A Visit To Iraq
by Raed Battah
In late June, 1999 my dreams came true. After routinely scanning
the headlines and making the usual
stops at the popular antiwar sites on the Internet, I found a
hit. I made a desperate attempt to reach a
Chicago-based organization called Voices in the Wilderness. Voices
in the Wilderness is a nonviolent
activist group that is leading a campaign to end economic sanctions
against Iraq. Since 1996, Voices in
the Wilderness (VITW) has sent nearly 30 delegations to Iraq,
including a group of US Congressional
aides, the first government representatives to visit Iraq since
the Gulf War. VITW organizes teach-ins,
marches, fasts, vigils, and meetings with government officials.
VITW provides its delegates an invaluable
tool for gaining information related to sanctions and for witnessing
first hand the effects of sanctions at
the most personal levels.
Normally there is a little down time in receiving responses from
VITW. Many more people these days
are learning about the situation in Iraq, and they want to get
involved. VITW is one of the most effective
ways to get involved. Because delegations are usually kept to
relatively small numbers (my delegation
would have seven members) there can be a little bit of a wait
to be accepted to a delegation. However,
with a little luck and a highly impassioned letter, I received,
remarkably, a response just a few hours
after submitting my e-mailed letter.
Kathy Kelly, co-founder of VITW, phoned me shortly after I returned
home from the computer lab where I
sent her my e-mail. She told me that two spots were open but
seven people were ahead of me with their
requests. However, due to my sincere letter, Kathy told me she
felt that I deserved to go. Kathy
remembered me from a speech she gave in Detroit to a reunion
of graduates from Al-Hikma University in
Baghdad, which my father attended. It had been one year since
I approached her and asked that she
not forget my face because I would call on her to offer my assistance
as soon as I finished my
broadcasting degree. I ended up staying a bit longer to finish
a political science degree, strictly for
academic credibility when I took the sanctions issue to the political
table.
Earlier, I had found myself at the computer one day, especially
frustrated at the situation. It could have
been any number of things: a new bombing in the no-fly zones,
the report of an outbreak of cholera, the
new figures on infant mortality, or the effects of the worst
drought in Iraq’s history as a nation. I was
especially troubled and told myself: "Just go! Nothing can be
more important. You can’t sleep. You
can’t concentrate. Just go!"
Since my father is a physician I was fortunate enough to solicit
lots of medicine to take to the Iraqi
people. He also contacted two Indian doctors who were happy to
donate updated medical textbooks
(prohibited by sanctions). With a suitcase full of life, and
a spirit full of compassion, I prepared to make
the biggest, most illegal decision of my life. Sanctions prohibit
the transportation of goods to and from
Iraq outside the determined "Food-for-Oil" deal. The penalty
for engaging in such actions is the threat of
imprisonment for up to twelve years and $1.2 million in fines.
I was breaking a number of federal laws just crossing state lines
with a suitcase full of illegal drugs,
mostly prescription. What is really interesting is that I had
no trouble boarding a plane in Detroit and
flying to Chicago with all these medications. What is still more
shocking is that no one ever checked
the suitcase in Chicago either. I was a little disappointed because
the whole point was to openly violate
the sanctions laws.
The other members of my delegation included Tom Sager, a computer
science teacher at the University
of Illinois, Ramsey Kysia, an American-Lebanese businessman and
photographer, Stacia Crezynski, a
teacher from New Mexico, Chris Allen Doucot, a seasoned delegate
leader from Boston, Dave
Rollstone, a ship builder from Wales, Great Britain, and another
Brit, Joanne Baker, an aroma-therapist
and teacher from London. I rounded out the group as the youngest
and only Iraqi.
