The Best Way to Defend Muhammad (S)

Dr. Syed Hasanuddin Ahmad

Peoria, Illinois

hasanuddinahmad@yahoo.com

 

         In this age, Islam and its followers are once again under full attacks by others. The Muslims all over the world are being harassed and persecuted on account of one or the other made up reasons and excuses. Honor and freedom have now become mirage for them, whereas insult and misery have now become signs of their recognition. The Qur’an tells us that a certain group was punished in the following manner: 

 

ضربت عليهم الذلّةُ والمسكنة وبآؤ بغضبٍ من الله (البقره 2: 61 )                                 

(They were covered with humiliation and misery; they drew on themselves the wrath of Allah)(Al-Baqarah 2: 61).

It seems the Qur’anic punishment is now fate of the Muslim Ummah. Muslim countries are being attacked and occupied. Muslims are being killed in mass. Their houses are being razed, and properties destroyed. They have become a laughing stock, and a target of every Tom and Harry to kick around. A clear new example of such assault on the sensibility of Muslims is the publication of cartoons ridiculing and insulting the last Messenger of Allah, Muhammad (S). This has been done in the name of freedom of speech. Freedom of speech has limitations. In a civilized world, one is free to criticize other’s conduct or idea based on facts. False and insulting accusations are never condoned by a civilized society. Do not they know that the non-western world does not accept their definition of freedom of speech? False accusation is a libel and liable to be punished by a civilized society. Some might say that in the western culture freedom of speech has no bounds, but needless to say that this principle is based on double standard. One is not free to criticize or express one’s opinion on certain events or actions of certain personalities of the West. Mayor of London, Lord Livingstone, was ordered not to go to his office for four weeks. Why? Because he had used his right of freedom of speech by calling a reporter like a Nazi guard! A historian, David Irving, was jailed for three years in Austria. Why? Because he had cast doubts on the number of deaths in Holocaust! A chaplain of New York jail, Abdul Jalil, was suspended from his job and his two weeks salary confiscated. Why? Because he had likened President Bush to Hitler! A teacher in Colorado, Jay Bennish, was suspended from his job. Why? Because he had likened the ruling group of Washington to Nazis. Recently, a Radio Talk Show presenter in St. Louis, Mr. Lenihan, was fired from his job. Why? Because he had called American Secretary of State, Ms Condoleeza Rice, an Afro-American coon, even though he had immediately apologized. On the other hand, world Muslims protests on publication of such cartoons have been rebuffed and ignored not only by the publishers but the governments of Europe and America in the name of unlimited freedom of speech. They express their surprise over strong protests lodged by Muslims all over the world. Do not they know that Islam teaches Muslims to love and honor the Messenger of Allah more than that of themselves? Allah clearly says in the Qur’an:

النبى أَولى بالمؤمنين من أنفسهم وأزواجه أُمهاتهم (الاحزاب 33: 6)

(The Prophet is closer to the believers than their own selves, and his wives are their mothers)(Al-Ahzab 33: 6). 

Also Allah has ordered Muslims to rise and defend the dignity and honor of the Messenger of Allah against false accusation and libel:

إن الله وملآ ئكته يصلون على النبى يآأَيهاالذين آمنواصلواعليه وسلمواتسليما(الاحزاب 33: 56)

(Allah and his angels send blessings on the Prophet. O you who believe! Send your blessings on him, and salute him with all respect) (Al-Ahzab 33: 56).

