Originally, Faye was Jimmy's girlfriend. She was very important during The Wonders' tour, as their costume mistress. When the band was in Los Angeles and Hollywood, taking part on a movie and preparing for their live broadcast presentation, Faye got sick, and no one except Guy noticed.

It was also Faye who came up with the band's first name, The One-ders, during a garage rehearsal in Erie, before the talent show that would make them famous.