2005 Opening Rosters
| Pos | Marauders | Anton | Pos | Foul Balls | Tom | Pos | JP is a Pimp | Mark/Dave | Pos | Heavy Hittaz | Chris |
| C | Ramon Hernandez | 1 | C | Jason Varitek | 10 | C | Yadier Molina | 1 | C | Javier Lopez | 18 |
| 1B | Jim Thome | 30 | 1B | Justin Moreau | 6 | 1B | Travis Haffner | 6 | 1B | Mike Sweeny | 6 |
| 2B | Mark Bellhorn | 6 | 2B | Jose Reyes | 5 | 2B | Jose Vidro | 6 | 2B | Jeff Kent | 17 |
| 3B | Aubrey Huff (1 yr) | 6 | 3B | Eric Chavez (1 yr) | 13 | 3B | Melvin Mora | 6 | 3B | Troy Glaus | 9 |
| SS | Bobby Crosby | 6 | SS | Michael Young | 14 | SS | Normar Garcianpara | 15 | SS | Orlando Cabrerra | 6 |
| OF | Larry Walker | 6 | OF | Jason Bay | 6 | OF | Adam Dunn | 20 | OF | Garry Sheffield (1 yr) | 18 |
| OF | Craig Wilson | 5 | OF | Michael Cabrerra (1 yr) | 6 | OF | Carlos Beltan | 46 | OF | Barry Bonds | 37 |
| OF | Preston Wilson | 17 | OF | Manny Rameriz | 38 | OF | Kevin Menche | 3 | OF | Geoff Jenkins | 5 |
| DH | Dave Roberts | 7 | DH | Steve Finley | 3 | DH | Shawn Green | 8 | DH | Mark Loretta | 17 |
| SP1 | Brad Radke | 6 | SP1 | John Smoltz | 17 | SP1 | Zach Greinke | 6 | SP1 | Chris Carpenter | 6 |
| SP2 | Randy Johnson | 41 | SP2 | Kerry Wood | 17 | SP2 | Pedro Martinez | 24 | SP2 | Mike Hickley | 1 |
| SP3 | Tim Hudson | 30 | SP3 | Andy Pettite | 9 | SP3 | Josh Beckett | 17 | SP3 | Kevin Brown | 6 |
| RP1 | Jose Mesa | 3 | RP1 | Jason Issiringhousen | 16 | RP1 | Guielmo Mota | 6 | RP1 | Danny Graves | 12 |
| RP2 | Chin-hui Tsao | 1 | RP2 | Shingo Takatsu | 12 | RP2 | BJ Ryan | 14 | RP2 | Trevor Hoffman (1 yr) | 6 |
| P1 | Matt Clement | 19 | P1 | Mark Buerle | 13 | P1 | David Bush | 1 | P1 | Moriano Riveria | 18 |
| P2 | Bronson Aroyo | 4 | P2 | Dontelle Willis | 5 | P2 | Antonio Osuka | 2 | P2 | Luke Hudson | 3 |
| Util | Jeff Weaver | 2 | Util | Mike Cuddyer | 3 | Util | Danny Haren | 4 | Util | Frank Thomas | 3 |
| Util | Migel Batista | 6 | Util | Chad Cordero | 5 | Util | Juan Uribe | 5 | Util | Moises Alou | 6 |
| Util | David Wells | 2 | Util | Wade Miller | 1 | Util | Greg Aquino | 6 | Util | Brandon Webb | 4 |
| Util | Jeff Bagwell | 1 | Util | Chase Utley | 1 | Util | Austin Kearns | 1 | Util | Garret Atkins | 2 |
| REMAINING | 1 | REMAINING | 0 | REMAINING | 3 | REMAINING | 0 | ||||
| Pos | Matts Mambas | Matt | Pos | yourmomsondeck | Hillel | Pos | Gary the Dog | Kevin Final | Pos | Dingo ate my bat boy | Dan Ford |
| C | Joe Mauer | 6 | C | Jason Kendall | 13 | C | Ivan Rodriguez | 16 | C | Johny Estrada | 6 |
| 1B | Albert Pujols | 47 | 1B | Mark Teixera | 15 | 1B | Derrick Lee | 15 | 1B | Todd Helton | 38 |
| 2B | Alfonzo Soriano | 30 | 2B | Luis Castillo | 6 | 2B | Ceaser Istiruz | 1 | 2B | Chone Figgins | 10 |
| 3B | David Wright | 6 | 3B | Hank Blalock (1 yr) | 6 | 3B | Alex Rodriguez | 40 | 3B | Scott Rolen | 28 |
| SS | Rafel Furcal | 15 | SS | Carlos Guillen | 2 | SS | Jorge Julio | 6 | SS | Edgar Renteria (1 yr) | 15 |
| OF | Carlos Lee (1 yr) | 6 | OF | Jim Edmonds | 25 | OF | Jose Guillen | 6 | OF | Scott Podsednik (1 yr) | 6 |
| OF | Aaron Rowand | 9 | OF | Brian Giles | 19 | OF | Richard Hildago | 1 | OF | Garret Anderson | 14 |
| OF | Nick Switzer | 3 | OF | Vernon Wells | 21 | OF | Juan Pierre | 23 | OF | JD Drew | 15 |
| DH | Andruw Jones | 17 | DH | Richie Sexon | 6 | DH | Alex Rios | 2 | DH | Chipper Jones | 15 |
| SP1 | Johan Santana (1 yr) | 6 | SP1 | A.J. Burnett | 6 | SP1 | Carlos Zambrano (1 yr) | 6 | SP1 | Ben Sheets | 10 |