Tom, Stacia, and I met in Chicago and flew together to Jordan
where we met the rest of the group,
except for Chris who was waiting for us in Baghdad. After a brief
two-day stay in Amman, where we
finalized some border papers and cleared up some things with
the Foreign Ministry, we set out across
the desert. My eyes close and I still can see that amazing barren
sacred desert that witnessed many of
the greatest stories of the Bible. Worth noting is the otherwise
impassable region which historically
represents the sites of Sodom and Gomorrah. For miles and miles
it is nothing but black, razor sharp,
bowling ball sized rocks that send the mind into a whirlwind
of speculation. For thousands of years this
region has remained untouched, presumably damned by God for the
sins of its early inhabitants.
Crossing the desert is a very unique experience. For miles it
is flat, then it turns into desert hills with
rocky cliffs. Growing up in Western Kentucky there was a strange
similarity in that it is common to
catch several deer crossing an old country road, but a big difference
in seeing a herd of wild camels just
easing on across the only paved road in a hundred mile radius.
Shepherds and their flocks of both
camel and sheep could be seen as well all through the desert.
I mean these folks just live out there,
completely self-sufficient and untouched by modernization. At
the Iraq-Jordan Border, a place called
Trebil, my group was cordially placed in a big sitting room which
displayed a giant mosaic of Saddam
Hussein on one wall. It was exciting to see because I had read
about this picture in several other
journalists’ accounts of traveling to Iraq, such by Brent Sadler
of CNN. This room is normally reserved
for diplomats and government officials, not transits. However,
Voices has made several trips to Iraq in
the past and has developed what you could call diplomatic relations.
So there I was, a diplomat taking a two hour nap in front of a
giant portrait of the world's last great
enemy. I slept just fine. I recall meeting two young boys who
were in that room. Their names were Ali
and Kasib. They were traveling from Baghdad to Amman. They were
12 and 14 years old, respectively. I
lost a few games of chess to all of them before discovering that
they were child chess champions
traveling to Jordan for a tournament. I gave them a few Snickers
bars and they kind of looked at them as
if they were alien. Have you ever seen a child smell a Snickers
bar? They hadn't ever seen one!
Our approval at the border came quickly due to our status and
the couple of cases of Shasta cola we
brought for leverage. The second half of the trip across the
desert I rode with Sattar Al-Jihad, who, unlike
his brother driving the other truck, could speak English. He
was a civil engineer who made his living
driving taxis from Baghdad to Amman. He was married and had two
children. I wish the reader could
have been there for that eight hour trip; I must have asked every
kind of question about Iraq, and he
always had an incredible answer. We became very close, and for
the first time in my life I had an
authentic Iraqi friend. Sattar explained to me that common daily
tasks in the US are monumental
achievements in Iraq. For instance, driving from one place to
another without the vehicle breaking down,
or having enough sugar to make a cake, or giving your wife an
anniversary present, or your child a
birthday gift.
When we reached Baghdad, it was almost overwhelming. My whole
family was waiting for me at the
hotel after having waited all day and the day before. They were
expecting me a day early but our papers
got held up. Some were missing. My aunt Khemi, the wife of my
mother’s brother had died nearly a
year earlier because she had no access to an athsma inhaler.
My cousin Behegia who had died from
heart failure was also absent. But their families were there
greeting me with tears and hugs. I had made
it home, to fight for all these people who were greeting me with
tears, who lived the nightmare that I
could only read about in America. Gena (19), Genevea (23), and
Julia (8) are the daughters of aunt
Khemi. All were there crying, overjoyed to see me -- the first
light they had had since their mother
abruptly died of athsma. 81-year-old uncle George couldn't make
it to the hotel. This small giant of the
Battah family, formerly known as "King of the Dates" because
of his chief involvement of the import and
export date business, waited at the house my father built over
thirty years earlier. His achievements are
incredible considering he was a Christian, a school dropout,
and had never married. He is perhaps the
greatest example of sacrifice in the Battah family.
