| FR. GERHARD TERHORST | 1886 - Oct. 1901 |
| FR. MELCHIOR FAUST | 1901 - May 1916 |
| FR. FRANCIS A. SEIFERT | May 1916 - June, 1916 |
| FR. CASPER DOUENBERG | July, 1916 - June, 1936 |
| FR. ANTHONY WAECHTER | July, 1936 - Oct, 1949 |
| FR. ALOYSIUS E EHLINGER | Dec, 1949 - May, 1957 |
| FR. RALPH J. STERBENTZ | June, 1957 - June 1966 |
| FR. L. MERCIER(appt. Admin.) | Jan, 1965 - April 1965 |
| FR. JOSEPH A. KICHAK | July 1966 - July 1969 |
| FR. WILLIAM C. OREMUS | July 1969 - Aug. 1972 |
| FR. GERVASE BREWER | Spet. 1972 - July 1974 |
| FR. CLIFFORD NADEAU | August 1974 - Feb, 1978 |
| FR. ALOYSIUS E. EHLINGER | March, 1978 - April 1980 |
| FR. PETER CARLI | 1980 - July 1982 |
| FR. EDWARD WENZEL | August 1982 - May, 1985 |
| FR. DAVID JENNER | July 1985 - June, 1991 |
| FR. PHILIP NAESSENS, OFM, CAP | June 1991 - Sept 1996 |
| FR. PAUL MANDERFIELD | 1996 - June 2000 |
| FR. KALLARACKAL GEORGE JOSEPH | - July 2000-June 2003 |
| FR. JAMIE ZIMINSKI | - July 2003 - June 2004 |
| FR. CHACKO KAKANIYIL | - July 2004 - April 2005 |
| FR. ANTONY LUKOSE | - July 2004-May 2005 |
| FR. GEORGE MAKI, Assoc. Pastor St. Anne and Sacred Heart | - April 2005 -
Present |
| FR. AUGUSTIN GEORGE, Pastor, St. Anne and Sacred Heart | -May 2005 - Present |