Question:

It is my understanding that Christ died so that we be free of the wrath deserving of such a sinful lot as we are.  I understand that does not absolve us from the responsibility to avoid sinning, or to repent and have faith in Christ.  However, what happened to all of the people who sinned and dies before Christ was born?  Since sin is inherent in our natures, isn’t it somewhat unfair to condemn some and spare others when all of out sins are ultimately the same?  And if they have been condemned, it was surely no oversight; after all, this is God we’re talking about.  He doesn’t require a warm-up to get it right.  So could you please answer this for me?  Were some people intentionally condemned, and others spared through Christ?  If so, why?

Response:
 

These are good questions.  Others have provided solid answers, but allow me to add my $0.02 worth.  I see three questions in your post, and I will attempt to answer all three.

                                  

1.        What happened to all of the people who sinned and died before Christ was born?

 

God doesn't exist in time and space like we do.  The cross of Christ was the focal point of all history.  People who lived before the cross looked forward to the cross for salvation.  All throughout the Old Testament are signs and pointers to Christ and His sacrifice.  Those who placed their faith in God and His word had that faith vindicated at the cross.  You can say the same thing for us who live 2,000 years later.  We weren't even born when Jesus dies, yet our faith in Christ and what He did, in effect, places us right there at the cross.  Our faith looks backward to the cross, and the OT saints' faith looks backward to the cross.  The key in all this is faith. God has always saved people on the basis of their faith in Him.

 

2.        Since sin is "inherent" in our natures... isn't it somewhat unfair to condemn some and spare others, when all of our "sins" are ultimately the same?

 

This is a trickier question, but here goes.  Sin wasn't inherent in the natures of Adam & Eve.  They were created sinless. Sin became a reality when they disobeyed God in the garden.  What happened when they sinned was a twofold penalty:  1) They were going to die physically; and 2) they died spiritually (i.e., their human nature became corrupt).  This corrupt human nature was passed down to their progeny--this is what many call inherent sin.

 

Now everyone born since Adam & Eve were born sinners.  As the old saying goes:  We aren't sinners because we sin, we sin because we're sinners.  Each person is born guilty in the eyes of God's perfect justice.  How do we prove this?  Simple, from the earliest moments of life children are completely selfish.  We constantly have to tell them "No."  At some point in every child's life, that unintentional selfishness turns into willful disobedience; that's the sin nature at work.

 

The Bible is very clear on this:

 

·        Romans 3:23 - All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.

·        Romans 6:23 - The wages of sin is death.

 

If all people sin, then it is not unfair to condemn all people to death, right?  Everyone who sins gets what they deserve when they die.  However, God's grace kicks in when He offers a way out of this conundrum.  God offers mercy and grace (which, by definition, are things that are given, not earned) to those who place their faith in Jesus Christ.  Jesus Christ bore God's wrath against sin on the cross.  In other words, He died vicariously for those who place their faith in Him.  If you have faith in Jesus Christ, then it is as if you were there on the cross--your sin penalty has been paid in full.  We don't deserve this, it was done by God out love.  So to answer your question:  No, it is not unfair.

 

1.        Were some people intentionally condemned, and others spared through Christ?  And if so, why?

 

This is perhaps the most difficult question to answer.  Not because the answer is hard to find, but because the answer is hard to accept.  Let me start by saying that God far exceeds our human comprehension.  In Deuteronomy 29:29 it says, "The secret things belong to God, but the things revealed belong to us."  In the Bible, God has revealed certain things. These are the things we know about God.  However, there are things that God has kept to Himself, not because He's cruel and doesn't want us to know, but because there is no way our human understanding can come to grips with these things.

 

For example, the Bible clearly states that God is working all things out according to His plan and will; yet the Bible doesn't spell that plan out. The Bible also clearly states that salvation is a work of God done in the hearts of men, yet it also speaks of us being offered a choice to accept the call of the gospel.  The Bible doesn't explain how those two seemingly contradictory truths come together.  This is what theologians call a paradox.  The Bible asserts two truths that the human mind cannot piece together.  Yet I believe in a God whose wisdom and intelligence far exceeds mine, so If I cannot figure it out, I know He can.

 

Here's what I know for sure.  We're all sinners, and because of this, God rightly condemns us to judgment.  I look back on my life before Christ, and all I see is a pattern of willful disobedience; no one made me sin, I did so willingly.  I also know that God draws people from their sin to Jesus (cf. John 6:44).  I distinctly remember a time when I renounced my sin and turned to Christ, yet not two months before I would have had nothing to do with the Bible and Christ.  I now understand that it was God working through His word to change my heart and mind--God's word has the power to change a life.  I also know that God's sovereign choice in salvation always works in conjunction with a person's acceptance by faith--God's choosing and our believing always go hand-in-hand.  If God chooses to pass over some people and leave them in their sin, that is His choice.  He is not treating anybody unfairly.  The Bible says in Romans chapter 1, that everybody has enough knowledge to make an informed decision to accept and believe in God, yet we all suppress this knowledge and reject it.  If we reject the gospel, we have no excuse.

 

I hope this helps!

Back to Q & A homepage.