Somewhere between all the family at the hotel, my group met Chris
Allen Doucot. Chris was our group
leader, a Canadian/Bostonian. He was a cross between a cynic
and an anarchist, but very organized,
and very official. You should hear the ringing of a Bostonian
accent in the office of the Iraqi
Under-Secretary Minister of Health. Chris did most of the coordinating
for our group. He was the main
liason with the Iraqi Red Crescent Society, which appointed minders
to our group on official visits. The
minders were never threatening -- they were usually simple people
who could translate and tell us small
significant do's and don't’s. Don't’s usually included taking
pictures of bridges or other government
buildings or from cars. The Iraqis were under a lot of stress
because of the on-going bombing taking
place in the north and south.
The bombing campaign had started December 16, 1998, after UNSCOM
Chief Weapons Inspector
Richard Butler declared Iraq as non-compliant. Iraq claimed the
current inspectors were spies.
UNSCOM inspectors, specifically U.S. and British, were later
confirmed to have been operating covertly
through the weapons inspection regime. The US, British, and Secretary
General of the UN all confirmed
these allegations. So Iraq was bombed for assuming the truth.
And the bombing was a bilateral action
that was condemned by the other three members of the security
council. What is sad is that even
today, mainstream media speaks of the bombing campaign in the
past tense even though US and
British planes have continued to bomb Iraq on nearly a day to
day basis, killing hundreds of Kurds in the
North and Shias in the South, the same people the U.S. claims
to be defending by creating the "no-fly"
zones.
So I didn't mind -- and actually appreciated -- the motive behind
being a little careful on Iraq's part. Iraq's
sovereignty and national integrity had been marginalized through
the actions of UNSCOM, especially
considering the trouble that Kofi Annan had gone through in February
of 1998 to get them back.
Referring to the extent at which Iraq had allowed international
inspectors in, Chief Coordinator for the
986 (Food-for-Oil) Program, Hans Von Sponeck said, "The Iraqis
have been completely undressed. It is
humiliating. Try and see if any such action would be acceptable
in a western state."
Although VITW made arrangements in a local hotel, I decided to
only use this as a base. Every night I
stayed at a relative's home. One night with my father's family,
one night with my mother's family, and so
on. Every morning at 8am we would meet and go through the day's
schedule. Activities, which usually
took all day, were completely optional. If one chose to abstain
from a meeting they were perfectly
welcome. A typical day usually went like this: by 10am we were
heading to the Red Crescent to meet
our minder. Each day there was usually a scheduled trip to a
hospital. At hospitals we would first be
briefed by a medical supervisor who explained the condition of
the facility, then discussed common
operating problems as a result of short supplies. Then the tours
would begin.
It is unfair to those people for me to even try to recreate in
black and white the conditions of these
hospitals, and the environment for the patients. Common were
paint chipping off walls, the smell of piss
and shit, broken windows throughout, almost suffocating heat,
sheetless hospital beds, fly tape over
patient beds, fecal contamination in the tap, non-existing pharmacies
(picture an empty closet), and the
unnerving screams of suffering children, grief stricken mothers,
and helpless doctors. It is the end of the
world in those hospitals, the end. One would think that your
chances are better off dying than extending
such a miserable life. The first doctor I met at the Saddam's
Pediatric Teaching Hospital was named
Raed. He was the chief resident and the first person other than
myself that I had ever known with that
name. Raed was just a student when Saddam invaded Kuwait. He
knows only the theoretical procedure
for curration, and has very little applicable knowledge.
Medical texts have been prohibited, along with computers, and
most of the essential elements of a
high-tech, highly effective medical facility. They don't even
have working centrifuge machines to separate
blood platelets. They are mixing regular table salt and tap water
to make I.V. fluid, leading to all kinds of
recurrences of water-borne infectious diseases. We were given
the opportunity to ask many of the
mothers in the hospital if they wanted us to relay any message.
Most of them said the same thing,
"What has my child done to make America want to kill him? Why
can't my child live a happy peaceful
life like American children? Would Americans do this if they
knew how our children suffer? Is our oil
worth our children's lives?" I knew most American didn't feel
that way. They didn't feel anyway; they
didn't even know those poor children were dying. That is why
I went: to find the truth.
