Welcome to "Missile Street" by Kathy Kelly
July 18, 2000--Word that our VOICES in the Wilderness Team
will
spend the hottest months of the year in Sunny Basra drew
hearty
laughter from our friends who work at a telephone/fax
center in
Baghdad: "We are going to send you home through the fax
machine!"
Upon arrival in Basra, July 15, we were each paired with
our host
family. The next morning, Mark McGuire’s summary statement
was:
"I’m immersed."
This dispatch will focus on the family that welcomed Ken
Hannaford-Ricardi into their home. Mr. Saadi, his wife
and their
seven children ages 2 – 19, live in a small threadbare
home that has
exactly seven pieces of furniture. They also own a refrigerator
but
have put it in storage since electricity is so erratic
and infrequent. Mr.
Saadi has been out of work for seven years. Formerly he
translated
and consulted for an Ad company, traveling abroad sometimes
on
company business. Since the sanctions were imposed he
has been
unemployed. He and his family mostly subsist on the ration
basket.
Last night, welcoming Ken, they had watermelon and dates!
They
also painted the door and washed all the floors in preparation
for his
visit. Now they also want to make room for Mr. Saadi’s
father who
went to the hospital for emergency treatment and remains
seriously
ill.
Ken marvels at how well the family treats him. "In the
Middle East,"
says Mr. Saadi, "our guests are treated as though they
own the
home." Their generosity is even more remarkable considering
Ken
comes from the country that bombed Mr. Saadi’s street
in January
1999. Now it's called "Missile Street" or "Rocket Street,"
and the
block’s residents all recall with horror the day that
a bomb struck,
killing 6 and wounding many more, including Mr. Saadi’s
teenage
son.+
Iraqis on "Missile Street" and elsewhere refer to the event
as "the
Accident." To us, it appears that ongoing US[/UK] bombing
raids
over the no-fly zones are "an accident" waiting to happen.
Likewise,
the sanctions prey on our vulnerable hosts.
Yes, all who warned us that we would melt in Basra were
right. But
mostly the children’s eyes and the Basrans’ countless
kindnesses
melt our hearts.
Kathy Kelly, From Basra, Iraq, in the "No-Fly Zone."
+ "The missile attack was on January 25, 1999 on the Al-Jamhuriyah
district of
Basra in southern Iraq. The missile used was an AGM-130
guided cruise missile.
The missile uses global positioning satellites [GPS] and
preprogrammed ground
coordinates to reach within 10 feet of the proscribed
target. When the missile is
closing in on the target the pilot can take control of
the missile (seeing what is
about to be hit with either infra-red or normal video
cameras) and choose ‘the
window pane or doorknob he wishes to hit’ (quote is from
a Pentagon
spokesperson I have interviewed on several occasions.).
The bomb killed 6 and
injured 64 people. Thirty-four houses were damaged or
destroyed. Another missile
killed 11 and injured 36 that same day in another neighborhood
[Khadasiyah] in
[sic: 25 kilometers outside] Basra. On Feb 15, 1999, 5
people were killed and 22
injured in another bombing in Basra."
-- N.B.: above figures verified through official investigation
by head of UN
"oil-for-food" program in Iraq.
The Streets of Basra by Lauren Cannon
July 22, 2000--Outside my window, as midnight nears, people
are
just "tucking in" for the night , or – as in my case –
carrying mats to
the rooftop where one can enjoy slightly less uncomfortable
night air.
Trapped by intense heat, thick smog shrouded the city center
today.
Lisa [Gizzi] and I felt as though we were chewing the
air when we
walked through an unkempt section of the main market.
The grim
determination we saw on so many faces masked, we knew,
an
intense weariness. There were two small children in the
market who
shyly called Hello from the street, then skipped away
when I replied.
It’s remarkable that Basrans maintain hope and preserve
their
intellectual heritage and abilities as they struggle against
the chaos
wrought by increasing deprivation. Miraculously, in spite
of the
troubles created by the sanctions and bombardment, they
raise
radiant, gleeful children.
Those gleaming eyes and wide smiles greet us as children
sitting at
the roadside say "hello" and then scoop water from a drainage
ditch
to quench their thirst. We try to dissemble our shock
as we meet the
gentle glances of mothers who have no choice but to clean
their
dishes in the same drainage ditch.
Later in the day, two members of my host family pick up
the copy of
Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina which I’m reading for the first
time, and tell
me how much they enjoyed reading it years ago. Just imagine
it – by
candlelight, because electricity was cut much earlier
in the day, we
discuss Tolstoy’s vision of land reform and then Gandhi’s
principles
of nonviolence.
This evening I walked with Nadra, my very dear and impeccably
tidy
host, to empty the waste baskets at the garbage dump:
the
intersection of our street. The trash piles up, mixed
with sewage, and
there simply are no trucks to pick it all up. Forbidden
by sanctions:
the trucks might have a military purpose. They might be
"dual use."
Summer in Basra – nightmare fears leaping into the everyday
lives of
innocents who’ve already endured close to two decades
of military
and economic warfare. Summer in Basra – a world of imprisoned
beauty where we feel no threat. Who does Iraq threaten?
Let’s be
honest. Iraq threatens the US ability to control Iraq’s
precious and
irreplaceable resources. [Kathy: As thousands of children
are
sacrificed because of this perceived threat tot US security,
the US
earns a fearsome reputation as the rogue superpower. We
feel sure
that families here in Jumhuriyah will teach us a new kind
of security
based on sharing, simplicity and care for others’ needs.]
Through Noora’s Eyes by Lauren Cannon
Upon our team’s arrival in Basra, I met Hani, one of our
hosts, a
proud Iraqi man, soon to become a protective "Baba" figure
for me.
Hani fixes telephones by trade, but under sanctions, telephones
are
rare, though they were previously commonplace. So Hani
has
expanded his repairing to include most household fixtures.