         Muhammad (S) was the only prophet whose full life-history has been preserved. His life remains an exemplary model for the entire mankind. He was a man of tolerance, forgiveness, and peace. Here I will give just two examples from history to illustrate the point: 1. When Muhammad (S) went to Taif to invite people there to Islam, he was stoned by urchins and opponents of the city so much so that he was profusely bleeding from head to toe. An angel came to seek his permission to overturn the mountain of the city on its citizens. He took pity on his tortures and denied the request; 2. When Muhammad conquered Makkah, he let all his enemy soldiers and fighters go free without any punishment. History fails to show any such parallel event. Does not the West know what its own writers and scholars have written about Muhammad? Just two examples, for the sake of brevity, from their literature will suffice-1, “During his lifetime Muhammad thus laid the foundation for a stable social and political order. Circumstances favored him in many ways, but he could not have achieved what he did without his personal qualities, his far-seeing wisdom as a statesman, his skill as an administrator, and his tact in handling individuals." (The Encyclopedia of Religion: Muhammad, Political and Social Achievement); 2, "My choice of Muhammad to lead the list of the world's most influential persons may surprise some readers and may be questioned by others, but he was the only man in history who was supremely successful on both the religious and secular levels.” “During this short period of 23 years of his prophet-hood, he changed the complete Arabian Peninsula from paganism and idolatry to worship of One God, from tribal quarrels and wars to national solidarity and cohesion, from drunkenness and debauchery to sobriety and piety, from lawlessness and anarchy to disciplined living, from utter bankruptcy to the highest standards of moral excellence. Human history has never known such a complete transformation of a people or a place before or since - and imagine all these unbelievable wonders in just over in two decades” (M.H. Hart, The 100: A Ranking of the most Influential Persons in History, New York, 1978, p. 33). These examples clearly show the status and honor given to him by the historians of the West, but the West is blind to rationality or logic in case of injuring Muslims’ feelings. They are like stones devoid of hearts and mind.           

         Peoples’ demonstrations on streets, peaceful or otherwise, writings on papers, and speeches and resolutions in legislatures have never been able to correct political and planned agenda of offences and assaults. Under such circumstances, should Muslims resort to start insulting others as a pay back, or become pacifist, or continue the mission of calling people to their Lord- the Creator?  Muslims should never insult or ridicule elders of others. Allah says:

And do not revile those whom they invoke besides Allah (Al-An'aam 6: 108).

         Also no, they should never become pacifist! They should, however, realize that just words, either by speech or in writing, are not enough to convince the people. We have to practice what we preach to let people see the fruits of Muhammad’s teachings. Our behavior and conduct should please people around us. Our social life, based on Islamic norms, should be a model for others. Thus, the only way, Muslims can successfully defend the honor and dignity of the Messenger of Allah is to learn how he, himself, used to deal with non-believers. Here I will give some examples from the life of the Messenger of Allah.

         Social Dealing: 1. a companion R of the Aslami tribe had taken some loan from a Jew. He was unable to pay back the loan in time. The Jew was continuously asking him to give back his loan. The companion wanted to delay the payment till the improvement of his situation. The Jew did not want to grant him more time. The case was presented to the Prophet (S). He ordered his companion to pay back the loan. The companion told him that he had nothing, except the dress on his body. The Prophet (S) ordered him to give his leg wrapper to the Jew and use his turban as a wrapper of his loin (Ahmad).

2. The Jews used to come to the meetings of the Prophet (S) to listen to his talks. They would deliberately sneeze during his talks to disturb the listening of the people. Instead of rebuking and punishing them on this rude and disturbing behavior, the Prophet (S) used to say, “May God guide you, and correct your manners” (Abu Dawood).

3. An old woman used to throw garbage over the Messenger (S) whenever he passed through her balcony. One day she did not throw the garbage. The Messenger of Allah enquired but her. He was told that she had fallen sick. He then visited her on her sick bed (Muslim).

         Justice: 1. a Muslim, named Bishar, had a dispute with a Jew. The Muslim asked the Jew to go to a Jewish Chief, K’ab bin Ashraf, to settle the matter. The Jew refused to go to his own chief, and brought him to the Prophet (S) because he believed him to be just. After hearing their case, the Prophet (S) decided in favor of the Jew (Abu Dawood).

2. A Muslim once took some loan from a Jew. He was not able to pay in time. The Jew was not ready to extend time of payment. The Messenger (S) ordered the Muslim to pay back the loan. He expressed his inability, saying he had nothing to pay. The Messenger (S) ordered him to compensate the Jew with his leg wrapper, and use his turban as a leg wrapper (Muslim).

         Toleration: 1. once, the Prophet (S) was talking to a villager in the mosque. The villager felt the call of nature to urinate. He urinated right there in the mosque. Some companions ran to him to admonish him. The Prophet (S) told them to leave him alone, and reminded them that they have been raised to make ease, and not create difficulty. He then asked them to wash the place with the water (Bukhari).