Another very interesting experience was a trip to the main Baghdad
sewage facility, Rustameiya. I'm not
a sewage expert, but compared the local sewage plants here in
Kentucky, this was a monster. It
covered probably about five square football fields, serving three
purposes: filtering water, extracting
sewage, and converting sewage to fertilizer. However, the plant
was merely a functioning skeleton of a
once-grand system. Most of the oxygen generators, which helped
naturally breakdown organic waste,
were not functioning. Pumps to move water from phase to phase
were used to simply push the water
through the system then back into the river. It was simply depressing
to see such a facility get nothing
done, and to think about the consequences for the people miles
away in the city. Working at the facility
was a health hazard. The plant lost an average of two employees
a month due to hydrogen sulfide
poisoning. A young boy who worked there with his father was waste
deep with knee high boots in a pool
of, I guess, shit, scrubbing algae off the edges of a water churner.
For less than a combined $0.15 a
day, where is the dignity?
This same day we went to a water treatment facility, one of 18,
along the Tigris. Their purpose is to
apply chemicals to the water such as chlorine. The Iraqis never
used fluoride. However, chlorine is
prohibited under sanctions, and what is permitted to be ordered
through the 986 program is far less than
what is necessary to maintain efficient and effective operation
and usage. What is permitted to be used
is frequently held up by the sanctions 661 committee.
In addition to hospitals and civil facilities, we visited with
Iraqi and U.N. officials. The most significant of
these meetings was with Hans Von Sponeck, the Chief Coordinator
of the Humanitarian Program in
Iraq. Von Sponeck is a German who took the reins of the program
after his predecessor, Dennis
Halliday, resigned. Halliday left his post having said, "Sanctions
are killing an average of 6,000 children
a month. I no longer want to be a part of that." Von Sponeck
referred to his colleague’s actions with
understanding but vowed to continue to work to help make the
program more efficient. An outspoken
critic of the 661 committee’s policy of holding up orders, he
is working to inform people on the
misinformation concerning supply stocks and misuse. Von Sponeck
said that it is a combination of
delays, poor working conditions, lack of transportation, lack
of trained personnel, depressingly low
wages, inefficient inventory systems etc. etc.. He mentioned
the fact that his colleagues had requested
a computerized inventory system to help keep an accurate account
of orders, their whereabouts, and
quality controls. The sanctions committee refused the request
because sanctions prohibit computers
from entering Iraq. This deeply disturbed me.
I asked Semere Solomon, Assistant Coordinator of UNESCO if this
was practical. Doesn't the U.N.
personnel keep a log of product whereabouts? Solomon confirmed
this by saying that every item, pill,
pencil, paper, or whatever, is ordered on a "cum by cum" basis.
Every item brought in the country has a
specific destination and is closely monitored. So why can't they
give the U.N., not to mention schools,
hospitals, and industry, computers? The answer is to keep Iraq
primitive. Every day Iraq gets further and
further behind the developed world.
Von Sponeck -- a true diplomat -- was a man of integrity. He was
visually perturbed by the present
situation. He spoke of his wife and daughter who were working
in Germany to get the sanctions lifted.
Unfortunately, the US State Department isn't so pleased; spokesman
James P. Rubin said Von
Sponeck undermined his position and rendered himself unfit to
keep his position as 986 Coordinator.
On August 6 -- the anniversary of the imposition of sanctions
and the day that the United States
dropped an atomic bomb on Hiroshima -- five members of my group
went south to Basra. About 100
miles north of Basra, we stopped at a place called al-Qurna.
This little historic mother of pearl is
otherwise known as the "Garden of Eden". It is the place where
the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers meet to
form the Shat al-Arab. I could have sat there and watched those
rivers blend forever, despite the fact
that the temperature in southern Iraq is frightfully worse than
in Baghdad. How bad is it? Some time in
late July sit in your car with the windows up and the heat on
and put a blow dryer up to your face on
high. This is what it feels like with the windows down in a moving
car in southern Iraq. It was great! The
people are so strong to deal with such a natural adversity.