| SP2 | Jason Schmidt (1 yr) | 6 | SP2 | Roger Clemens | 14 | SP2 | Roy Halladay | 26 | SP2 | Kevin Escobar | 12 |
| SP3 | Horatio Rameriz | 2 | SP3 | Bartolo Colon | 13 | SP3 | Mark Mulder | 20 | SP3 | Doug Davis | 7 |
| RP1 | Joe Nathan | 18 | RP1 | Ted Lilly | 1 | RP1 | Brad Lidge | 6 | RP1 | Bob Wickman | 6 |
| RP2 | Troy Percival | 9 | RP2 | Ryan Madson | 1 | RP2 | Francisco Cordero (1 yr) | 6 | RP2 | Francisco Rodriguez | 6 |
| P1 | Eddie Guardado | 10 | P1 | Barry Zito | 20 | P1 | Kevin Millwood | 7 | P1 | Joe Kennedy | 1 |
| P2 | Jeff Francois | 1 | P2 | Javier Vazquez | 15 | P2 | Randy Wolf | 3 | P2 | John Thomsom | 2 |
| Util | Lance Berkman | 5 | Util | Greg Maddux | 6 | Util | Pat Burrell | 5 | Util | Jason Giambi | 5 |
| Util | Brian Larwence | 2 | Util | Jermaine Dye | 9 | Util | Jake Weastbrook | 2 | Util | Jeff Suppan | 1 |
| Util | Scott Kazmir | 1 | Util | Ryan Wagner | 1 | Util | Juan Rincon | 1 | Util | Ken Griffey Jr. | 1 |
| Aaron Boone | 1 | Util | Edwin Jackson | 1 | Util | Derrick Low | 4 | Util | Jerome Williams | 1 | |
| REMAINING | 0 | REMAINING | 0 | REMAINING | 4 | REMAINING | 1 | ||||
| Pos | Chucks Chargers | Rob | Pos | Master Batters | Andres | Pos | Roc's Rynos | Ryan | Pos | Team Roids | Jesse |
| C | Jorge Posada | 12 | C | Victor Martinez | 6 | C | AJ Pierzynski | 1 | C | Mike Piazza | 12 |
| 1B | David Ortiz | 6 | 1B | Paul Konerko | 6 | 1B | Sean Casey | 6 | 1B | Carlos Delgado | 34 |
| 2B | Marcus Giles | 6 | 2B | Brett Boone | 10 | 2B | Kaz Matsui | 3 | 2B | D'Ángelo Jimenez | 1 |
| 3B | Mike Lowell | 16 | 3B | Adrian Beltre | 6 | 3B | Arimas Ramirez | 6 | 3B | Casey Blake | 6 |
| SS | Jimmy Rollins | 6 | SS | Kahlid Greene | 1 | SS | Derek Jeter | 18 | SS | Miguel Tejada | 32 |
| OF | Hideki Mastui | 27 | OF | Bobby Abreu | 38 | OF | Vladimir Guerrero | 45 | OF | Carl Crawford | 21 |
| OF | Johny Damon | 17 | OF | Corey Patterson | 6 | OF | Coco Crisp | 14 | OF | Sammy Sosa | 14 |
| OF | Tori Hunter | 6 | OF | Ichiro Suzuki | 26 | OF | Magilio Ordonez | 19 | OF | Cliff Floyd | 3 |
| DH | Luis Gonzales | 3 | DH | Phill Nevin | 1 | DH | Brad Wilkerson | 15 | DH | Corey Koskie | 1 |
| SP1 | Oliver Perez | 6 | SP1 | Jake Peavy (1 yr) | 6 | SP1 | Carl Povano | 6 | SP1 | Mike Mussina | 19 |
| SP2 | Curt Schilling | 26 | SP2 | Mark Prior | 18 | SP2 | Freddy Garcia | 12 | SP2 | Odalis Perez | 4 |
| SP3 | Roy Oswalt | 26 | SP3 | Rich Harden | 18 | SP3 | Eric Milton | 4 | SP3 | Kris Benson | 1 |
| RP1 | Danny Kolb | 6 | RP1 | Eric Gagne | 25 | RP1 | Armando Benitez (1 yr) | 6 | RP1 | Billy Wagner | 15 |
| RP2 | Denny Baez | 7 | RP2 | Keith Foulke | 19 | RP2 | Octavio Dotel (1 yr) | 8 | RP2 | Braden Looper | 14 |
| P1 | Joel Pinerio | 9 | P1 | Jeremy Affelt | 2 | P1 | CC Sabithina | 8 | P1 | Brad Penny | 4 |
| P2 | Livan Hernandez | 6 | P2 | Bobby Madrisch | 4 | P2 | Jeremy Bonderman | 13 | P2 | Jarret Wright | 4 |
| Util | Mike Adams | 5 | Util | Cliff Lee | 1 | Util | Latroy Hawkins | 1 | Util | Paul Lo Duca | 4 |
| Util | Al Lieter | 1 | Util | Russ Ortiz | 1 | Util | John Leiber | 5 | Util | Jason Marquis | 4 |
| Util | Matt Lawton | 3 | Util | Joe Boroski | 1 | Util | Vincent Paddillia | 4 | Util | Woody Williams | 1 |
| Util | Matt Morris | 3 | Util | Dimitri Young | 1 | Util | Jeremy Burnitz | 6 | Util | Jarrod Washburn | 1 |
| REMAINING | 3 | REMAINING | 4 | REMAINING | 6 | REMAINING | 7 |