Reviews are out of 100, and are divided into these sections:
Artwork (25 points): The model: if it's a new model, it should be done correctly, not super-polyed and without any holes in it (missing triangles). Stick models won't recieve points!
The skin: the textures themselves, not the way they look on the model. If they are taken from another model (copy/paste), the skin won't recieve much points. Details are a good thing.
Originality (25 points): The model: if it's a new model, it's original!
The skin: Something new, wich makes the model look different. Not just a new style of camo for the grunt, or a new suit color for the G-man
Game (25 points): How does the model/skin looks ingame. I do not take points if the it looks out of place in the game (as custom maps and mods are possible).
Bugs (25 points): If the model doesn't deform right, or some animations are missing and stuff like that. If the model is bug-free, it will automaticly recieve 25 points. This goes for skins too!(aren't i nice?)
Extras (+10 points): Anything from new sounds, animations, sprites (like the gargantua eye) or any other stuff that are on the model. If you just change the gun, it's an extra and not a new model.
Hmm... Looking at the criteria, I don't think I'll dare reviewing my own skins :-| |