From Qurna we went on to Basra. Once again, when I arrived, my
family was waiting. My mother’s other
brother Jamaal lived in Basra on the largest petro-chemical complex
in Iraq. He is production manager
of this superplex, and his wife is a private practicing gynecologist.
They have four children. They live in
company housing because they can't afford to buy a home. (Imagine
the same family in the US and the
lifestyle they would enjoy.) He owned a small Volkswagen that
was given to him in the eighties by
Saddam Hussein for taking a bullet and some shrapnel in the Iraq-Iran
war.
In Basra we visited a refugee camp called Moe-Fuckia. It was a
huge stone building complex that was
designed and intended to house government workers. But construction
stopped nearly two thirds of the
way in because of the Iraq-Iran war. Now, it is home to nearly
15,000 refugee families, nearly 50,000
people. The complex is one big health hazard: open pools of raw
sewage, lack of water, doorless
balconies several stories high, no electricity, and its great
distance from any conceivable medical
facilities. The refugees were predominately Shia who were displaced
do to the fierce fighting that
occurred on the Iraq-Iran border in southern Basra. Many thousands
were Palestinian refugees, and the
others were made up of Kurds, vagrants, and Iranians. Iraq had
a very generous policy towards refugees
prior to 1990. Dr. Abid Amir, of UNHCR, said that, "Iraq is a
rich nation, was a rich nation, and had all
the goodwill to take care of these refugees. It is only now after
sanctions that they need our help." Iraq
would often permit refugees to integrate fully into society and
would provide 70 dinar a month for general
welfare. Prior to 1990 that was about $210. Now it is less than
$.04. Iraq still provides this 70 dinar a
month.
Also in Basra we visited a village called Jumhouriya. I was late
returning to the hotel the morning before
leaving for the village and subsequently missed my group. However,
to my surprise and delight, Hans
Von Sponeck himself showed up in the lobby of the Basra Sheraton.
He recognized me from our
previous meeting in Baghdad and insisted that I ride with them.
So there I was, climbing into those
damn white Range Rovers that you always see on CNN with Hans
and his little Indian entourage. I got
to speak briefly on a personal level with him and he told me
a little about his history and how diplomacy
runs in the family. Hans had traveled to Basra to visit Jumhouriya
and to make arrangements to rebuild
some of the destroyed houses. Jumhouriya was bombed in January
1999 with an AGM-130. This bomb
is satellite guided and accurate within ten meters. Unlike laser
guided bombs, weather does not affect
its heading. In addition the AGM-130 has an optical guidance
system which allows the pilot to precisely
guide the bomb. Even if the pilot loses contact with the bomb,
its satellite guidance should not fail it.
Technical failure or pure barbarism killed seven people that
day in the crowded village and destroyed 64
homes.
After returning to the hotel, I retired around 5 p.m. for a nap.
All day it was misery, misery, misery. You
couldn't imagine the horrible schedule of events. It seemed like
the complete opposite of reality.
Wherever there should be yes there is no, pleasure/pain, happiness/sadness,
health/death,
hope/disparity, anger/compassion, hate/love, revenge/forgiveness.
How was any of it possible? As I lay
in my bed in the hotel I hear all the families outside in the
pool trying to cool off and act somewhat
normal. My eyes closed, and with a sigh I heard the air raid
sirens ring through Basra. The Americans
were flying over. I was Iraqi. I was home. I was happy. My sacrifice
may have been at hand.
On the way back to Baghdad we stopped briefly in a town called
Amara. It is a poor, or poorer, town.
We briefly visited the hospital, saw your typical suffering humans,
long lost to the rest of the world,
thanked them for suffering for us, apologized and moved on. By
this time it was hard to be shocked
anymore.