Hani took me to meet his family in Al Jumhuriyah, an extremely
poor
district of Basra, where our team has been graciously
welcomed for
a two-month visit. One of Hani’s daughters, Noora, is
a beautiful little
shy-but-playful girl. She became my new friend at once.
Noora has
already left an indelible mark in my mind and heart of
the forgiveness
of the Iraqi people for those of us just arrived from
the country whose
policy of sanctions ignores all but one Iraqi – the President.
In Hani’s meager three room home, with plastered walls
crumbling,
he points out each of his seven children, his wife, his
son’s wife and
children, and then to a large framed picture on the wall.
In his broken
English he says, "This is Hudah, age 8 and Hibeh, age
4." I saw two
precious dark-haired girls smiling in the picture. The
room grew
quiet. Hani then pointed to a 3 x 3 foot hole in the living
room ceiling,
now patched with scraps of metal. "On March 23, 1991,
this is where
my girls were killed when a bomb came through our house."
I
stammered out an inadequate "ana asif" ("I’m sorry). I
said that I
hoped to be a conduit to convey the Iraqis’ experiences
to
Americans.
This family suffered from the Gulf War, but nine years
later, cannot
escape the slow killing grip of sanctions. I said that
our team had
come to live on these streets to help get their story
out.
These streets do reflect the sanctions. Last night I helped
little Noora
take out the household trash. She led me around the corner
and
threw the trash into a huge pile in the middle of the
street. A similar
mound can be found on every block here. Noora explained
to me in
sign language that a truck comes to push it away sometimes.
The
stench and thickness of the pile spoke for itself, but
I learned that it is
only once per month that these families see removal of
the waste.
Before sanctions left the city’s trucks broken down with
no
replacement parts allowed form the UN’s "Committee 661,"
these
families enjoyed daily sweeping, spraying, and dumpster
removal on
their streets. Now, I see harried, gaunt people picking
through the
trash, and women washing their dishes in the street water
– even
with all this filth.
Yet somehow Noora still takes my hand and begins to skip
back
home. We run and laugh, then secretly make faces at each
other
when it is time to sleep (with the family on one big mat
on the living
room floor).
This girl, with the sparkling eyes, was only two when the
US bomb
ripped through her home and took her sisters. She does
not know
that our groups go to prison in the U.S. because we protest
the
making and dropping of these bombs. She does not know
I spent 30
days in maximum security prison, with children like her
in mind. She
does know that I come from a country that is strangling
hers with
sanctions. And yet somehow she is flirting me into a new
card game,
dancing, and singing.
And so we skip together down these once clean streets,
Noora and I,
looking into each other’s eyes, and I align myself again
with my hope
to be a voice for her, and for all these forgotten faces
behind the
U.S.-led sanctions against Iraq
Creativity Under Siege by Lauren Cannon
July 27, 2000--It is 7:00 a.m. in Basra and sweat is already
pouring
out of our bodies. This may be our hottest day yet. I
am writing from
the roof where my host family and I sleep on thin mats,
benefiting
from occasional Gulf breezes. Nadra, my new Mom and Arabic
coach, stated with frightening conviction that today would
indeed be
hot and "rotubah" – humid. It’s 7:00 and already 120º
in the shade …
No strangers to the heat of a Basra summer, the women wear
both
the hijab and abia, so they show only their hands and
faces. Still it is
we who are sweating profusely, even with our heads uncovered!
We
cut up our wash cloths, turning them into sweat rags,
and dream of
tank tops.
The intensity of the sun and heat prompts an afternoon
shut-down of
business. A nap is traditional between 2 and 4 p.m. When
business
resumes, our team is still unable to fax our reports,
or phone the U.S.
media – the lines are down. There are only a few hours
per day when
international calls can get out. Internet service is non-existent
for the
public in most of Iraq,** and certainly in Basra.
All of Iraq’s power grid (and most of its water treatment
system) was
targeted and bombed during the Gulf War. And now, ten
years later,
replacement parts are still being held up by the UN’s
"Committee
661" as "dual use." So the government here has to ration
electricity
and even water – with less and less available every day
as the plants
progressively degenerate. The sanctions are making sure
that the
devastation begun with the bombing inexorably, increasingly,
kills the
people here.
Basra has a few factories which receive priority for electricity
during
the day, and power is restored to our streets for just
a few hours most
evenings.
These families we stay with cannot afford air coolers,
even where
there is power to run them. But the daily power outage
deprives them
even of fans. And other things. Children get heat rash
routinely. Food
spoils. People have to adapt to life in the dark. But
we also see how
children play in these streets when the TV cuts out. We
witness
tremendous creativity under seige.
Midway through our Arabic lesson each morning, when the
ceiling
fan slows to a halt, and power goes, we let out a collective
gasp, and
begin to sweat – if possible – even more profusely. We
should have
taken our pre-Basra weights to measure our shedding under
the
sanctions! [Kathy Kelly: "I’m drenched after 30 minutes
in the kitchen,
preparing lunch!"]
We eat only the contents of the United Nations "oil-for-food"
family
ration, which means lentils, rice, salt, sugar, flour
and some weak
tea. We drink the "chai," and make chubuz – the flat bread
– with
hosts who are unfailingly gracious. Our group did come
armed with
our privilege: packets of "Emergen-C" to keep ourselves
fortified in
this heat. Yet we see how easily children become ill,
subsisting on
the deficient ration. Immunities are lowered, and that
means death in
streets filled with garbage and raw sewage.
We are constantly invited to homes to drink chai, try a
creative new
cake (made with the flour ration), and take a shower.
Women try to
take my sweaty clothes to wash them for me. Only occasionally
am I
asked an exasperated, "Why does the U.S. want to kill
our children?"
