Dallas News.com(The Dallas Morning News)
Gifts of wonder: Scientists reflect on things that sparked their quest for knowledge
12/24/2001
A passion for science has to start somewhere. As the scientists here tell us, it can begin with a simple gift. Perhaps the gift is someone else's time or a shared sense of wonder at nature. Sometimes it's a quiet place where serendipity and science meet. And often it's a tangible offering from a relative or mentor – when opening a box can mean opening a whole new world.
The glass flask
When I was 8 years old my aunt came to visit and gave me a distillation flask. It was a beautiful piece of glassware from her chemistry lab at the University of Wyoming. My aunt, Sara Jane Rhoads, was one of the first women in the United States to attain the rank of full professor of chemistry.Like the glass flask, she was brilliant. She was my hero, and I loved her beyond all reason. I used to call her the "Colossus of Rhoads." I remember vividly playing with the distillation flask while my family sat around the living room talking and enjoying Aunt Sara's visit.
And I remember to my horror breaking the flask by accident, and after many tears watching as my beloved aunt tried (unsuccessfully) to seal it back together again with my father's blowtorch. This simple gift started my career in chemistry – and my strangely deep interest in glass blowing!
Richard Smalley is a chemist at Rice University. He shared the 1996 Nobel Prize in chemistry for the discovery of buckyballs.
Lessons that last
My science gifts, both tangible and intangible, were spread throughout my childhood, but the time around the sixth grade sticks in my head. I remember chemistry sets, and frog dissection kits, and being outside. My father brought home a bittern with a broken wing. A retired geologist took me out to find fossils, taught me how to identify a tektite, and showed me how to tie a diamond hitch on a pack mule, which I have never done but I still hope to do. Now my gifts come every day.Louis Jacobs is a paleontologist at Southern Methodist University and the author of Lone Star Dinosaurs.
Calculated thrills
I think my favorite science gift was when my dad gave me an HP-45 hand calculator in 1974.Electronic calculators had just been invented, and the first HP-35s cost $800, a huge amount for a graduate student (equivalent to several months' rent!). But suddenly the slide rule (a key appliance for a physics major) was obsolete. For my master's graduation, Dad gave me the new HP-45. Better than the 35 because it had more functions and even modest programming ability. And the price had fallen to $400 – still well out of reach for me, but it made a gift that I treasured.
Square roots were a snap, and it had sines, cosines, and logarithms – heaven! Before that, we had to carry around tables to look the functions up, and then to do the six-digit multiplications was a pain. I always managed to miss a carry somewhere. But now all the calculations were done like magic.
I think I still have it tucked away somewhere. And I still get the best new electronic device whenever it comes out – right now it's my Apple Titanium laptop. I make movies, I analyze my science data, I send e-mails to friends. And all for about the same cost (in months of rent) as that first HP-45.
Patricia Reiff is director of the Rice Space Institute at Rice University.Bones everywhere
There is no question at all about my most memorable science-related gift. I had attended the University of Texas at Austin and eventually ventured out into the business world. I was miserable. As an escape, I often went backpacking in Big Bend National Park.Near sunset on one multiday hike, I put down my pack, ate a bite, and then went to the top of a nearby hill to drink a small glass of wine. This is a precious moment to a hiker. After sitting for a moment I soon realized that the entire hill was littered with dinosaur bones. I was amazed. I looked at the bones until it was dark. I sat there in the dark trying to imagine what that beast must have been like, what Big Bend must have been like millions of years ago.
Very soon after, I came to the University of Texas at Dallas for a Ph.D. in paleontology. I now study those bones and the enclosing rocks, or at least some like them. The problem is, I have not been able to find that same site from many years ago.
Homer Montgomery is a paleontologist and science education specialist at the University of Texas at Dallas. Among other projects, he excavates dinosaurs in Big Bend National Park.Humor and humanity
I've got one answer that sits right on my desktop at all times, though often buried by papers. It's a signed, slim book in a cardboard case, titled Up the Ivy by Academicus Mentor (the pen name of Ashley Montagu). When I was finishing my sophomore year of classes at Princeton, Dr. Montagu was in his late 70s but taught with the vigor of a newly minted Ph.D. student. He had the most amazing recall of any person I've met and could tell you page and verse, as well as the book-cover color, of most things he'd read. Dr. Montagu gave me the book as a Christmas gift after I'd finished his class on human nature. It's a tongue-in-cheek text on "how to succeed in academic sciences," and includes such gems as "Keep a weather eye out for early trends in research that may become fashionable."I keep the book with me to remind myself that we have to be well-humored and humane in our search for knowledge. With the book he also gave me this advice: "Always ask why. And don't be surprised if a student tells you the answer." He's been right a number of times.
Michael Adler is an archaeologist at Southern Methodist University. He specializes in the ancestral Pueblo traditions of northern New Mexico.Death Valley awakening
It was February 1971. I had just turned 20 and had no idea what to do with my life. Melissa (now my wife) and I loved to travel and be outdoors together, and we'd lost interest in school. We dropped out of college in California and were hitchhiking around the state. After a few weeks of this, I left Melissa and her toothache with her mother in Los Angeles and set out alone to see Death Valley for the first time. I had no interest in science.The second day out, it was late afternoon when I was dropped off in the middle of the Panamint Valley. The desert sky was clear, and the road was visible for miles, coming straight down the range to the west and going straight up the range to the east, where I was headed. I'd had only one short ride since leaving Highway 395 at the south end of Owens Lake around noon. The sun would set soon, and there was no point trying to hitch a ride in the dark on this unlit, two-lane desert road.
