Chapter Seven:

Civilizations of Late Rome, Byzantium,  and the Early Medieval West

 

We must always remember that swinging pendulum of HUMANISM.

 

As we have seen, just about every society begins with strict, conservative rules.  Next, the pendulum shifts to the middle and increased freedom and humanism produces a golden period of art and culture.  Invariably, that freedom and humanism seems to lead to corruption, then revolution, then to a new society which starts off as strictly conservative as the old one.

 

Case in point: Christian Rome

(Ichthys

Early Christian symbol of a fish. Greek for fish is an acrostic for Jesus, Christ, God, Son, Saviour)

 

After years of intolerance and persecution from others, once the Christian Church becomes established in the Roman Empire, the pendulum of humanism immediately swings to the right and all other religions are considered “pagan” and no longer tolerated.

 

Leading, in the 16th century, to the infamous Spanish Inquisition

 

With the empire divided into two halves, east and west, there was a great deal of infighting among the various rulers (Tetrarchs).  Then prior to the Battle of the Milvian Bridge (312), Emperor Constantine I had a vision.

 

He saw the Chi-Rho symbol painted on the shields of his soldiers.

 

Parts of the Chi-Rho symbol: Christ, Man, Woman, Child

 

The Battle was won.

 

Shortly thereafter, Constantine issued The Edict of Milan (313) which ended persecution of Christians forever and gave them legal recognition.

            By 395, most Romans had become Christian.

 

The first major dispute in Christianity: Arius (Christ, as the son of God was a lesser deity.) and Athanasius (Christ is basically the same being as God.)  This was argued in Nicaea in 325.  The council supported Athanasius and wrote The Nicene Creed, but Arianism divided the church for decades after.

 

The Nicene Creed

            We believe in one God, the Father, the Almighty, maker of heaven and earth, of all that is, seen and unseen.

            We believe in one Lord, Jesus Christ, the only Son of God, eternally begotten of the Father, God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made, of one Being with the Father. Through him all things were made. For us and for our salvation he came down from heaven: by the power of the Holy Spirit he became incarnate from the Virgin Mary, and was made man. For our sake he was crucified under Pontius Pilate; he suffered death and was buried. On the third day he rose again in accordance with the Scriptures; he ascended into heaven and is seated at the right hand of the Father. He will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead, and his kingdom will have no end.

            We believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, the giver of life, who proceeds from the Father and the Son. With the Father and the Son he is worshiped and glorified. He has spoken through the Prophets.

            We believe in one holy catholic and apostolic Church.

            We acknowledge one baptism for the forgiveness of sins.

            We look for the resurrection of the dead, and the life of the world to come. Amen.

 

            By the reign of Theodosius (379—395), Christianity had become the state religion of the Roman Empire, and non-Christian temples were destroyed, their religions forced to go underground. 

            The arts had to follow Christian edicts, and secular art virtually disappeared, although most works were based on classical Greek and Roman principles.

 

            The Fathers of the Church: Ambrose (340-397), Jerome (340-420), and Augustine (354-430)

 

            Saint Ambrose:

Preacher, teacher, bible student of renown, and writer of liturgical hymns. He stood firm against pagans and Arians. His preaching helped convert Saint Augustine, whom Ambrose baptized and brought into the Church. Ambrose's preaching brought Emperor Theodosius to do public penance for his sins. He called and chaired several theological councils during his time as bishop, many devoted to fighting heresy.

 

            Saint Jerome:

Monk. Lived for years as a hermit in the Syrian deserts. Reported to have drawn a thorn from a lion's paw; the animal stayed loyally at his side for years. Priest. Student of Saint Gregory of Nazianzen. Secretary to Pope Damasus I who commissioned him to revise the Latin text of the Bible. The result of his 30 years of work was the Vulgate translation, which is still in use.

 

            Saint Augustine

A rather wild child, Augustine was converted to Christianity by St. Ambrose, became Bishop of Hippo, in Africa, and a most influential author, (Confessions (autobiography) and City of God). He leaves behind him 218 letters and 500 sermons.

            In the year 430, he died praying while the Roman Empire collapsed in confusion and attack.

