Ecuador's Slippery Slope

    For a long time in Ecuador the government has said
that Plan Colombia has nothing to do with us. And even
the concession of the U.S. Base at Manta was not going
to affect us because this was only to monitor drug
trafficking. But it's an advanced military base with
high technology which is the eyes and ears of Plan
Colombia. From there they are going to control the
operations. Hopefully they're not going to be any
bombings.
     As a result of this we can't deny that we're now
in Plan Colombia through our base. The government has
said it opposes regionalization of Plan Colombia but
it's already a fact. It's a matter of how to manage
it. We can't say we're against regionalization when we
have the base at Manta as one of the pillars of Plan
Colombia. The political discourse has been deceiving.

The Need for a Comprehensive Andean Response

     The majority of our energy in Ecuador is going to
go toward confronting the effects. We have to do that
as an emergency response
but it isn't going to solve anything. Until we solve
the root causes this is going to continue and Plan
Colombia is going to be here a long time. They're
talking about ten years.
     We as human rights people believe that the
military solution is not going to work. The reductions
(in coke production) that were achieved in Peru and
Bolivia resulted in increases in Colombia. If they
decide to reduce production in Colombia it will
relocate somewhere else. This is not going to resolve
the problem. And there's going to be an unprecedented
damage to the people and the land.
     Our position would be that the U.S.-Colombia
devised approach of controlling drug trafficking is
defining the course of all the Andean Region. What is
needed is an alternative relationship such as the US
together with the Andean Region. I also think Brazil
would be interested. I think this would be a more
viable alternative. We at least we would have some say
in this. Because while we depend on what's agreed to by
the U.S. and Colombia we don't have anything. We have
to accept what they have decided. In addition to the
social control factors there's also the natural
resources. In the Putomayo area there's a lot of
petroleum and it is crucial to controlling the Amazon
Basin. This would include the bio diversity and the
water resources. The threat of a regional arms race is
also a harmful factor. The $1.3 billion for the
Colombian Army; that is going to make the Colombian
army the strongest army in the area. And its going to
cause an arms buildup in the other countries. This
will bring more problems, hopefully not border
conflicts. But maybe it will increase the internal
repression.

Increased Power for Ecuador's Military

    Traditionally the face of repression in Ecuador
has been the police which is not the the case in the
other countries. Traditionally it has been the army.
But lately the military has been given the role of
maintaining internal order which isn't its role. This
is also harmful. There's a recent problem that the
Ecuadoran military is detaining Colombians. This is
not their function. It should be the police that
arrests these people if they've committed a crime.
They're detaining Colombians for being Colombians. In
some cases there have been complaints of torture. I
have heard of seven cases but these still have to be
investigated and documented.




More