We talk of a decade of sanctions that has followed a decade
of war
with Iran. There is no doubt among Basrans as to who is
responsible
for the sanctions. The remind us that China and Russia
have
expressed disapproval of the U.S. – led policy in the
Security
Council. They know well that the U.S. and U.K. manipulate
their daily
life. And so, to their questions of "Why …" I am ashamed,
and can
only answer with my shared outrage and resolve to voice
their stories
in the U.S.
We think of the perseverance of parents like Majid and
Carema who
have lost all their material possessions to the sanctions,
but retain
their dignity. While we visiting their one-room home with
their 6
children, they do not complain. We see glimpses of despair
and
humiliation, but mostly we see courage and creativity.
Well, now the power is off again. And now we have only
our humor to
offer. And just now, we have all given a salute in unison,
looking up at
the fan …
** Note: (July 27, 2000 10:31 a.m. EDT http://www.nandotimes.com)
Iraqi Communications Minister Ahmad Murtada inaugurated
the country's first
public Internet center Thursday and pledged three more
would open soon in
Baghdad. The center, a two-story building in the capital's
commercial Al-Saadun
Avenue, has 18 computers, five of which are reserved for
those wanting to access
e-mail and the rest for those wishing to surf the Web.
Both Ends of Missile Street by Ken Hannaford-Ricardi
Basra, Iraq, July 26, 2000 – I am visiting with Umm Heyder
(literally,
"the mother of Heyder") in the living room of her home
on Rocket
Street in Basra, southern Iraq. It was here, among these
closely-constructed, adobe brick and stucco apartments,
that a
cruise missile exploded on January 25, 1999, forever fragmenting
long-held hopes for the neighborhood’s safety. This story
begins,
however, a world away from the destitution of Basra, so
perhaps we
should begin there.
A little more than two years ago, I committed my first
act of civil
disobedience. Early on a raw March morning, seven members
of the
"Raytheon Peacemakers" prayed, poured our blood, and trespassed
onto property belonging to the Raytheon Corporation, the
nation’s
third largest defense contractor and the manufacturer
of the
Tomahawk cruise missile, used widely in the 4-day December
1998
'Desert Fox' bombing of Iraq.
On that late winter day, my sole knowledge of the conditions
in Iraq
was second-hand, but that was soon to change. In September,
and
again in November, of that same year I made two visits
to the Middle
East to view for myself the destruction visited upon Iraq
by US/UK
weapons. Today, along with four other members of the Voices
in the
Wilderness campaign, I am living in the Al Jumhuriyah
City section of
Basra, Iraq’s third largest city and its only port.
On January 25th, 1999, a house on what has come to be known
as
Rocket Street suffered a direct hit from an AGM-130 guided
cruise
missile (similar to the Tomahawk missle). Four young children
were
killed, and many more were wounded, in this attack on
one of the
city’s poorest residential districts.
On my first day in Basra, I met several examples of President
Clinton’s "collateral damage" – boys and girls with mutilated
legs,
burned hands, and scarred faces – children whom Secretary
of State
Madeline Albright declared were the price worth paying
to preserve
US hegemony in the Middle East. I have met Umm Heyder,
whose
son’s life was ripped from him by the attack. When I asked
her, "How
can you smile with the memory of your son’s death so raw?"
she
replied, "What else can I do?"
I have now stood at both ends of the Tomahawk Missile’s
continuum
– the quiet, well-manicured factory where men and women
choose to
make a weapon whose only purpose is the death of other
human
beings, and the sandy, garbage-strewn street where children
scarred
by the attack continue to mourn those who died. The US-sponsored
economic sanctions, soon to enter their eleventh year,
and the
weekly bombing of Iraqi farms, factories, and homes –
the real
weapons of mass destruction in Iraq – have claimed the
lives of
almost a million Iraqis. Aside from hands covered with
the blood of
children, what have we gained? Umm Heyder, and the mothers
of the
other murdered men, women, and children, would certainly
say,
"Nothing."
Aligned With Maghareb by Kathy Kelly
July 28, 2000--Fax in hand and eager to telephone Chicago,
we
appear, each day, at Basra’s telephone/post office. There,
workers
greet us with knowing looks and a gesture that says, "Lines
cut."
"Shukran, Bill Clinton," we respond with remorse. "Shukran,
George
Bush (shukran is Arabic for 'thank you')." Then Mohamed,
Entissar,
and Fatima smile at us. The ritual is good-natured, but
the reality
persists. With microwave stations debilitated, often because
of
direct bombing, and a lack of needed equipment and faulty
underground cables, Basra’s phone service frequently "goes
down"
for days. Workers are idled, isolation sets in, and frustrations
rise.
I feel relieved, returning to "Bet Nadra," having no choice
but to forget
about sending our "urgent’ fax. Once we settle down on
the small
stoop outside, beaming, affectionate children will eagerly
help us
study as we stammer in "baby Arabic." We learn to match
names
with faces, study the personality of each new, young friend,
and thrive
on their clever charm. Little girls, hands extended, beg
us, "Please,
visit my home – now?" An afternoon visit almost always
begins with
an invitation to "swim." This means ducking into the family’s
w.c.
(water closet, i.e. bathroom) to pour several bowls of
water over our
heads. I do this about four times a day, but 15 minutes
later I am still
soaking wet. Seated on floor mats with families, we share
stories
and laughs, knowing the exchange might replace a good
meal. At
night, before falling asleep on the roof, we search the
sky for visible
stars and wait for warm breezes to nudge the stifling
air.
A rooster awakens me at dawn. In the tranquil early morning
hours,
studying Arabic and sipping coffee, I feel embarrassingly
safe, given
that I’m from the country waging war against these innocents.
A few
blocks away, on "Missile Street," a young girl, Maghareb,
awakens
and examines the scars, seven in all, large and dark,
that cover parts
of her thighs, shoulders, and chest. The wounds were inflicted
by a
US missile on January 25, 1999.
