Origional Broadway Cast
| Alonzo | Hector Jamie Mercado |
| Asparagus/Growltiger | Stephen Hanan |
| Bombalurina | Donna King |
| Carbucketty | Steven Gelfer |
| Cassandra | Rene Ceballos |
| Coricopat/Mungojerrie | Rene Clemente |
| Demeter | Wendy Edmead |
| Etcetera/Rumpelteazer | Christine Langner |
| Grizabella | Betty Buckley |
| Jellylorum/Griddlebone | Bonnie Simmons |
| Jennyanydots | Anna McNeely |
| Mistoffelees | Timothy Scott |
| Munkustrap | Harry Gronener |
| Old Deuteronomy | Ken Page |
| Plato/Macavity | Kenneth Ard |
| Pouncival | Herman W. Sebek |
| Rum Tum Tugger | Terrence V. Mann |
| Sillabub | Whitney Kershaw |
| Skimbleshanks | Reed Jones |
| Tantomile | Janet L. Hubert |
| Tumblebrutus | Robert Hoshour |
| Victoria | Cynthia Onrubia |
| The Cats Chorus |
Walter Charles Susan Powers Carol Richards Joel Robertson |
*Mungojerrie and Rumpelteazer were nothing like what they are today! Here they are two puppets created by Mistoffelees in order to tell a story to Bustopher Jones. Coricopat and Etcetera were the kitties in costume*
*Etcetera was eventually replaced on Broadway by a full-time Rumpelteazer when the Notorious Duo became actual cats*
*Mistoffelees was still doing most of the narration of the story, including the entire Invitation to the Jellicle Ball and The Old Gumbie Cat, but Munkustrap was starting to gain some ground, being one of only two cats (Tugger being the other) to sing Old Deuteronomy*