We drove into Baghdad and straight to the UN compound. There were
our friends in a tent across from
the compound on what was a terribly busy highway. The tent had
English and Arabic slogans draped all
over it. Beat up cars whisking by would honk. I thought to myself
candidly about all those drivers who
passed and realized, as they drove by beating their steering
wheel, that their horns no longer worked. I
bet everyone was honking in their hearts. We all gathered at
the UN again the next day which was
August 9, the anniversary of the bombing of Nagasaki. We all
shared thoughts, poems, prayers, and
music. Some read from the Bible, particularly the Lamentations
of Jeremiah. Stacia read a beautiful
poem she wrote. I simply recited an old Pink Floyd lyric, "No
more turning away from the weak and the
weary. No more turning away from the coldness inside. Just a
world that we all must share, it's not
enough just to stand and stare. Is it only a dream that there'll
be no more turning away." I stood right
there and wished the hate away.
August 10 was our last full day. I met with Semere Solomon on
this day and some others met with
Farrid Zarrif, Assistant Coordinator of UNOHCI. I spent the remainder
of the day and that evening at
Uncle George's house where my family gathered to see me off.
It was then that a friend of the family
brought me his daughter Areege. Areege is 15 years old and suffers
from spinal scoliosis. She had a 15
degree curvature of the spine. The operation, if equipment was
available, would cost 15 million dinar.
This beautiful girl who looked no older than 11 spoke enough
English to say "thank you" as I promised
to try and help her here in the States. I have failed Areege;
I don't even have the courage to inquire about
her condition. I knew when I looked into her eyes that all I
could give her was false hope.
I returned to my uncle’s home and sat, mostly in silence, as time
ticked away. Sitting on that floor with
all those people I didn't know whether I wanted to bring them
home with me, or make Iraq a country one
need not escape from. People are fleeing in droves from the Garden,
and it's not because Saddam is
chasing them out. It's because sanctions have embargoed hope,
dreams, and ambition. It has worn
their spirits thin. It has created a cultural black whole that
Iraq will never forget. Iraqis aren't stupid,.
though our government’s stated policy would assume otherwise.
Madeline Albright has said that the US
State Department cares much more about Iraq's people than Saddam
-- the death of over 500,000
children and the impoverishment of millions of innocent and noble,
God-loving people must be “caring” to
the US.
In conclusion I want to dedicate this report to the people of
Iraq; I want to dedicate this entire
independent study to the children of Iraq and to those who died.
I did it all for them. I want to dedicate
my entire academic career, in both broadcasting and political
science, to the pursuit of truth and peace.
I want to thank the Department of Government for giving me this
opportunity and for helping me become
credible through its support. I hope that Eastern Kentucky University
doesn't soon forget its outspoken
Iraqi student. I hope that people will recall that there was
always a movement, albeit a small one,
against the genocidal sanctions on Iraq, even here in eastern
Kentucky. I hope that whatever number,
quote, fact, or image that may have made an impression on any
of my teachers burns into their memory
and that they share the reality of that truth to their students.
On behalf of Iraq, let me tell what the US
Government denies: the truth.
Myself and other members of Voices in the Wilderness, including
your Person of the Year, Kathy Kelly,
have been in D.C. for one month starting January 15th, Martin
Luther King Day and the anniversary of
the beginning of the Gulf War, doing a liquid-only fast and trying
to get Congressional reps to sign on to
the Tom Campbell/John Conyers letter to President Clinton asking
him to delink economic sanctions
from the military embargo. When we started, there were only 35
signatures, but our efforts have brought
that number up to 62. Our fast ended February 11th, and we will
travel to New York to do a
civil-disobedience rally in front of the U.N. building on February
14 to commemorate the cruise missle
bombing of the Al-Ameriyah bomb shelter during the Gulf War in
which 1,175. The action is called "We
Remember, We Resist." Speakers will include Kathy Kelly, Dennis
Halliday, John Dear and others.
--------
Raed Battah recently graduated from Eastern Kentucky University.
Copyright 1999 Raed Battah.