Friends in the US will soon begin a series of actions in
Philadelphia
and Washington, DC, trying to awaken people to the criminal
warfare
waged to "protect" us against Iraq. Aloof and perhaps
contemptuous
toward the protestors, presidential campaign workers and
candidates will endorse policies that abuse Iraqi children
and
sacrifice them – daily. Eyeing contribution coffers, they
won’t dare
question sanctions against Iraq lest they jeopardize support
from
defense companies, oil companies, and powerful, influential
decision
makers.
We shouldn’t feel ashamed that, relative to their campaigns,
our
efforts are poorly financed, nor should we be disheartened
by
sneers. A little girl, Maghareb, lives in the land of
"Lines cut." Her
very body speaks volumes about warfare. Yet our efforts
are fueled
precisely by her affectionate smile and warm embrace.
We are
aligned with Maghareb.
For What Crime? by Lisa Gizzi
July 29, 2000--Last night I visited the village of Abu
Khasib with my
Iraqi family. Abu Khasib and Al-Jumhuriya have in common
the
misfortune of being bombed within twenty minutes of each
other on
January 25, 1999, by American warplanes. On my December,
1999,
trip to Basra, our delegation visited the two dusty villages
to interview
survivors.
An encounter with one young man in particular etched itself
indelibly
into my memory. Hussein Abdul-Jabar was 19 years old when
he
was massively injured in the shoulder and chest by shrapnel
from the
US bomb, and his 22- year- old sister Nahida became what
western
media refer to as "collateral damage." His superbly handsome
face
wore a haunted regard and betrayed his emotional scars,
which I
managed to capture in a compelling photograph. His utter
silence
compounded the expression of anguish in his eyes, and
it was left to
his brother to recount his tale – a tale I myself have
told innumerable
times in various forums.
Last night, with the help of that invaluable photo and
my resourceful
Iraqi father, we were able to track down Hussein. I was
delighted to
find him relatively animated compared to our first meeting,
but only
slightly less taciturn. I took only enough time to thank
him for having
shared his story with me and to convey my affinity for
him. Having
related his experience so many times, I felt a closeness
to him akin
to that of a family member or dear friend. His gratitude
was both
sincere and heartwarming. The experience reaffirmed for
me the
humanity and dignity that are unfortunately masked by
the ugly
euphemism "collateral damage."
On the other side of Abu Khasib, we visited the family
of my Iraqi
father to offer our condolences for the death of his eleven-
year-old
cousin. Since the Gulf War bombing, Abu Khasib has been
cut off
from the city’s main water systems, and sanctions restrict
the import
of spare parts that would allow for repair. Consequently,
the villagers
must walk a few hundred meters to the Nahar Khuz River
to fetch
water. It was at that river, while his mother drew water,
that Hamza
drowned four days ago.
We entered the home, and I followed my Iraqi mother to
a room
where several black-veiled women were seated. We took
our place
among them and cried together for several minutes. After
our teary
catharsis, Hamza’s grandmother recounted the details of
his death.
Only later, when hearts were slightly less heavy, did the
women
inquire about my presence. I have an unfortunate and unjustified
habit
of bracing slightly when my nationality is revealed, lest
I encounter
any resentment. It never comes. "She is from America,"
Najah, my
Iraqi mother, told them. A smile lit the old woman’s face.
"Ahlah
wusahlan," she beamed. Welcome.
That gracious welcome was extended once again at the home
of
another group of relatives. The women embraced me, while
the men
smiled warmly. I shrank with regret on beholding an abundance
and
variety of food they offered their humbled guest. A little
math,
including the average Iraqi salary, the value of the dinar,
and the cost
of foodstuffs contributed to my regret of my hosts’ sacrifice.
There is an oft-repeated saying in Iraq that aptly conveys
the extent of
Iraqi hospitality. "When you enter our home, you become
the owner,
and we become the guests." That this hospitality is extended
so
freely even to citizens of a country responsible for so
much suffering
in their own makes it that much more appreciated.
The drive back to Al-Jumhuriya was somber. The beauty of
the
date-palm-lined rivers of Abu Khasib belies the deprivation
of its
people. I gazed into the clear, starlit Iraqi sky seeking
illumination.
Why have such a gracious people been made to suffer so?
For what
crime has their beautiful land been reduced to rubble?
And lastly, if
the Iraqis can make such a clear distinction between the
American
people and the policies of their government, why can’t
the US do the
same for Iraq.
Embraced as Family by Lisa Gizzi
July 31, 2000--The commencement of our two-month sojourn
with
Iraqi families in Basra has been bittersweet. The joy
in our hearts
inspired by the hospitality of our Iraqi friends is sadly
tempered by
the sight of their grand nation reduced to a state of
decrepitude.
Basra in particular is a once-affluent city that has seen
one million of
its residents emigrate as a result of the Iran/Iraq war
and, now,
sanctions. As in the rest of Iraq, everything in Basra
is in a state of
disrepair. Formerly sturdy structures now seem as if they
would
collapse into rubble at the snap of one’s fingers. Cars
sputter and
clunk along as if gasping their last breaths. As the daughter
of my
Iraqi host family aptly reports, "Daddy’s car is tired."
All of the cars in
Iraq are tired.
Everything down to toilets and door handles is jerry-rigged
for lack of
spare parts. Indeed, as far as the eye can see are signs
of a nation
that has been cruelly cut off from the rest of the world
and left to fend
for itself.
The streets of Al Jumhuriya, where our group of five has
taken up
residence, are like none one might find in the US, nor
for that matter
in Iraq before 1991. Garbage rots in heaps in the middle
of the
street, where goats forage for food, and children for
anything that
might be saleable.
Because sanctions restrict the repair of Gulf War damage
to Iraq’s
water systems, the gutters flow with a ghoulishly green
waste water,
the stench of which permeates the air and makes one wonder
if the
lesser of two evils is to breathe through the nose and
thus smell it, or
inhale with mouth open and perhaps face worse. At the
sight of
children frolicking in these fetid pools, an observer
aware of Iraq’s
high rate of water borne diseases will surely cringe.
