activities available on the internet or in the tradebooks to further their understanding of the topic.

ADDITIONAL REFERENCE PRINT RESOURCES STUDENTS MAY USE :

World Book Enclyopedia

"Big Cable Bridges" video (produced by Segments of Knowledge Productions)

"Awesome Bridges" video (produced by Simitar Entertainment)

THE FOLLOWING BOOKS CONTAIN INFORMATION ABOUT THIS TOPIC:

Bridges: From My Side To Yours by Jan Adkins
How We Build Bridges by Neil Ardley
Bridges by Nicola Baxter
The Bridge Book by Polly Carter
Structures: Bridges by Andrew Dunn
Bridges!: Amazing Structures To Design, Build & Test by Carol A. Johmann and Elizabeth J. Rieth
Bridges by Etta Kaner
How Bridges Are Made by Jeremy Kingston
Bridges: A Project Book by Anne and Scott MacGregor
Math Projects Series: Building Toothpick Bridges by Jeanne Pollard
Bridges by Julie Richards
Bridges by Joy Richardson
Bridges by Cass R. Sandak
How Are They Built?: Bridges by Lynn M. Stone

The Brooklyn Bridge by Elizabeth Mann
The Golden Gate Bridge by Sharlene and Ted Nelson

Structures by Discovery Channel School Science
Designs in Science: Structures by Sally and Adrian Morgan
The Science of Structures by Janice Parker
Super Structures by Philip Wilkinson

Force & Motion by Peter Lafferty
Experiments With Motion by Salvatore Tocci

 

FOR ADDITIONAL ONLINE INFORMATION AND MEDIA PERTAINING TO THIS UNIT, TEACHERS MAY WANT TO USE THE FOLLOWING INTERNET ARTICLES:  

Title1: Brantacan Bridges

URL1: http://brantacan.co.uk/bridges.htm

Description1: This is a comprehensive site which includes photographs of various bridges, a chart with the lengths of the longest bridges of different types, and other important information.  It provides more detailed information about each bridge, including the longest bridge of a particular type, materials that are used to build the bridges, and the advantages and disadvantages of the main types of bridges.

  
Title2: 42 Explore - Bridge Building

URL2: http://42explore.com/bridge.htm

Description2: This site includes numerous web links that the teacher can use to suplement the unit on bridges.  A section on bridge webquests is also included.
   


Title3:
Engineering is Cool

URL3: http://www.engr.utexas.edu/wep/COOL/AcidRiver

Description3: This site provides activities, games, and terms related to bridges.  It also provides information about forces acting on various types of bridges, the three main types of bridges, famous bridges, bridge disasters, and types of engineering related to building bridges.
 


Title4:
Bridgepros

URL4: http://bridgepros.com

Description4: This site includes videos and news of current information about bridges.  There is information in regards to past, present and future bridge projects, and also a learning center with pertinent links.

   

Title5: Zome System Bridge Building Project

URL5: http://www.zometool.com/pdfs/bridge_building_project.pdf

Description5: This site includes an integrated unit lesson on bridges.

 

Title6: Building Model Bridges Following the Engineering Process

URL6: http://www.yale.edu/ynhti/curriculum/units/2001/5/01.05.04.x.html

Description6:This site includes a curriculum unit on building model bridges.
 
 
 

RELEVANT INFORMATION, STUDENTS WILL VISIT THE FOLLOWING WEB SITES:  Title1: Building Bridges 

URL1: http://www2.newton.mec.edu/~mike_sylvia/bridge/home.html

Purpose of Use1: Students will use this site to find information about various types of bridges and their forces.

Description1: This site includes information about the beam bridge, suspension bridge, arch bridge and truss bridge (cantilever) and the forces that act upon them.
  

Title2: Geometry of Bridge Construction 

URL2: http://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/jmac/rs/bridges.htm

Purpose of Use2: Students will use this site to locate information about various types of bridges and to gather photographs for their presentation.  They will also use this site for their timeline.

Description2: This site includes brief descriptions of the arch bridge, beam bridge, suspension bridge, cantilever bridge, and cable-stayed bridge.  It has photographs of various bridges, as well as the early history of bridge building.
 
 

Title3: Better Roads

URL3: http://www.betterroads.com/articles/bridgeinv04.htm

Purpose of Use3: Students will use this site to locate the number of total bridges each state had as of the year 2004 and complete a spreadsheet and graph.

Description3: This site includes a "2004 Bridge Inventory" of the total number of bridges for each state and the number and percentage of brigdes that are obsolete or unusable.
 

Title4: Fact Monster

URL4: http://www.factmonster.com/ce6/sci/A0808901.html

Purpose of Use4: Students will use this site to locate general information about various types of bridges and an early history of bridges.

Description4: This site includes information about early bridges and the beam bridge, arch bridge, truss bridge, cantilever bridge, cable-stayed bridge, and suspension bridge.
 
 

Title5: Building Big (PBS)

URL5: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/buildingbig/bridge

Purpose of Use5: Students will use this interactive site as an introduction to bridges.  They should take the "Bridge Challenge".

Description5: This site includes information about the beam bridge, arch bridge, suspension bridge, and truss bridge.  There is an interactive lab on the forces that act on the bridges, as well as an interactive problem-solving activity (the "Bridge Challenge").  There are links to other websites, as well as a database of "Wonders of the World".
 
  
Title6: Super Bridge (PBS - Nova)

URL6: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bridge

Purpose of Use6: Students will use this interactive site as an introduction to bridges.  They should complete the problem-solving activity "Build a Bridge".

Description6: This site includes information about the arch bridge, beam bridge, suspension bridge, and cable-stayed bridge.   There is an interactive  problem-solving activity ("Build a Bridge").


*Photos courtesy of www.engr.utexas.edu/wep/COOL/AcidRiver/allaboutbridges_Disasters_Tacoma.htm