 

            Although western Rome fell to the northern tribes in 476, Constantine had long since moved its capital to the east, to a city he named Constantinople.  This eastern empire (called the Byzantine) thrived for a thousand years, developing a civilization that was racially and ethnically more diverse than the Roman, and far more Greek than Roman, eventually replacing Latin with Greek and creating its own Greek Orthodox Church.

 

            The Hagia Sophia

            The Church of Hagia Sophia was also the Cathedral of the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople for more than one thousand years. Originally known as the Great Church, because of its large size in comparison with the other churches of the then Christian World, it was later given the name of Hagia Sophia.  (Sophia, which means "Holy Wisdom", was a name given to Christ by 4th century theologians.)

            View from the South.  The thrust of the huge dome is countered by the two half-domes and the smaller domes, to the east and west, and the massive buttresses to the north and south.

            Hagia Sophia Interior.  Four arches swing across the piers, linked by four pendentives.  The apices of the arches and the pendentives support the circular base of the huge central dome.

            The Hagia Sophia contains many examples of Byzantine Art, which tends to have these characteristics: religious in theme (by subject or implication); flat (an Asian influence), ornate (especially with gold), and a rather disproportionate sense of anatomy, probably due to the superhuman status of holy figures.  The Christ child is often depicted as a baby with an adult face.  Images are usually dour, lacking in amusement, reflecting the seriousness of the religion.

 

            The lunette is decorated with a superb mosaic composition of the enthroned Virgin and Child flanked by Constantine the Great, who presents a model of the city and Justinian who offers a model of the Church.

 

            The mosaic which is in the north gallery shows Alexander clad in full imperial regalia adorned with precious gems.

 

            Mosaic depicting the Empress Zoe (1028-1050) and her third husband, Constantine IX Monomachus (1042-1055), presenting to the enthroned Christ a bag containing gold coins and a scroll inscribed with a list of donations.  The composition, illustrates in a most eloquent manner, the association of the Byzantine Emperors with the Great Church.

 

            Mosaic of the Emperor John II Comnenus (1118-1143) and his consort Irene presenting a bag of gold coins and a scroll inscribed with a list of donations to the Theotokos.  (Θεοτοκος is a Greek word usually translated "Mother of God." )

 

            The oldest surviving mosaic in Hagia Sophia is that of the Virgin enthroned, “the living throne of Christ Pantocrator,” with the Christ Child in her lap. 

 

            Here are a few other Byzantine icons, as well as a few works from the early Renaissance that were modeled on Byzantine works.

            The 10th-century Fedorovskaya icon from Kostroma

            Bernado Daddi,     1290-1349.   Madonna and Child

            Giotto. Madonna and Child with St. Nicholas, St. John the Evangelist, St. Peter and St. Benedict (Badia Polyptych). c.1300.

           

            A good example of symbolic realism.  Justinian is depicted here with 12 supporters and a halo. (Text picture)

 

            With the fall of the western Roman Empire and the political confusion that followed, monasticism  became an important part of Christianity, providing a solid, dependable religious center in a changing world.

            Monasticism was integral to Byzantine life. From the fourth century, after the founding of the first monastic institution in Constantinople, Dalmatou, monasteries proliferated throughout town and country.

 

            St. Catherine monastery on Mount Sinai, founded by Justinian between the years 548-565, said to be built on the historical site of the burning bush.

 

            Monasticism spread quickly to western Europe. The Rule of Saint Benedict, compiled in the first half of the sixth century, laid the foundation for the form of monastic life most commonly practiced there. The rule—with its stress on moderation, obedience to the monastery's leader (the abbot), and a prescribed program of prayer, work, and study—synthesized many of the teachings of the desert hermits and early Christian writers.

 

            The Cuxa Cloister, mid-12th century
French or Spanish; From the Abbey of Saint-Michel-de-Cuxa (modern France)

 

            Monasteries were the homes of great art and beautifully copied manuscripts.

 

            Chora Monastery (Kariye Camii), Constantinople, mosaic of Theodore Metochites presenting a model of the Church of the Chora to Christ, from the inner narthex, 1316–21

 

            Studenica Monastery, Church of Saints Joachim and Anna, Kraljevo, Serbia, fresco painting of the Birth of the Virgin, 1313–14.