Despite the fact the US-inspired sanctions have turned
the Cradle of
Civilization into Gotham City, the Iraqi people have embraced
this
group of Americans with a sincerity and generosity that
stirs the
heart. We are welcomed into every home we visit with warm
smiles
and offers of "chai" (tea), coffee, or "numi Basra," a
sweet lemon
drink unique to Basra.
Often, our gracious hosts offer us small gifts as sincere
gestures of
friendship. It is touching indeed, when a people who have
so little
delve into their pockets and drawers and deep into their
hearts that
they may offer up a token of affection to their grateful
guests.
Yesterday, after a half-hour long conversation with a young
woman
about her family’s fall from affluence as a result of
sanctions, she
removed a tiny rainbow-colored clip from her hair and
offered it to
me in friendship.
Today and always, I carry that clip and along with it thoughts
of a
young woman and a people who are suffocating under the
weight of
an economic siege. It is her story and theirs that we
wish to convey
over the next two months in the hope that Americans may
see Iraqis
not as citizens of a "rogue state" but as a generous,
proud, and
gentle people who have embraced us as their family.
How Have We Sinned? by Kenneth Hannaford-Ricardi
"Killing the innocent does not defeat terror; it feeds
terror. You are
making new enemies when what you need are friends."
--Secretary of State Madeleine Albright December 21, 1999
Each afternoon, as the temperature staggers toward 125
and the
heavy, wet air off the Persian Gulf hangs dense over the
neighborhood, the boys of Al Jumhuriyah City gather on
a dusty dirt
road to play soccer. The goals are simply lines toed in
the sand; the
sidelines the open ditches of raw sewage moving sluggishly
down
either side of the street. Nearby, groups of younger children,
often
wearing the only clothes they own, play marbles and gleefully
chase
each other under the watchful eyes of their mothers. Scrawny
hens
peck the hard ground for food, a solitary rooster’s cry
rises above the
din, and, close by one of the small, dingy shops that
dot almost every
corner, a cluster of emaciated sheep and goats grazes
in the mound
of garbage that marks the neighborhood’s boundaries. In
the early
evening, as the smoky smell of supper drifts through open
doorways,
I sit on the stoop as children, drawn to "the American"
as if by an
unseen force, shyly approach to show me their arms, legs,
chests,
and faces, scarred by missile fragments sent hurtling
through the
streets in a horrifying 1999 attack, mute testimony to
a suffering they
are at a loss to understand.
At night, the afternoon’s heat just beginning to dissipate
into thick,
stagnant air, groups of older Iraqis, men and women between
20 and
45, often stop to converse in front of the adobe brick
and stucco
house where I am staying. Occasionally one asks, "How
have we
sinned? What are we guilty of that your country would
punish us for
these ten years? Tell me!" he blurts out, his voice barely
restraining a
rising tide of frustration and anger. The answer, of course,
is that
none of these people has sinned. The children who die
needlessly
each month from malnutrition and illnesses easily preventable
before
the imposition of sanctions (Denis Halliday, the former
UN
coordinator of humanitarian aid who resigned his post
rather than
preside over the destruction of "an entire country," says
the number
approaches 6000) were not even born when the Gulf War
was fought
in 1991. They are Bill Clinton’s "collateral damage,"
the price
Secretary of State Madeleine Albright maintained was "worth
paying" to preserve American hegemony in the Middle East.
What is even more disheartening, however, is our government’s
deliberate decision that the targeting of innocents –
the young, the
elderly, the infirm – is an acceptable means of attaining
and
enforcing US foreign policy. The validity of that policy
is not the
question. What matters is that we have now adopted, in
Iraq and
elsewhere, a completely immoral approach to achieving
national
goals. We are now no better than any evil, real or perceived,
that we
are trying to prevent.
The issue is not just one of ending the sanctions against
Iraq; there is
not one shred of doubt that they should be lifted immediately.
Of even
greater import is our open declaration to the community
of nations,
through our support, now almost alone, for the continuation
of the
embargo, that the vulnerable are expendable, that they
will no longer
be spared. As a nation proud of being founded on taking
the moral
high ground, we must speak out now to end the targeting
of the
innocent - forever.
After This, You Will See by Mark McGuire
If you want to see the end-point of the endgame of strangling
a
people for the sake of a strong economy, come to Iraq.
Better yet,
come to Basra. Better yet, come to the Jumhuriya district,
a few
miles west of downtown Basra. Jumhurlya is home to tens
of
thousands of lower working class families, some having
moved here
from middle class neighborhoods where they found themselves
selling their possessions and finally their home to simply
survive. But
most of the residents seem to have lived here for generations.
It is
not unusual to have ten people living in a house, encompassing
three
generations, all sleeping on mats on the floor, the furniture
having
been sold to pay for medical bills.
We came to Basra in July to live with families in Jumhuriya,
eat as
simply as they do, study their language, and try to get
a genuine, if
culture-bound, sense of what keeps them going under these
difficult
conditions. We chose Basra because it has been the most
severely
affected by the sanctions imposed on Iraq b y the United
Nations in
early August of 1990. It also suffered extensive damage
during the
Iran-Iraq war and was bombed heavily during the Gulf War.
But it is
the sanctions that continue their daily grind on the people
of Basra
today. I had read a mountain of literature on the effects
of the
sanctions, spoken with dozens of people who had visited
Iraq in the
last several years, and had viewed numerous videos on
the situation
here, but little of it prepared me for Jumhuriya.
