Bet Yoshi could own both of them.

I definately think that mario would win. He is always the main character used, so he gets more experience. The only times luigi got any playing time were when there was a second player..... and everyone knows that second players are never as good as first. Mario also has the weight advantage, and if the bros. ever got into a fight, then it would more than likely turn into a wrestling match and the heavier fellows always win those. My final comment is that the games were always called "Mario" Bros. making mario the main man. But they could both beat me up because they are mean little italians, and i'm fat. What do you guys think?

eeh, i don't know. I'm gonna have to take luigi's side on this one. For one, i think he's the eldest. ask dave, how often does he beat his big brother up? second, luigi's got the reach on mario. true, mario'd win in a grapple, but between long arms and long legs, i don't think mario's going to catch up. unless he holds "B" while chasing him.

hmm its been a while since i have posted

but anyway

on this one im going to have to say luigi, with my evidence being most super smash brother mario/luigi matches i ahve played.

--richard

i'm going to go ahead and side with matt and richard...luigi wears green, losers wear red. my high school color was red and my high school is a loser school. UTSA's colors aren't green but our grass is green so it makes us winners...so yeah. luigi rocks. by the way matt, i like your adventures keep it up cuz if you're not gonna post ldr's then you better post the adventures...or else. and yeah that's a threat.

anywayz, i gotta get to class, its hard to find a good seat...laterz!

Linds

I'll agree with the fact that luigi has the height and reach, but that doesn't necessarily guarantee a victory. that would be like me (mario) fighting dave (luigi). i would kill dave. and i'm still going to have to stick with my main point of mario having much more exerience than luigi, and who says loosers wear red? there are plenty of green teams that aren't any good at all. The oakland atheletics are green, and they aren't that great. so are the seatle supersonics and the green bay packers, and neither one of those teams are any good at all. Then you have red teams that are good, such as the braves and the indians which both have playoff hopes still alive. and there are way more red superheros than there are green ex. spiderman, dare devil, captain america and so on. the only geen ones i can think of are the green lantern and the hulk. ok, this is way too long so i'll just wait to see what others write.

ok this about steve's first message he wrote
1. yes you are fat.
2. heavier guys don't always win (i.e. me beating fat head(whihc was more than once for the record)that weighs like 1 and a half of me or so)

o yeah i forgot

i am cool

steven... jesus.. you are nowhere in comparison to the fighting genius that is mario, and to compare dave to luigi? thats up there blashphemy. ok lets talk about these green teams... the a's, the supersonics, and the packers were all quite good in the heyday of the mario games (late 80s early 90s). braves = blue. indians = cleveland. they both suck. and to make it worse, spiderman and the cap are blue and red (not red only) and daredevil was originally yellow. the green lanter and the hulk are both the shit, and you forget the green arrow, the green goblin and many other good green guys

as for just general gameplay, look at mario 2. this hands down shows the luigi would win. he jumps the highest. its like when you were little and the tall kid would hold shit so you couldnt reach it. yeah liek taht. luigi would get a mushroom and taunt mario until he couldnt fight logically, then just beat the piss out of him. im sorry but you just cant argue with this shit man. oh yeah new grudge match idea: the thing vs the hulk

richard richard richard...... first off, the braves are red and blue. you will NEVER find a sports team that is just one color. second i didn't say that the 3 green teams were never any good, i said they weren't any good RIGHT NOW, which was my argument on linds's point, and both the braves and the indians are near the top of their division right now, so get the facts straight first.
aslo, i would choose mario over luigi anyday in mario 2, because while luigi is floating around in the air for half an hour, mario has already beaten the game and taken a victory lap. mario was always much faster than luigi. (princess was the best in the game anyway) and for the superheros, i said the green ones were the only ones i could think of at the time, because i had class in 2 minutes. and there were countless more red ones that i didn't mention to name. and i can still beat the piss out of dave

hey----
i've been waiting this one out, and i have to go with steve on it. my only argument is that mario is the main guy and the understood leader of the 2. oh yeah and.......steve and i can kick the piss out the rest of you so we're right.

I chose the blue question mark because I have never seen a blue question mark before and I always wanted to see a blue question mark... I beg to differ although steven and bradley (the traitor) are my friends they are wrong. In a wrestling match heavier guys don't necessarily win I have demonstrated that throughout the years. Another thing I know is that younger brothers fight better than older brothers for the most part and seeing that Luigi and Mario are both grown up I say Luigi wins.

Ok I am new to this thing. But anyways Mario vs Luigi who would win. Who do you think?...Luigi of course...Ok first of all Mario is a pudgey little man that for some reason always manages to get the princess. Maybe he is hung like Ron Jeremy i mean who knows. But anyways this isnt important. Take the example of Mario 2 for NES, ok excluding the princess who was the best character on the game? Luigi, I mean geezs did you see the standing jump that guy has? I mean think of the leg muscles that one has to have to be able to jump to the top of the screen. I mean he should be able to beat the hell out of Mario just by doing a few Kangaroo kicks. I know you probably say, wait kangaroos lean back on their tails when they use their feet and Luigi doesn't have a tail. Well think about it if Mario has a Ron Jeremy penis wouldn't you think Luigi being his brother have one as well i mean they are from the same gene pool. I think Toad can vouche for that!! (little fast to squat fungus). If by some unfortunate fluke that Luigi was cursed with a stumpy penis, he still has the height and reach advantage. Ok im sure several of you work or have worked at the movie theater. We will take two real life examples that represent Mario and Luigi. Ok Mario is going to be played by Sara Alcire (you know fat chick that can't do anything but smoke and tear tickets and possible clean up an over-turned nacho tanker). Luigi will be played by Regina. Ok we all know that Sara can't go five minutes without taking a break and Regina was the ability to tear your head from your body.
Ok so I don't make this post incredibly long to sum it up. There is no possible way that Mario(sara) could win unless possibly he had been fasting for like a week and was just craving a couple chilli dogs and nachos. But as we all know, no fat person is going to go a week let alone 30 minutes without eating, therefore in a no contest decision Luigi takes the belt!