Indeed, acid-attack victims typically see their lives all
but ruined. Many are forced to give up school and work, and
the recovery is long and expensive. In Bangladesh, a poor
and conservative Islamic country, marriage--usually arranged--means
economic survival for many women. A burned girl, considered
unmarriageable, will often be rejected by her own family.
She is expected to live her life in a state of shame, her
face covered by a veil. She is not expected to speak out.
Bina has defied all these expectations.
Acid
attacks have been on the rise in Bangladesh since the first
was reported in 1976. Naripokkho, a Dhaka-based women's activist
organization founded in 1983, began in 1996 to track acid
violence reported in local papers. The number--47 that year--surged
to 130 two years later. In April 1997, Naripokkho sponsored
a workshop for acid survivors. Bina, then 15, was among nine
participants: Selina, 11, was the youngest, and Monira, 18,
the eldest. Six girls, including Bina, were burned in incidents
involving rejected suitors--the most common scenario--while
two were burned by their husbands for not obtaining larger
dowries. When Nargis, 14, refused to become her neighbor's
second wife, he sprayed her genitals with acid while she was
in the bathroom that she and her brother shared with the neighbor's
family.
This
brutal form of "If I cannot have her, no one will" is not
just a problem in Bangladesh. In a widely reported U.S. case,
in 1986 two men slashed a Manhattan model, Marla Hanson, in
the face. Hanson's landlord, Steven Roth, a television makeup
artist whose overtures Hanson had rejected, orchestrated the
attack after Hanson broke her lease early and demanded the
return of her rent deposit. In June 1998, the Milwaukee Journal
Sentinel related that a man hired a woman to throw acid on
his ex-girlfriend. Other attacks, motivated primarily by a
woman's rejection of a man's advances, have been reported
in Egypt, England, India, Italy, Jamaica, Malaysia, Nigeria,
and Vietnam.
Nasreen
Huq, the Naripokkho women's health project coordinator, says
acid violence is usually targeted at young, beautiful women.
"The motivation is revenge. In Bangladesh, an exchange of
looks, or just the fact that a man likes a woman, means to
him that she is obligated to like or love him." As Bina says,
"If a girl says no to a marriage proposal, the boy thinks,
'I'm a good husband, I have everything. How can she not marry
me?' They are so angry--they think, 'How dare she? Well, I
will destroy her life.'" At Naripokkho's 1997 meeting, which
gave birth to a nationwide campaign against acid violence,
Bina stood out. Her outspokenness and courage inspired the
other girls to share their stories and take off the veils
that hid their scars.
A
Naripokkho publication summarizing the event credits Bina
for her "determination that the workshop not only be for grieving,
but an occasion for joyous celebration because they were alive
and life was still worth living." Soon after the conference,
Bina was named head of Naripokkho's acid advocacy program.
She
and others working against acid violence have their work cut
out for them. There are few services for victims (the sole
public burn unit in Bangladesh has eight cots reserved for
women), and little legal recourse. Though Bangladesh law calls
for the death penalty when acid throwing results in death
or permanent facial damage, only a handful of perpetrators
have been tried. In Bina's case, after she brought charges,
community elders began bullying her uncle. She says, "I went
to them and said, 'Why are you talking to my uncle? I filed
the case.'" Local officials never arrested Dano; ultimately
Bina's family was forced to move. Bina believes that "many
stories never come out because the attacker says, 'We have
money, you cannot hurt us,' or 'If you give this to the paper,
we'll do worse things.'"
As
the head of Naripokkho's acid program, Bina's immediate priorities
are providing services for victims and raising public awareness.
She tracks acid incidents reported in Bangladesh and abroad,
corresponds with survivors, counsels hospital patients, and
documents survivors' stories for publication. She travels
throughout the country to address public gatherings about
her experience and to visit survivors who cannot afford the
trip to Dhaka. Nasreen Huq remembers Bina's first public speaking
engagement. "We took her to Patharghata, on World Youth Day
in 1997. She gave an electrifying speech--the entire town
heard it because speakers were set up in the main square.
The town embraced Bina. They kept saying, 'If we are staring
at you, it's because we cannot imagine how cruel and inhuman
a person can be.'"
UNICEF
chose Bina to attend the Children's Leadership Conference
in New York in July 1998. The trip--Bina's first abroad--was
enlightening. She says, "I thought abuse and torture were
only in Bangladesh. Everybody had similar stories." When she
returned from New York, she resolved never to cover her face
again. "I used to wear a veil, but now I don't want to hide
anything," she says. "What happened to me isn't my fault.
When people see me, they will realize the consequences of
acid throwing."
Naripokkho
distributes leaflets that explain what to do in the event
of an acid attack. "I met a girl who went to take an exam,
and some boys threw acid on her," Bina says. "She put water
on her face and the burns weren't so bad. The next day, she
went back to school to take her exam. She came to Naripokkho
to thank me." Perhaps the most difficult, and rewarding, part
of Bina's job is counseling victims. This work begins in the
hospital when victims arrive for treatment. Bina visits and
encourages each patient throughout the surgery and recovery
process. Huq says, "Every time Bina counsels a victim, in
a way she's reliving her own experience. Many times, she'll
come back to the office and cry."
Bina
is a role model for girls who have been attacked. "She has
given everybody courage," Huq says. "Other girls come to our
office and see Bina laughing and joking, and they cannot believe
it. They want to be like her." A support group meets weekly
at Naripokkho's offices in downtown Dhaka. At one such meeting,
Bina--radiant in a gold-trimmed tangerine sari, her hair swept
back in a pony tail--was surrounded by three giggling girls.
Their scars varied from blistered flecks to the total absence
of smooth flesh, but their shared experience joined them in
a chilling sorority.
In
November 1998, a Spanish company flew six acid victims to
Valencia for cosmetic surgery. Huq says, "Bina was offered
a place, but she felt other people needed it more than she.
She was also scared." Bina acknowledges her fear: "Every time
I went for an operation, I felt like I was dying. I'm scared
to go through it again. I have to get an operation so my eyes
are better--then I can concentrate on education. "Knowing
I'm helping other people gives me the strength to continue
my work," she says. "A lot of guys I see in the streets are
scared of me now."
Liz
Welch is a freelance writer based in New York City.