We arrived in Basra in the late afternoon, expecting heat
and
disintegration, and we found both--and then some. By the
end of our
first day, I knew it was all here. Raw sewage lining the
streets, fetid
air mixing with dense internal combustion smog; herds
of sheep
joined by barefoot children, picking through piles of
garbage on
street corners, vying for any available scraps of food;
a hollow,
directionless daily economy in which money seems to just
rattle
around; idle, jobless men walking to the end of the streets,
sitting on
the base of a lamp post and then walking back to their
stoops, house
after house in a state of disrepair, there being no money
left over at
the end of the month for upkeep - all of this taking place
In 120
degree heat and no end in sight for a lifting of the sanctions.
Intentions can have a way of changing their color and substance
when they come knocking on your front door, and however
much we
intended in our stay in Jumhuriya, even on the most modest
of levels,
to bear witness to the challenges and difficulties faced
daily by the
people of Basra, it is becoming increasingly clear that
the witness
being borne is being done by our friends in the neighborhoods
of
Jumhuriya. It is a witness borne of a faith in and an
understanding of
an order of values that too many of us for too long have
thought we
can live without. After enduring and suffering through
two devastating
wars and ten years of cruel and heartless sanctions, and
living with
the constant awareness of threatening and unfriendly visitors
flying
over their community, one would expect to find those bonds
of family
and friendship, which are the life blood of the social
fabric, to be in a
state of advanced decay and disorder. Instead one is confronted
every day with a simple goodness and decency, a deep patience,
and an inner reserve of strength, which can only leave
us marveling in
wonder. Good, Gandhi said, travels at a snail's pace,
and it is
traveling pretty slowly these days in Jumhuriya. But it
is there - I have
seen it - and it isn't going away. When I inquire as to
how they are
able to do it, how they can keep their chin up under conditions
which
I'm afraid would have caused most of us to crumble a long
time ago, I
am usually told in a calm, studied voice that it is simply
in their
centuries-old tradition to be generous, open, and kind-hearted,
whether they be times of happiness or adversity.
But these are only words, and we are blessed with the good
fortune,
while we remain in Jumhuriya, to see the truth of these
words given
persuasive shape and clarity in the daily lives of those
we meet as
we make our daily rounds. It is a truth which they do
not appear to be
in any great hurry to explain, but in their spontaneous
gestures of
warmth and simplicity one begins to see that the burden
is on us and
that they have nothing they need to explain, that, without
their trying,
they are offering to give back to us a part of our humanity
which we
may have lost.
Last month, shortly before we departed Amman for Iraq,
outside our
hotel, I held my last late night session with my Palestinian
friend,
Nassim. We were discussing my government’s attempts to
skew and
distort the American public's perception of Iraq. I assured
him that I
knew that Iraqis are much more than the image presented
to us by
our government and media. He smiled, politely demurred,
and said:
"No, my friend, you really don't know at all. In one day,
two days, you
will go to Basra, my friend, then you will see. Look into
their eyes, my
friend, and you will see. You read all the magazines,
the papers, you
look at the TV, but you took into their eyes and you will
see. After this,
my friend, you will see. After this, you will see."
A Circle of Hell By Kathy Kelly
August 10--Last night, following a three day fast and vigil
in
Baghdad, our team returned to Basra, arriving shortly
after sunset, A
new friend, Hamad, drove us. The six hour trip seemed
shorter than
usual, partly because Hamad is hell-bent on passing every
vehicle on
the road and partly because he sings beautifully. Hamad
has driven
the Baghdad-Basra route, round trip, almost daily, for
years. He
points to his head, laughs, and says an Iraqi word for
"Crazy!" It was
too late for Hamad to return to Baghdad.
"Where will you sleep?" I asked.
"Fi sayarrat," he said, with a shrug and a sad smile, in the car."
Shut your kitchen door, turn on the oven, and curl up in
a space half
your size to understand "fi sayarrat."
"It's a circle of hell," said Ahmed, another driver.
I first met Ahmed I February 1998, during a crisis when
the US
threatened to massively bomb Iraq in a dispute over UN
weapons
inspectors' movements.
Ahmed had graduated from University studies in the late
80s with an
engineering degree, a good command of English, a fine
car, and
hopeful prospects. Ten years of economic sanctions and
warfare
have steered him toward increasing loss and impoverishment.
Since
1989, he's had only one opportunity to work as an engineer
- a
three-month contract helping a foreign NGO rehabilitate
a water
filtration plant.
When I met him in February 1998, he was the driver for
a dynamic
young Italian, Umbrto Greco, who represented an NGO called
Bridges to Baghdad. Tooling about Baghdad's busy streets
in a
decrepit 1968 Land Rover, the two easily resembled Don
Quixote
and Sancho Panza. We'd laugh as Ahmed told of Umberto
arguing
with shocked parking lot attendants at Baghdad's swank
Al Rashid
hotel. When guards balked at allowing the Land Rover through
the
gates, Umberto would excitably insist, "But I live here!"
In late 1998, Umberto left Iraq and Ahmed sought work as
a taxi
driver. But the ramshackle Land Rover was soon consigned
to a
junkyard. He has since driven a succession of cars, each
"new" one
in worse condition than the previous one and not likely
to last more
than two weeks before expensive spare parts are needed
for careful
repairs. His latest purchase is a 1981 Toyota that cost
him $2000
USD.
"Do you at least earn enough money, driving each day, to
feed your
family?" I asked.
"En challa (Arabic for God Willing)," he said, but I notice
he has
grown more somber in the past two years. He doesn't toss
his head
back and enjoy a good laugh as often as he once did.
Driving - and driven - Ahmed has no choice but to work
as a driver
because a large, extended family now depends on his meager
income.
I like watching Ahmed and the "shoeshine boys" interact.
The boys
playfully shadow us everywhere we go within the hotel
vicinity. If our
shoes are slightly dusty, they encircle us like sharks
after fresh prey.
