|
 |
Maltese Medical History
LEAD IN THE MALTESE ENVIORNMENT:
A HISTORIAL PERSPECTIVE
C. SAVONA-VENTURA
More than forty elements are found in the
human body; of these the major elements are well known, as is their
importance in sustaining life. Several of the less abundant elements
have vital roles in regulating the body's metabolism of macronutrients
and in the maintainance of life. The availiability of particular trace
elements to the organism can be adversely modified by the presence of
other non-essential elements such as lead. Lead is a non-essential
element with known toxic properties. It also competes with a number of
essential elements - particularly iron, calcium, zinc and copper - to
adversely modify the metabolic pathways of
the organism. While the effects of acute lead poisoning are dramatic
and obvious, the situation is not so with chronic lead poisoning. Lead
taken internally in any of its forms is highly toxic; the effects are
usually felt after it has accumulated in the body over a period of
time. The symptoms of lead poisoning are anaemia, weakness,
constipation, colic, palsy, and often a paralysis of the wrists and
ankles. A lead hazard at levels once thought safe is that of increased
blood pressure. Children are especially at risk from lead, even at
levels once thought safe. Twenty years ago authorities believed that
children were safe with up to 400 ug/l of lead in the blood. The "safe"
level has slowly fallen. Nowadays the safe level has been decreased to
below 100 ug/l. New studies have linked even low blood lead levels to a
host of problems, including IQ loss, aggression and hyperactivity,
reduced attentiveness, hearing loss, slow reaction time, slow growth
and problems with balance. Chronic lead exposure can also
have effects on the unborn child. A study from Malta has shown
that high lead levels may have caused a longer duration of labour for
the mother and a decrease in the newborn's birth weight.
Lead is widely distributed all over the
world in the form of its sulfide, the ore galena. Lead ranks about 36th
in natural abundance among elements in the earth's crust. Ores of
secondary importance are cerussite and anglesite. Maltese rock
formations are markedly deficient in lead ores, the mineral being found
only in minute traces in the local limestones. Lead has been important
for industrial purposes since ancient times. The metal was imported to
Malta by the Bronze Age people with pieces of lead being excavated from
Borg in-Nadur and Tarxien Cremation Cemetry. The Romans in Malta
similarly imported the element and used it for making water pipes,
soldered with an alloy of lead and tin. Other Roman uses of the metal
included household articles such as leadened buckets, and the stock and
collar of ship anchors. The high carbonate content of natural water in
Malta usually forms a coating on lead pipes inhibiting the formation of
soluble lead hydroxide. It is thus
unlikely that the use of lead water conduits during Roman times
predisposed significantly to lead intoxication. The use of lead-based
utensils for cooking food may however assist the contamination of
foodstuff. In 1904 a case of suspected poisoning reported to the Police
was traced to the intake of a considerable quantity of lead being
absorbed from the broken enamel of some of the pans used as cooking
utensils.
By the nineteenth century, the toxic
effects of lead salts were recognised by medical practitioners. The
Maltese medical journal Il-Barth , published by Dr. G. Guilia,
on a number of occasions drew the attention of the medical profession
to the various ways in which lead intoxication could occur. Thus in
1876 attention was drawn to the possiblity of chronic poisoning from
lead-contaminated beer, and from lead contained in cosmetics, water
pipes and infant feeding bottles. The formation of a dark blue line on
the gums was associated by Maltese medical practitioners with the use
as an astringent mouth gargle of lead acetate or sugar of lead in 1842.
They did not however recognise this as a sign of lead toxicity. Lead
acetate is a white crystalline soluble salt with a very sweet taste. A
judicial postmortem was performed in 1861 on a man suspected of having
died from the effects of chronic poisoning by lead acetate. Chemical
analysis of portions of the viscera were also performed, but no traces
of lead could be discovered. At least two two deaths from lead
intoxication were reported in the fortnightly mortality reports of the
late nineteenth century (1-15 February 1885 and 16-22 February 1891).
These were probably occupational deaths. Both occurred in male
individuals aged 25-45 years from Cospicua.