 

            Before the printing press, illuminated (illustrated) books were the great art of the early medieval period.

 

            Page from an Illuminated Gospel, early 15th century
Ethiopia, Lake Tana region

 

            Plaque with Saint John the Evangelist, early 9th century; Early Medieval Carolingian; Made in Aachen of Elephant ivory

 

            Leaf from the Epistle to the Hebrews, 12th century (1101)
Byzantine; Found in Meteora, Greece (before 1898)
Tempera, gold, and ink on parchment.

 

            Leaf from a Manuscript: Christ in Majesty with Angels and the Angel of God Directs Saint John to Write the Book of Revelation, ca. 1180

 

            Bifolium, from a Manuscript of the Decretals of Gratian, ca. 1290

 

            Among the books copied in the monasteries was The Book of Kells, a copy of the four Gospels in Latin. It is known for the extraordinary array of pictures, interlaced shapes and ornamental details. It is thought to have been the work of several individual scribes over many years, likely before A.D. 806. Held at Kells until 1661, it was moved to Dublin where it remains as the chief treasure of Trinity College Library. A 13th century scholar, Giraldus Cambrensis, writes of the Book of Kells "... you might believe it was the work of an angel rather than a human being". 

           

Charlemagne

742 - 814

            Charlemagne was determined to bring order to Europe. In 772 he launched a 30-year military campaign to accomplish this objective. By 800 Charlemagne was the undisputed ruler of Western Europe. His vast realm encompassed what are now France, Switzerland, Belgium, and The Netherlands. It included half of present-day Italy and Germany, and parts of Austria and Spain. By establishing a central government over Western Europe, Charlemagne restored much of the unity of the old Roman Empire and paved the way for the development of modern Europe.

 

            Alcuin of York was appointed head of Charlemagne's Palace School at Aachen and there he developed the Carolingian minuscule, a clear script which has become the basis of the way the letters of the present Roman alphabet are written. Before leaving Aachen, Alcuin was responsible for the most precious of Carolingian codices, now called the Golden Gospels. These were a series of illuminated masterpieces written largely in gold, often on purple colored vellum.

 

            Carolingian minuscule separated words more clearly, used capital letters at the start of sentences, and periods at the end.  It made writing much more easily read.

 

            Music, in this period, like everything else, was strictly devoted to the Church.  The earliest medieval music is named after Pope Gregory and is called the Gregorian Chant.  Used in the Mass and sung by men only, without accompaniment, this music used a single line of melody and had an impersonal, unemotional quality to it.

            Kyrie: Hodie Christus Resurrexit

 

            Later, by the ninth century, a second line of music was added, making it polyphonic.  This gave a whole new depth and intensity to the mass.

            Josquin Desprez: “Ave Maria . . . Virgo Serena”

 

 

            With strict church rules, and most of life subordinate to the church, there was little room for creative man, for humanism.  Any kind of creativity or individual thought could be called “heresy” and punished severely.

            But humankind cannot be held down forever.  The creative human mind must have its outlet, then as now.

 

            Jean-Francois Millet, “Man with a Hoe” 1863

 

            Hidden away, in the hearts of humans, are stories and myths, songs, and other religions.  (Stonehenge)

 

            One myth which has lasted is the oldest story we have in English (Anglo-Saxon), Beowulf.

            From Bullfinch's Mythology: “ALTHOUGH the manuscript which contains the epic of Beowulf was written about 1000 A.D., the poem itself was known and had been elaborated upon for centuries by minstrels who recited the heroic exploits of the son of Ecgtheow and nephew of Hygelac, King of the Geats, whose kingdom was what is now Southern Sweden.
            In his boyhood Beowulf gave evidence of the great feats of strength and courage which in manhood made him the deliverer of Hrothgar, King of Denmark, from the monster, Grendel, and later in his own kingdom from the fiery dragon which dealt Beowulf a mortal blow.”

 

            Obviously, by the time the oral tale of the pagan Beowulf had been set down in writing concessions had to be made for a Christian audience. 

            Other arts would soon break through, especially the theatre, which only awaited a nod from church officials to begin again.

            The trigger for many changes in European culture would be The Crusades.