Mary Elizabeth Jenkins Surratt was born in May or June of 1823 near Waterloo, Maryland. In 1840, at age 17, she married 28 year old John H. Surratt. The couple went to live on lands that John had inherited from his foster parents, the Neales, in what is now a section of Washington known as Congress Heights. John and Mary had 3 children. Isaac was born on June 2, 1841. Anna was born on January 1, 1843, and John Jr. was born on April 13, 1844.
In 1851 fire destroyed the Surratt home. John Surratt decided not to rebuild the home at that location. He chose to build a combination home/tavern. The couple bought a farm and established a tavern and later a post office. The tavern was in operation by the fall of 1852, and by 1853 the family was living in the newly-constructed Surratt House and Tavern. On December 6, 1853, John Surratt Sr. bought the Washington D.C. property on H Street that would later become Mary's ill-fated boardinghouse. The price: $4000. Mr. Surratt was appointed postmaster on October 6, 1854, and the surrounding area was henceforth called Surrattsville, Maryland (On May 3, 1865, the Post Office Department changed the town's name to Robeystown, after the postmaster Andrew V. Robey, and subsequently to Clinton on October 10, 1878).
In August of 1862 John Sr. died, and on October 1, 1864, along with her daughter, Anna, Mary moved to the Washington D.C. property previously purchased by her husband. She rented the Surrattsville tavern to a man named John Minchin Lloyd.
To make money, Mary started renting rooms in her Washington, D.C. residence located at 541 H Street. During the Civil War, Mary's son, John, became a Confederate spy and messenger. John Jr. met John Wilkes Booth, and early in 1865, Booth became a frequent visitor to the boardinghouse. Other people, later identified as coconspirators, also frequented the boardinghouse. It is unclear if Mary Surratt knew what all the "activity" was about.
On April 11, 1865, Mrs. Surratt made a trip to Surrattsville. She traveled with Louis J. Wiechmann, one of her boarders. During the trip, they met John Lloyd on the road at Uniontown. According to Lloyd, Mrs. Surratt told him the "shooting irons" would be needed soon. The "shooting irons" had been hidden in Lloyd's tavern by Booth's coconspirators.
Three days later, on the day of the assassination, Mrs. Surratt made another trip to Surrattsville. Again Wiechmann accompanied her in a hired buggy. This time, according to Lloyd, she delivered Booth's French field glasses to him and reminded him to ready the weapons and escape gear hidden at the tavern he leased from her. Lloyd, a heavy drinker, was drunk during this conversation. At midnight, after the assassination, Booth and David Herold stopped at the tavern to collect these items.
On the night of April 17, officers arrested Mrs. Surratt. She was charged with conspiracy and with aiding the assassins and assisting their escape. The fact that Lewis Paine, a definite conspirator, had come to her boardinghouse just as she was being arrested didn't help her cause.
The carte-de-visite entitled Morning, Noon, and Night was taken from a mantel at the Surratt boardinghouse during the police search of the premises. On the back of the carte-de-visite, Anna Surratt had placed a photograph of John Wilkes Booth.
Mary Surratt claimed total innocence. She said she knew nothing of Booth's plans, and that her trips to Surrattsville had to do with collecting some money she was owed by a man named John Nothey.
One thing that looked suspicious about Mrs. Surratt was that she claimed she had never seen Lewis Paine before when he appeared at her boardinghouse on April 17. He had been there many times before the assassination. Was she lying, or was this due to poor eyesight?
Mrs. Surratt was tried along with 7 men. In jail Lewis Paine maintained Mrs. Surratt was 100% innocent. However, she was convicted mostly due to the testimony of John Lloyd and Louis Wiechmann. These men drew great criticism for their testimony. However, nearing age 60 and dying, on June 2, 1902, Wiechmann allegedly called to his sisters, asked them to get pen and paper, and told them to write "This is to certify that every word I gave in evidence at the assassination trial was absolutely true; and now I am about to die and with love I recommend myself to all truth-loving people." However, this statement has never been produced and must presumed to be lost. Also, John Lloyd stuck to his damaging testimony at the 1867 trial of John Surratt. In court Mrs. Surratt was dressed in black, with her head covered in a black bonnet. Her face was mostly hidden behind a veil. The jury voted the death penalty for her but added a recommendation for mercy due to her "sex and age." The recommendation was that the penalty be changed to life in prison. (** see below **)
President Andrew Johnson maintained that he never was shown the plea for mercy. Judge Advocate Joseph Holt said he had been in Johnson's presence when the president read the plea. Johnson was quoted as saying that Mary Surratt "kept the nest that hatched the egg." Thus, along with Paine, Herold, and Atzerodt, Mrs. Surratt was executed by hanging on July 7, 1865. She wore a black dress and black veil. Her last words on the scaffold were "Don't let me fall."
Four years later Anna Surratt made a successful plea to the government for her mother's remains. Today, Mary Surratt is buried in Mount Olivet Cemetery in Washington, D.C. The address of the cemetery is 1300 Bladensburg Road, NE. Her headstone reads simply "MRS. SURRATT." Anna Surratt and Isaac Surratt were buried on each side of their mother. John Surratt was buried in Baltimore. Strangely, John Lloyd, whose testimony was so damaging to Mary, was buried less than 100 yards south of her in the same cemetery. His simple tombstone is marked John M. Lloyd.
Elizabeth "Bessie" Jenkins, Mary Surratt’s mother, passed away in June, 1878, at age 84. She was buried at St. Ignatius Church on Brinkley Road in Oxon Hill, Maryland. She never made a public comment about her daughter’s execution.
The building that housed Mrs. Surratt's boardinghouse in Washington still stands.
Historical opinion is divided on the subject of Mary Surratt's guilt or innocence. In 1977 a "Lost Confession" of George Atzerodt resurfaced. Regarding Mary Surratt, Atzerodt stated, "Booth told me that Mrs. Surratt went to Surrattsville to get out the guns, Two Carbines, which had been taken to that place by Herold, this was on Friday." On the face of it, this statement by Atzerodt would certainly seem to point towards Mary Surratt's complicity with John Wilkes Booth. Although no one knows for certain, it seems at least possible that Mary knew about the plot to kidnap the President, but may not have known about the plan to assassinate him. Several good arguments for Mary’s innocence are made by Elizabeth Steger Trindal in her article entitled The Two Men Who Held The Noose in the July, 2003, edition of the Surratt Courier.