Other sources of lead salts in the Maltese
diet were subsequently identified. In May 1897, samples of raw coffee
imported from Trieste were noted to have a suspicious appearance in
that the berries were dark, greenish and soiled the hands when handled.
These were analysed by the Department of Health Laboratory who found
these to be coated with
a mixture of finely powdered plumbago (graphite) and lead chromate.
Later on during the same year, another quality of coloured coffee was
detected, the berries being yellowish in colour. Analysis showed these
to be coloured with lead chromate. The percentage of this colouring
material differed with the different samples being generally less than
0.0525 grams of chromate per 100 gms berries, though a number of
berries were dotted all over with the bright yellow lead salt. Of 370
samples of coffee taken from different shops, not less than 261 were
found to be coloured with lead chromate. The coffee originated from
Trieste, Genoa, Hamburg and London. On the 7 June 1897, a law
prohibiting the importation of coffee coloured with substances
injurious to health was enacted.
In the subsequent six months, only 3.7% of tested coffee samples were
found to be contaminated with lead chromate. Lead chromate, or chrome
yellow (PbCrO4), a crystalline powder used as a yellow pigment, is
prepared by the reaction of lead acetate and potassium bichromate.
Chrome red, orange chrome yellow, and lemon chrome yellow are some of
the pigments obtained from lead chromate.
Another instance of contamination of
foodstuff with lead occurred in 1908. At this time the number of
factories manufacturing of "aerated waters" had greatly increased owing
to the cheapness of the machinery. Abour 12% of the samples tested by
the Public Health Laboratory were found to be unsuitable for
consumption because of the presence of a consideranle amount of lead,
which was traced to the use of impure tartaric and citric acid used in
the manufacture.In May 1903 an epidemic of lead posoning was reported
in Maltese bakers. On enquiry this was traced to the use of wood as
fuel obtained from the thickly painted timber from HMS Hibernia.
The famous Base Flagship HMS Hibernia had been launched in 1804
and broken down in 1902. The amount of leaded paint used in her
maintainance over a hundred years can only be left to the imagination.
A general inspection of all the bakeries in Malta showed that wherever
such fuel was in use, symptoms of lead poisoning became evident. Lead
was also discovered in the bread supplied to the public when baked in
ovens heated with lead painted fuel. 166 samples of ashes from ovens
and 72 samples of bread were analysed. Fifty-seven percent of the ash
samples contained lead oxide in a proportion varying from traces to
8.6%, while 50% of bread samples contained lead. All symptomes of lead
poisoning disappeared when energetic measures were taken to prevent the
use of this wood as fuel, especially since those mainly effected were
the bakers themselves. Red lead or minium (Pb3O4), a scarlet,
crystalline powder formed by oxidizing lead monoxide, is the pigment in
paint used as a protective coating for wood, iron and steel. Even
though the sale and use of Red Lead paint is now controlled, this paint
remains an important source of lead in the Maltese ecosystem through
the burning or scraping of old wooden items previously treated with Red
Lead paint.
The twentieth century saw a dramatic
increase in the number of petrol-driven vehicles. These vehicles have
contributed significantly towards the introduction of lead in the
Maltese ecosystem. Lead tetraethyl or the bromide is the chief
constituent of the antiknock compound added to gasoline to prevent
premature detonation in internal-combustion engines;
it is considered a significant contributor to air pollution. The
significant presence of lead contamination from vehicular emmisions in
Malta was demonstrated in a Junior College (Royal University of Malta)
exhibition in 1971. Sample leaves collected from the main street in
Floriana (Malta) were washed with concentrated acid. After filtration
of the carbon particlres and adjustment of the acidity, the solution
was tested with potassium chromate and shown to have a high proportion
of lead in solution. The significance
of the high levels of lead in the Maltese ecosystem was finally
confirmed in 1981. The Maltese population was shown to have a
high level of exposure to lead and cadmium when compared to other
countries. A population survey showed that the Maltese population had a
significantly higher mean blood lead levels than the Belgian
population. The mean lead level in Malta was 307 ug/l with a maximum
value of 863 ug/l, while in Belgium the mean level ranged 145-240 ug/l
with maximum values of 279-570 ug/l depending on the locality studied.