Each morning of our vigil, Ahmed let us all squeeze into
his car, three
viligers and four shoeshine boys. He'd drive us to our
tent site,
opposite the UN headquarters. Inside the faded, dilapidated
tent,
we'd begin "Madrasa Polish" - Shoeshine Boys School -
- dutifully
opening our English -Arabic textbooks. The boys, our teachers,
struggle to read Arabic, but their antics and pantomimes
carried us
through several hours of Arabic study, which would have
been
unbearably dull without them.
We held the August 6-9 vigil and fast to remind UN workers
of our
shared responsibility to uphold the UN charter, which
forbids warfare
that attacks civilians. Beginning on August 6, Hiroshima
Day, we
noted that it's also the day that marks 10 years of economic
sanctions against Iraq. Voices in the Wilderness and an
increasing
number of other groups insist that the sanctions are an
economic war
against innocent Iraqis. In the last month, our experiences
living with
very poor families in Basra convinces us that the sanctions
afflict our
new neighbors with cruel and unjust punishment.
Joking with the shoeshine boys has, for the past four years,
given us
a needed break from encounters with overwhelming grief
and
insoluble problems, as our delegations visit hospitals,
slum
dwellings, sites recently bombed, and other places that
show how a
state of siege devastates a society that was, formerly,
relatively
affluent. We can only try to guess how Iraqi people whom
we meet
cope with the grief and loss, day in, day out.
Although we laugh with the boys, we know clearly that their
prospects
are also bleak. They've each had a particularly rough
childhood.
We've winced as we've seen two boys and their family move
from a
pitifully humble apartment into an even worse hovel, as
the boys'
income just couldn't meet rising expenses. In a month,
school will
start. In a sense, September is "the cruelest month,"
for parents who
want so badly to send their children to school and who
simply can't
afford clothes for their kids. Families sell belongings
in order to get
shoes, clothing and schoolbags. Those with no more assets
to sell
must keep their children home. Most of the shoeshine boys
we know
are going to school and proud of it! Even so, it's disconcerting
to
realize that they're in their early teens and still unable
to read.
The boys respect Ahmed, and he brings out the best in them.
When
one of the boys begins to frown and pout over some slight,
Ahmed
talks to him in a manner that is neither harsh nor condescending.
He
rarely becomes exasperated. I envy his ability to cope
with intense
pressures in such a calm and dignified way.
I think the boys will learn, from Ahmed, some needed lessons
about
exercising caution and restraint. Sometimes they are reckless,
as
when a fight over soccer spills out into heavy traffic.
Hotel managers,
increasingly less tolerant of the boys' persistent sales
pitches with
tourists, sometimes call the police if their clients complain.
The
police sometimes solve the problem by confiscating a shoeshine
boy's box, his portable kit that he carries on a shoulder
strap. A new
box costs $30 USD and loss of the box effectively puts
a boy "out of
business." VitW has undertaken a "back to work" campaign,
investing, so far, in two new boxes. (We can't claim,
any longer, that
we've avoided capitalist investment).
A few days ago, I heard the boys whisper about another
driver whom
we know who has been in police custody for two weeks.
According
to one story, he drove a foreigner, "a Hindi man," (presumably
someone from India), into a restricted area. A second
story says that
the foreigner went with the driver to a poor neighborhood
and
distributed money to needy families. Still another account
says the
driver took three foreigners for a ride and they snapped
photos
without permission. A fourth report has the driver helping
a foreigner
to negotiate a small but bad business deal. We know this
driver quite
well. He's an earnest fellow who eagerly pursues every
business
prospect imaginable. If a team member mentions a need
for a towel,
he'll return with a trunk full. We find all four rumors
plausible.
It's harder to understand why drivers are so restricted
- why the
demand for a "guide" to accompany foreigners? And why
can't a
foreigner distribute money in a poor area?
Several of us raised questions like these with Iraq’s Ambassador
to
the United Nations during a February 2000 meeting in New
York. A
month earlier, after one of our teams had visited a home
in Basra,
armed soldiers surrounded and searched the home, badly
frightening the family.
Much to my surprise, the Ambassador said, "I would have
ordered
the same thing, were I in charge of that governorate.
Mr. Saeed
Hassan al Muswai, a former University professor of geography,
is a
gentle, thoughtful person who often uses ironic understatements
to
make a point. His blanket assertiveness seemed out of
character.
"Look," he continued, "your country has stated, at highest
levels of
government, that it intends to overthrow my country's
government.
Your country has dedicated 100 million dollars for that
purpose. If
people from your country visit a home, unannounced, in
my area, -
YES, I will investigate. Yes, I will search."
The Ambassador's blunt response made us think further,
and now I
think he was actually understating the case.
In poor neighborhoods in the US, many people are accustomed
to
armed raids on their homes.
Once, near my home, a drunken woman assaulted me because
she
thought I had picked her pocket. A police car happened
upon the
scene and a policewoman nearly locked me up because she
couldn't
believe I'd be in that neighborhood, at night, for any
purpose other
than to negotiate a drug deal.
Suppose the US government anticipated that another country,
a very
powerful country, was trying to engender a coup or an
assassination
or some serious destabilization of the US government.
Would the US
government predictably restrict the movements of foreign
citizens
from the enemy country? And suppose the enemy country
bombed
the US once or twice a week and had subjected US people
to a
brutal ten-year state of siege. Would the US government,
in a
beleaguered and battered state, insist that foreigners'
movements
be watched? Would there be prohibitions against distributing
cash to
desperate US citizens who might, for badly needed funds,
agree to
help subversive groups achieve their aims? Would tourists
be
restricted from snapping photos that could help subversive
forces
map out sites for bombardment or battles?
I would still hold out for Gandhian methods. I imagine
that Gandhi
would have assured potential invaders or attackers that
if they
attempted to seize power, Gandhi and his followers would
not harm
them, but Gandhi and his followers 'Would also practice
complete
non-cooperation with the "enemy" and try every nonviolent
means
possible to win them over and gain world support.
In our troubled world, which response seems more credible?
