The
Puppet Masters - Robert Heinlein (1951)
Classic SF Noir displaying America's paranoia in what has always been for me
Heinlein's best novel. It exemplifies all that is good about mainstream SF of
the Nineteen Fifties and suffers only from minor political incorrectness in
terms of male and female stereotyping, and the rather irritating remark made
about gay men by the US President; 'There have always been such unfortunates.'
But then, Heinlein is rather on the right wing of the SF stalwarts of the time,
and this is a peculiarly masculine novel. We are told in the first few pages
that the entrance to the secret headquarters of a government department so secret
it doesn't even have a name is situated in the men's washroom on Macarthur Station.
The women (for thankfully there is at least one female agent) no doubt use the
other entrance situated in a shop called 'Rare Stamps and Coins.'
Our hero, Sam Nivens, is a square-jawed All American type who would willingly
die to preserve the liberty of America and whose laconic monologue tells the
tale of the invasion of the Puppet Masters.
A rather decent TV movie of the book was made with Donald Sutherland in the
role of 'The Old Man', the hard-nosed boss of the Department. Although surprisingly
faithful to the text of the novel it suffered in that it was set in the present
day. It should really have been made in black and white and visualised as a
Nineteen Fifties view of America in 2007.
Heinlein's aliens, a perfect metaphor for what America believed typified the
evils of Communism, are a kind of gestalt entity; grey slugs which attach themselves
to the backs of humans and take over the mind and body of their hosts. They
are sexless, appear to have no individual personalities and exchange information
by some form of physical transference when in direct contact with each other.
Just as in 'The Body Snatchers' (Jack Finney, 1955) the aliens 'infect' humans
by stealth, reinforcing the idea of communism as a plague, contagious, insidious
and more than anything else, invisible.
The hosts are literally enslaved by their masters ('Master' actually being a
term which Sam uses to describe them). Heinlein takes these threats of loss
of individuality, the natural fear of disease and the rather disturbing concept
of slavery (which is as alive and well today in the guilty American consciousness
as it was in Nineteen Fifty One) and winds them all together into a chilling
tale of what is essentially a war of ideologies.
I imagine a writer of today would not make the story so one-sided. In a sense
this novel says a lot about Heinlein. The book might well have been stronger
if there had at least been some benefit, or purpose to the aliens' invasion.
As it is the aliens do not compel their hosts to wash or eat properly, and so
are destroying the hand that feeds them, as in when it is discovered that the
bubonic plague has returned to Communist Russia.
No system is truly evil. If Heinlein consciously meant these aliens to be metaphors
for Communism then he should have made them less unknowable. The suggestion
is that one shouldn't even try to understand Communism. To attempt to know Communism
is to be infected by it. The menace cannot be lived with. It has to be eradicated
from our minds.
Of course, it's difficult to understand, in a post USSR world, what level of
paranoia existed in America at the time.
Certainly, whether consciously or not, a large number of SF films and novels
of the time featured ordinary people being 'possessed' by aliens, often taking
over an entire community, abandoning American culture and values and replacing
it with something else.
Sam - who eats steak 'just warmed through' - needs to prove to a sceptical President
that the aliens exist. His plan fails and when a live slug is eventually captured,
Sam is 'possessed' and for a while we see the world of the 'hag ridden' through
his submissive eyes. It is this experience which elevates Sam from a mere two-dimensional
hero into something greater. A stereotype he may be, but in Nineteen Fifty One
it is interesting to see an SF hero with fears, emotions and failings, and who
even cries on occasions.
Of course, with the help of his partner - an efficient female agent with a taste
for weaponry - the world is saved and Sam spearheads a military operation aimed
at saving the elf-like denizens of Titan from the curse of the Puppet Masters.
This suggests, one presumes, that even back in Nineteen Fifty One Americans
felt they had a duty to right wrongs beyond their own borders. The aliens themselves
are beautifully thought out. An immortal gestalt entity which reproduces additional
units of itself by binary fission and may which hold memories dating back to
the dawn of its sapience.
At the end of the novel they remain enigmatic, and the question, raised in the
opening paragraph of the book as to whether they are intelligent in any way
we understand, is never answered.