Among Britain's children the average quantity of lead in the blood is
between 70-75 ug/l. The US Centres for Disease Control (CDC) considers
any value above 100 ug/l as an unsafe level. The blood lead levels in
Malta were similar in both men
and women suggesting that this was not an occupational hazard
but a continuous enviornmental one. A follow-up study two years
later reported a slight drop in the mean blood lead levels, but
was still elevated at 243 ug Pb/l. Subsequent studies have persistently
confirmed the high lead levels in the various sections of the
Maltese population including children and neonates. Other studies
have shown that blood lead levels are elevated in Maltese children
aged 7-9 years with a mean of 241.5 ug Pb/l in Malta and 194.4
ug Pb/l in Gozo. The latter island has a more rural
environment promoting a lower traffic density, thus accounting
for the lower blood lead levels observed. The blood lead levels
in the rural community seem higher than would be expected from
petrol lead exposure alone, thus suggesting that the source of
lead in the enviornment is multifactorial and not simply due to
traffic emissions.
The causes for this high blood lead level in
the Maltese population
have still not been fully elucidated. Lead is ubiquitous in the
environment and consequently it can reach the human organism through
a number of pathways. There are a number of sources which may
introduce lead in the environment. Investigations attempting to
identify a particular lead source that contributed to these elevated
lead levels in the Maltese population has proved to be difficult.
Food analysis have shown that lead levels in Maltese foodstuffs,
except of potatoes, flour, carrots and pasta, compared well to
those from similar food items from Mexico, Belgium and Sweden.
Soil sample analysis have further demonstrated that soil lead
levels rose in soil samples obtained close to road. The soil lead
levels ranged from 29.0 - 367 ug/g dry material. The airborne
lead content was found to be about 1 ug/m3 in areas with traffic
congestion. This airborne lead has been estimated to result in
an increase of 1.5-3.0 ug Pb/dl of blood. Common entry portals
of lead into the ecosystem include industries, lead paint and
vehicular emissions. The latter is an important contributor to
lead in the Maltese ecosystem in view of the high traffic density
which pertains to the Islands. The Maltese Islands are a small
group of islands with a total area of only 313 km2. Car ownership
in Malta is amongst the highest in Europe, estimated at an average
of 1.7 cars per household. With the small surface area of the
Islands, this car ownership level results in a very high traffic
density. The number of registered cars in 1990 amounted to 182254,
giving an automobile density of 582 per km2. There is at present
no legal restriction on the quantity of lead in petrol sold on
the Islands, with recent estimates reporting a value of 0.32 g
Pb/l. Leaded petrol consumption in 1994 reached a value of 63647
m3, suggesting a total annual lead emission of about 20.6 tons.
The consumption of unleaded petrol remain low 10242 m3. Thus the
consumption of unleaded petrol is only about a sixth that of leaded
petrol, and about 20 tons of lead are released in the environment
annually.
Lead compounds derived from vehicular
emissions are mostly
inorganic and consequently exist in a particulate form. Lead,
in the form of tetra-methyl lead or tetra-ethyl lead, is added
to petrol to increase its octane rating to reduce engine knocking.
Ethylene dibromide and ethylene dichloride are further added to
petrol to remove the lead from the engine cylinders. The predominant
lead product exhausted from automobiles is lead halides, which
undergo chemical changes quite rapidly with other exhaust gases
and in the atmosphere. Vehicular lead sources may enter the human
organism through inhalation and/or ingestion. Inhaled lead is
taken up more efficiently than through ingestion. The uptake of
lead by inhalation is dependent on the lead concentration in the
air, particle size and the breathing and ventilation rates. In
the situation of air lead levels of 1 ug/m3 described for the
Maltese ecosystem, an adult is estimated to take 15 ug Pb/day
of which 50% would be deposited in the lungs. Ninety per cent
of the deposited lead is absorbed and equilibrates between the
circulation and the tissues. In the Maltese circumstances therefore,
an adult living in areas of traffic congestion would absorb about
7.5 ug Pb/day of which 3.75 ug Pb/day remains in the circulation.
Absorption of lead through the gastrointestinal tract is a relatively
inefficient process. A number of conditions influence the rate
of absorption of lead, particularly the chemical form in which
it is ingested, the type of diet, and the individual's physiology.