I think
we'd have to agree that most heads of state, if subjected
to
bombardment, siege, a threatened overthrow, and vast outside
surveillance, would follow a course similar to that chosen
by Iraq's
government. And most heads of state would probably understand
Ahmed's reference to being caught "in a circle of hell."
During some quiet hours at the vigil site, Ahmed fingered
his worry
beads, looked skyward, and seemed lost in thought. Is
he wondering
what will happen to the jailed driver? Does he have some
Beatrice,
holding a lantern, in mind? Can he still dream of repairs
for his
broken society? For the moment, more immediate "hands-on"
repairs await. He'll have to carefully twist wires underneath
his
dashboard just to start his car - the end of the line
in a circle of hell.
Dignity and Faith by Lauren Cannon
August 14--After five hot and humid weeks in Basra, our
team
already has a tremendous collection of compelling and
heartfelt
evidence to demand an immediate lifting of the sanctions
(current
US-led UN policy on Iraq,) by all accounts, the most comprehensive
ever imposed in modern history. We can see well the complexity
of
forces that make life challenging for these Iraqi families,
who truly live
hand to mouth in this poorest district of Basra, Al-Jumhuriyah.
It is
quite clear that the Sanctions have strengthened the current
regime.
Daily propaganda blasts from each household TV, children
sing
party songs in the streets and salute the portrait of
the President on
every corner. However, the unquestionably obvious primary
grief
among people is the radical change in the conditions of
their lives,
over the last ten years of severe economic sanctions.
One way we
see this is the difference in how the telling of a decade
of war with
Iran is juxtaposed with the decade of Sanctions (including
the Gulf
War.)
I spend several hours each day with a family who lives
on the same
street as my host, but who is much worse off. Due to stated
concerns
for the safety of the women, and the acceptance of Americans,
our
hosts refused our request to live with the poorest families
on the
block. Majid and Karima have only a simple open courtyard
and one
room for a home. Nadra has four rooms and a door that
locks. With
our team's determination to be independent a neccessity,
we all
underwent much negotiation at first. Our hosts would not
compromise
on their concerns for our safety. Majid and Karima's home
was
deemed to be unsuitable, because my belongings could not
be
secured in the open courtyard. So, I sleep up the street
at Nadra's
and spend my days with Majid, Karima, among other families
in the
neighborhood. Majid and Karima's family has fallen from
a
comfortable middle class Iraqi existence a decade ago,
to full
welfare reliance today. Despite Majid's military service
in both the
Iran/ Iraq and the "Bush War," as it is called here, he
supports himself
by working at a local factory. This brings him a meager
10,000 Dinar
per month (about five dollars). This entire monthly salary
just covers
the rent of the courtyard, so he creates drawings, and
peddles them
at the market for additional income.
Karima and the girls have carefully showed me the contents
of the
monthly food ration, which comes through the UN Oil-for
-Food
program. Majid has shown me the distribution and pick-
up systems
for August. I am struck by the self-sacrificing determination
and good
humor with which Karima has 'rationed' flour, sugar, tea,
lentils and
rice into some sort of nutrition for her whole family.
To live simply on
this for two months is one thing, but another for Karima,
who has
been curious about my vegetarianism, and previously used
to a
hearty meat and fish diet. As she makes kabobs (without
meat), she
laughs that they are well seasoned ten-year vegetarians
now
themselves. I cringed when the family splurged to purchase
special
vegetables and beans for a welcoming dinner in my honor.
This night, I wonder if they quietly count me as a naïve
optimist as we
find broken language to talk about non-violence and alternatives
to
war. They have lived two decades of intimacy with war.
Karima was
home with five young children, sleepless, as she braced
both the
rattling of the Gulf bombings and Majid's absence to service.
Majid
shows me the disfiguration of his leg suffered when US
missiles hit
his factory and his bench mate was killed. What do these
survivors,
from so many presences, know of the 'freedoms' we have
in the US
to exercise our voices against the killing of civilians?
How do our
consequences for that compare to this family's struggle?
How does
silence compare?
This dusky, somehow peaceful evening, we sit in this courtyard
and
the hot air is quieting. The whole family devours the
few chosen
pictures of my American life, which I have put off showing
until now.
The power has been off for hours and I am grateful that
the dim light
of the kerosene lamp can help hide my self-consciousness
about my
own relative wealth- a car, an apartment, a family summer
vacation
spot. We talk of their curiosities of all that Sanctions
have deprived
them of ... the Internet, travel, and international educational
exchange.
It is hard for me to picture them in their former middle
class life.
There is sewage seeping in to the courtyard form the street.
We hear planes overhead and together we shrug. We have
previously discussed the "no-fly zones," American weapons
sales,
and control of oil economy in this region. I try to keep
my head up.
They simply offer me more tea. When the power comes back
on, we
sit on the floor of the room, eating a simple tomato and
rice dinner
with our hands. They are laughing at me, forcing me to
eat, eat, eat,
with typical Iraqi hospitality. We learn, now with the
TV on, that those
fly-by's actually dropped bombs tonight, four hundred
kilometers
north of here, hitting a food supply center, 16 homes,
injuring dozens.
The US presence is what is palpable here; it is what we
can speak
about; and it is what we, in the US, have power to change.
Majid and
Karima and the kids can fill me with hope with their beauty
and
humor through this siege. The feel of their home is much
warmer than
that individualized one from which I come. Perhaps being
forced into
a one-room existence is to thank. Perhaps their dignity
and faith is
what I am filled with. The one thing that is certain is
that these dear
ones do not deserve to live like this and they do not
have a voice in
the US government. We, their guests, do.
Voices In The Wilderness 1460 West Carmen Avenue Chicago, IL
60640 Tel. (773) 784-8065 Fax. (773)
784-8837
e-mail: kkelly@igc.apc.org on the web: www.nonviolence.org/vitw/