This is
the way I believe this disease causes MM:
Explanation of diagram 1:
The original transforming event as witnessed by heavy chain re-arrangement, happens in the
lymphnode. This area of transformation would favor a viral etiology. A retro virus
explains a lot of the phenomena seen in MM. After the original infection, which has to be
spesific to a particular gene on a spesific chromosome, the KSHV would activate the
expression of IL-2 gene by the tax (or generic) gene. It is one of the cytokines
responsible for B-cell differentiation and proliferation. It also acts with IL-6 to aid
transcription of c-myc from the P0 transcript regulator.
With TNF it acts as a 'osteoclast stimulating' factor. In other words the virus has the
gene to start the process. On differentiation the pre-B cell moves to the BM to become a
plasma cell. It is important to remember that the malignant plasma cell is a normal plasma
cell which has a few genetic mutations. In other words in many respects it acts like a
normal plasma cell.The MM plasma cell interacts with the bone marrow stromal cells (BMSC).
The plasmacytosis induces a normal feedback system, whereby TGF-B1 is produced by BMSC.
TGF- B1 acts on the Rb gene to stimulate cell differentiation and proliferation and
ultimately programmed cell death (PCD) after terminal differentiation. 80% of MM patients
have a monoallelic deletion of the Rb gene, but Juge-Morineau et al (1996) found no
decrease in the Rb gene or gene product expression. It would be very unlikely that a
deletion of high penetration does not have any affect on the disease process. This is the
first of the mutations giving rise to MM. A possible explanation for the Rb gene not
functioning properly is the E2F molecule which binds pRb. Various viruses make a
antagonist for this molecule called E1A in DNA virusses like Karposi sarcoma Herpes virus.
It would interfere with normal function of pRb and no differentiation would take place.
The increase of TGF- B1 would continue because the BMSC want to decrease the amount of
plasma cells in the marrow. TGF- 1 has a powerful down regulation on the whole immune
system and gives a negative feedback signal to the pre-B cells in order to reduces the
amount of plasma cells produced. It also has a direct depressive effect on the cellular
immunity and this explains part of the immune deficiency seen in MM. It is also possible
that the retrovirus will infect T cells with the CD4+ receptor, and cause decreased
functioning of these cells.
In an effort to induce differentiation via a third pathway TGF- B1 induces IL-6 secretion
by BMSC. IL-6/IL-6R bind with gp130 to induce cell differentiation, but once again we have
found various mutations in the cytoplasmic domain of gp130. Futher on in this pathway p21
ras has also been shown to have point mutations. The amount of IL-6 in the bone marrow
environment is now at high levels and this gives rise to various pathological processes:
- IL-6 acts as a proliferation and not a
differentiation cytokine on MM plasmacells. The plasma cells increase and the vicious
circle repeats its self.
- IL-6 and IL-2 transcribe c-myc from the
P0 promoter. The normal regulatory function c-myc has on p53 is lost. Various mutations
have also been reported affecting p53.
- IL-6 acts with various other cytokines
to activate osteoclasts and give bone resorption.
It is obvious that MM develops as a
consequence of various mutational abnormalities in various crucial pathways. Every cell
has a built in program to facilitate programmed cell death. There are various backup
pathways to facilitate PCD and until all these pathways have been neutralized, MM will lie
dormant as MGUS. Dr Mathew Rettig et al. has show a virus that infects dendritic cells and
is closely associated to MGUS transforming to Multiple Myeloma. The increase cell survival
is important in this respect to give enough time for the multiple genetic events to occur.
The best explanation for the multiple mutations seen in MM is a transforming retrovirus.
This means a retrovirus with the ability to incorporate in the host DNA lifelong. This
virus acts different to HIV and is not cytopathic. It can only spread by direct cell to
cell contact. The various adhesion molecules in MM make this task much easier. Over years
there is a continuous bombardment of the plasma cells genetic structure with viral genetic
insults, and as soon as the critical pathways to PCD have been destroyed, multiple myeloma
develops. This explains the long dormancy period from the development of MGUS to MM.
In order to cure MM or at least revert
back to MGUS it is only necessary to activate one of these pathways:
- Functional Rb gene replacement - this
can be done with a retroviral vector.
- IL-6 superantagonist - a decrease of
IL-6 in vitro causes cell apoptosis, most likely by reducing the amount of abnormal c-myc
production and the tumor suppressor signal via p53.
- B7- cells can be transfected with a
retroviral vector. Expression of B7 should give T-cell mediated cytolysis, in a normal
functioning immune system. (Early disease). MM is an immunogenic tumor.
- Anti-retroviral therapy will give
reduction of IL-2 gene expression, which will give a normal c-myc transcript and cell
apoptosis. (This seems to be the most feasable option and the one which will now be
vigorously investigated)
- A superantagonist for TGF- 1 and IL-2
will help our cause a lot.
- Upregulation of hetrodimer BAX
associated with downregulation of BCL-2 and BCL-Xl.
- BAD and ICE molecules are there to be
used when necessary.
- Fas antigen stimulation.
The Multiple myeloma cells are mostly
still intact enough to realize that they have to undergo cell death. This is evident by
the expression of high levels of activation markers, but the pathways effecting PCD are
not functioning. Lets help them.
|