| The Godfather | 1972 | Nominated for an Oscar: Best Supporting Actor | |
| The Godfather | 1972 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| Serpico | 1974 | Nominated for an Oscar: Best Actor | |
| Serpico | 1974 | Won the Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| The Godfather: Part II | 1975 | Nominated for an Oscar: Best Actor | |
| The Godfather: Part II | 1975 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| Dog Day Afternoon | 1976 | Nominated for an Oscar: Best Actor | |
| Dog Day Afternoon | 1976 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| Bobby Deerfield | 1978 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| ...And Justice for All | 1980 | Nominated for an Oscar: Best Actor | |
| ...And Justice for All | 1980 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| Author! Author! | 1983 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Musical or Comedy | |
| Scarface | 1984 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| Sea of Love | 1990 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| Dick Tracy | 1991 | Nomnated for an Oscar: Best Supporting Actor | |
| Dick Tracy | 1991 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Supporting Actor | |
| The Godfather: Part III | 1991 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| Scent of a Women | 1993 | Won the Oscar: Best Actor | |
| Scent of a Women | 1993 | Won the Golden Globe: Best Actor in a Drama | |
| Glengary Glen Ross | 1993 | Nominated for a Oscar: Best Supporting Actor | |
| Glengary Glen Ross | 1993 | Nominated for a Golden Globe: Best Supporting Actor |