Gary's Movie Reviews and Ratings

1999 Movie Chart

1999 Movie eAwards

All Time Movie Chart

Thelma and Louise = 49 =

Hailed as a breakthrough movie because it supposedly potrays women as tough central characters, I found Thelma and Louise to have the opposite effect with almost every character (including the women) shown as being dopey and childish.

Geena Davis and Susan Sarandon play the title characters who set off on an innocent fishing weekend. Both are escaping some baggage at home, Thelma from her pig of a husband Darryl (Christopher McDonald who gets some funny lines), Louise from her greasy spoon job and fear of commitment to her boyfriend Jimmy (Michael Madsen in a typically quiet tough guy role). It goes a bit haywire when they stop at a bar, have an unpleasant encounter with a redneck and end up on the run from an increasingly large contingent of pursuing cops.

Along the way they run into a slick cowboy type (an early role for Brad Pitt), a loopy truck driver, and an unfortunate lone police officer. They also have regular telephone contact with detective Hal Slocumb (Harvey Keitel) who confusingly takes charge of the case even though Max (Stephen Tobolowsky) seems to have more actual authority.

The setting of the American South and Mid West is stunning with plenty of use made of the sweeping landscape of Utah's Monument Valley. The music sets this off well and helps try to create a semblance of the mood of an epic road trip.

Sarandon and Davis also try their best but the whole story does not work. It is supposed to be about the journey of empowerment that these women take at the expense of hapless males, but it comes off more as their descent from a boring suburban rut into crazed lunacy. All of the characters are annoying, none more so than Thelma who ranges from being just plain dumb to sheer irresponsibility.

I suppose this is all to be expected from a director like Ridley Scott who probably does not set out to make movies to please everybody but should be praised for making movies according to his vision and the story he wants to tell.

A lot of people like this movie, but it didn't work for me.

F.A.Q.

Home

All Time Movie Archive

  Director: Ridley Scott  
  Starring: Susan Sarandon, Geena Davis, Harvey Keitel, Brad Pitt, Michael Madsen, Stepehn Tobolowsky, Christopher McDonald
  Date seen: 28 December 1999  
  Last Updated 31 December 1999  


Contact Gary at harbourboy@oocities.com