2. Once the Prophet (S) was going somewhere with a shawl of thick border wrapped over his shoulders and neck. A Bedouin pulled his shawl so hard that it left injurious marks on the shoulders and the neck of the Prophet (S). The man then said, “O Muhammad! Give me something from the treasury of Allah, which you have. And it will not be a giving from your own or your father’s wealth.” The Prophet (S) attended to him and ordered to give something to the man (Bukhari).

         Gifts & Charity: 1. once, the Prophet (S) received a silk robe. He sent that robe to Umar R. Umar R brought the robe to the Prophet (S), and said, “O Messenger of God! You have forbidden the believers to wear silk and gold. What should then I do with it?” The Prophet (S) replied, “I did not give it to you to wear, but for some other use.” Umar R then sent that robe as a gift to his non-believing brother in Makkah (Agreed Upon).                                                                                                                                                     2. Once, a man came to the Prophet (S) and begged him to give him some cattle. The Prophet (S) gave him the entire horde of animals. The man went back to his tribe and told them to embrace Islam because the Prophet (S) was so generous that he had not cared of becoming poor [S, Muslim].                                                

3. Once, some non-believers came to visit him. He entertained them with goat milk so much so that they drank up milk of all the goats. That night his family members slept hungry. Abu Basrah Ghiffari RA, who was one of those non-believers who drank up all the milk that night, narrated this story. He later became a Muslim (Ahmad).

         Funerals & Graves: 1. once, a funeral procession of a Jew passed by the Prophet (S). He stood up as a mark of respect, and said, “Respect the dead” (Bukhari).                                                                                           2. Once, the Prophet (S) visited the grave of his mother. There, the tears started flowing out of his eyes. His companions wanted to know the reason. The Messenger (S) said, “I sought the permission of God to pray for the forgiveness for my mother. The permission was denied. I then sought the permission to visit her grave. This permission was granted. Do visit the graves, it helps remembering the death” (Muslim).                                                                                    

         Neighbors’ Rights: Non-Muslim neighbors have also rights over their Muslim neighbors Abdullah bin Umar RA used to send meat of his slaughtered goat to his neighbor who was a Jew (Abu Dawood).

         Here of-course, I am talking about a huge social struggle and transformation of our attitude. But then Allah does not help unless we struggle to help ourselves:

إنَّ الله لآ يغير ما بقومٍ حتى يغيروا ما بأَنفسهم (الرعد13: 11)

(Verily never will Allah change the condition of a people until they change it themselves with their own souls)(Ar-Ra’d 13: 11).

         All these can be achieved only when all Muslims play their individual and collective role with zeal and devotion. Example of how much zeal and devotion to the cause we need is that of the Messenger of Allah (S). He asserted so much devotion and energy that Allah had to say:  

فلعلك باخع نفسك على آثا رهم إن لم يؤمنوا بهذا الحديث أَسفًا (الكهف 18: 6)

(Thou would only, perchance, fret thyself to death, following after them, in grief, if they believe not in the message) (Al-Kahf 18: 6).

To develop this much zeal and devotion, and to strengthen our resolve and perseverance, we must adopt the same technique that was prescribed by Allah to his Messenger (S)- practice and habit of standing at night to seek his help:

و من اليل فاسجد له و سبحه ليلا طويلا (الانسان 76: 26)

(And part of the night, prostrate thyself to him; and glorify him a long night through)(Al-Insan 76: 26).

         We should be mentally prepared to face rebukes, insults, ridicules, criticism, excuses, neglect, and such other offensive acts or talks etc. Patience and toleration should be our shields to keep our own emotions, anger, and sorrow under control. Let us recall a hadith narrated by Lady ‘Aisha R that the Prophet (S) never avenged an insult or injury to his own personal feelings, body, or substance. However, he never forgave those who committed a crime (of Allah’s limitations), and always punished them (Agreed Upon)

         When we are able to witness the Messenger’s way of life, then and only then not only we can regain honor, and respect for him, but also rights to live and practice our own way of life in the world, and forgiveness of Allah in the Hereafter.

         To start with let us first proclaim with pride and dignity that we are Muslims, and be not shy or afraid of it; and that is what Allah says:                                   

ومن أَحسن قولاً ممن دعآ الى الله و عمل صالحًا و قال إننى من المسلمين (فصلت 41: 33)

(Who is better in speech than one who calls (men) to Allah, works righteousness, and says, “I am of those who bow in Islam”?)(Fussilat 41: 33).

 

.