It has been estimated that the absorption of lead from the
gastrointestinal
tract into the bloodstream averages 10% in adults and 40% in infants.
Vehicular lead emissions are sparingly soluble in water, but
have been found to be 90% soluble in hydrochloric acid at a pH
1, stimulating the chemical conditions inside the stomach. The
soluble lead forms are more efficiently absorbed by the
gastrointestinal
tract. Dust ingestion seems to be an unlikely pathway in adults.
It has however been shown to be a significant source in children.
Investigations have revealed that dust may account for half the
total daily intake of lead by a young child amounting to an average
value of 50-100 ug Pb/day. Dust can be ingested indirectly by
eating sweets or sucking toys while playing at home or in the
street. The child can transfer up to 50 mg of dust from his hands
to a sweet after 30 minutes activity in a playground. A local
study has demonstrated the high lead levels in dust from playgrounds
in high traffic density areas and the relationship to dust lead
levels to child hand-wipe lead levels. The risks of lead intake
through ingestion of dust extends also in the home since housedust
in urban areas has also been shown to have significantly higher
lead levels when compared to rural areas. The increased transfer
of lead from household, street and playground dust in areas of
high traffic density has been demonstrated by the higher blood
lead levels noted in children living in Malta compared to those
living on the more rural island.
While vehicular emissions contribute
substantially to the lead levels in soil, which levels are inversely
proportional to the distance from the road; the organic matter
in soil together with the high alkalinity of maltese calcareous
soils immobilizes the lead decreasing its availability to plants.
Thus fruit and vegetables, provided they are well washed from
adhering soil and dust, are unlikely to be direct sources of lead
ingestion. On the other hand, seafood may be an important source
of ingestion of vehicular-originating lead in the Maltese
circumstances.
The level of lead in sea sediments in the vicinity of the capital
city was found at 118 ug/g to be markedly higher to levels of
other Mediterranean inshore sediment exposed to urban and industrial
pollution (Thermaikos Gulf: 71 ug/g; Gulf of Venice: 45 ug/g).
Certain edible shellfish, such as the Date Mussel and the Warty
Venus, collected from Maltese waters have also been found to carry
high lead levels. The main source of this high sediment lead is
most likely to be car traffic rain washoff . Used car engine oil
can also contribute either when disposed off in fields through
leaching to soil and the water-table, or when sold to bakeries
to be used as fuel. Another possible source of lead in the Maltese
ecosystem may be the lead shot used by hunters which deposits
onto the soil and slowly but gradually leaches into the soil and
is absorbed by plants. This is a slow process which may be accelerated
by the use of pesticides. While the use of leaded paint has now
been controlled, some cheap imported toys may still use these
types of paint. The burning of old wood which may have been painted
in the past by "Red Lead" paint may also be contributory
to chronic lead intoxication. Cases of lead intoxication were
recently reported in Maltese drug users after heroin sold in the
streets was laced with lead acetate.Vehicular emission is a definite
contributor of lead in the Maltese environment resulting in the
reported high blood lead levels of this population. Serious efforts
to reduce the amount of leadened petrol and promote lead-free
petrol must be taken by the authorities. There is evidence that
the environmental benefits of lead-free petrol are being increasingly
appreciated by the Maltese, resulting in an increase in lead-free
petrol demands from 5281 m3 in 1992 to 10242 in 1994. In spite
of this 94% increase in lead-free petrol demands, the leadened
petrol at 63647 m3 in 1994 remains the major source of automobile
fuel demanded. The authorities, alerted to the high blood levels
in the Maltese population in the 1980s, instituted a number of
community preventive measures to attempt control this environmental
problem. It appears that these measures have had a significant
favourable effect. A recent study has confirmed that there has
been a definite lowering in PbB levels in newborns in 1996 when
compared to a similar study conducted in 1985. While in 1985,
31.6% of neonates had PbB levels greater than 200 ug/l, no neonates
studies in 1996 had these high values. However a high proportion
of neonates in 1996 still had values for which the CDC recommends
community prevention activities (>100 ug/l).
|
 |
|