| This rating system is my own opinions and do not reflect any official or unofficial polls. *Bad ** Good *** Very Good **** Excellent |
| Season 3 |
| Line of Fire ** |
| The Samurai ** |
| The Revolutionary * |
| The Cross of St. Antoine ** |
| Rite of Passage *** |
| Courage * |
| The Lamb * |
| Obsession * |
| Shadows * |
| Blackmail ** |
| Vendetta * |
| They Also Serve ** |
| Blind Faith ** |
| Song of the Executioner *** |
| Star-Crossed **** |
| Methos **** |
| Take Back the Night *** |
| Testimony ** |
| Mortal Sins ** |
| Reasonable Doubt ** |
| Finale pt 1 *** |
| Finale pt 2 **** |
| Adrian Paul-Duncan MacLeod Stan Kirsch-Richie Ryan Philip Akin-Charlie DeSalvo Lisa Howard-Anne Lindsey Michel Modo-Maurice Jim Byrnes-Joe Dawson |
 |