I saw no traffic, so I decided to use the remaining daylight to find a place where I could get out of the wind and build a small fire and lay out my sleeping bag. The immediate future promised another bad dinner and a cold and windy night alone. Before I had gone very far from the road, a big white step van – an old bread truck – pulled up from out of nowhere and stopped. To this day, I have no idea why I didn't see it on the road earlier. Two guys about my age asked if I wanted a lift; they were headed to Death Valley. I jumped at the chance. They were geologists – fossil collectors, really – looking for things to take back to San Francisco to sell.
There wasn't a third seat in the bread truck, so I sat on the steps and watched the country roll by. The rocks around Death Valley were unbelievably beautiful, all kinds of browns, yellows, and reds, twisted into all sorts of shapes. When they stopped the van, away from prying eyes and in the middle of nowhere, I got out to help them search. I had no idea what to look for, and I'm sure my stupid questions must have made them regret picking me up.
For me, every answer brought more questions, and my interest in rocks grew while we climbed up hills and stopped to turn over rocks. We didn't find anything worth collecting, but the way they read the rocks captivated me. I wanted to be able to read the book of the Earth, too, and when they dropped me off in Pahrump, Nevada, a few days later, I knew that if I ever went back to college, I would take a geology course or two.
I have no idea whatever happened to those guys, but my motivation to do whatever it takes to learn all that I can about the Earth dates from that ride.
Robert Stern is a professor and chair of the geosciences department at the University of Texas at Dallas.Uncle Dan's hand
My uncle, Dan Miller, had a great influence on my life, giving me differential-equations books when I was in the fifth grade and taking me to his campus when I was in the sixth grade (got to run a nuclear reactor, a real nuclear reactor). Then I chose to go to that school, the University of Missouri, Rolla, majoring in nuclear engineering.He gave me as a Christmas/go-to-college present a matched set of slide rules (this was just before calculators, but I am not that old). I remember leather cases, yellow-painted aluminum slide rules. One was a large, 16-inch one with a belt loop (real nerdy look) for precision calculations, and another was a small, 6-inch size in a leather case with a pocket clip for estimated calculations that just had to be done right then. I still have these slide rules – too bad they went the way of the Edsel. But they will never run out of power.
Harold R. "Skip" Garner is a professor of biochemistry and internal medicine at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas. He once built a robot called Dr. Prepper that prepared DNA for sequencing.
Curiosity, not coal
I don't think it was the humorous – I hope – lump of coal from my sister that predestined me for a Ph.D. and career in geology. Every Christmas there was at least one '50s boy tech toy under the tree: the Gilbert chemistry set, the little microscope nestled in its wooden box, the metal erector set. Each fed and aroused what would become a passion for understanding and manipulating the physical world.But the annual subscription to Scientific American probably was the deal maker. It was a gift from my grandfather, not a scientist he, but a businessman, an importer of fine wool. During high school, in the Sputnik era, Scientific American introduced me to the breadth of science and technology and their relation to society. Good reading at the critical moment.
Nick Pingitore is a geologist at the University of Texas at El Paso.
Disassembly required
When I was in seventh grade, I got to take electronics shop in junior high school and found it fascinating. For Christmas, my dad gave me a soldering iron so I could work on electronics projects at home. I would get old TVs, radios, and other appliances that people would throw out, and use my soldering iron to take them apart to try and understand how they worked. I saved all the resistors, capacitors, and transformers with the intent of building a TV – someday.The gift of the soldering iron indirectly fueled my curiosity about how things work, and this has stayed with me through my career as a particle physicist. Now I take protons and neutrons apart to understand how they work. As with the old appliances, fortunately we don't have to put the protons back together.
While it was the high-tech electronic equipment that stimulated my imagination and drew me into the physics field, somewhere along the way I became a theorist, so now they don't let me into the lab (possibly for my own good). Therefore, I do my experiments on paper and with computer simulations.
Fred Olness is a physicist at Southern Methodist University. He co-directs the Dallas Regional Science & Engineering Fair.
Advice and reward
Without a doubt, the most important scientific gift I ever received was the strong advice of my father to pursue a career in biochemistry. I hope that gift was returned when he attended my induction into the National Academy of Sciences 20 years later.
Eric Olson is chairman of the Department of Molecular Biology at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas.
Doorway to the desert
Certainly the gift that changed my life was a magazine dropped in my lap by a fellow graduate student in geology as I was eating lunch in the cafeteria of Johns Hopkins University three decades ago. The cover story in the February 1970 issue of Scientific American led me on a 30-year odyssey of exploration and discovery in one of the most infamous and mysterious desert regions in the world: the Afar Depression of Ethiopia.The area was described as "one of the world's most forbidding regions," with some of the highest temperatures and lowest elevations on Earth – a "nightmarish desert landscape." Exactly one year later I arrived in Ethiopia, following the conviction that the greatest discoveries are made where no one else will go, when no one else will go.
Throughout much of the next decade I explored the Afar region and in the process co-founded the team that discovered the 3-million-year-old "Lucy" skeleton and led surveys in areas that have since produced the oldest human remains known (5.8 million years). Altogether the desert that had been labeled "terra incognita" has given us the longest, most complete fossil and archaeological record known.
Jon Kalb is a paleoanthropologist based in Austin. He is the author of Adventures in the Bone Trade: The Race to Discover Human Ancestors in Ethiopia's Afar Depression.
Chemistry testing
When I was 8 years old my parents bought me a chemistry set. It was nothing fancy. But it contained enough different chemicals – mostly things that one can find at home now, but some other substances that they no longer sell over the counter – that made solutions change colors, that generate a lot of effervescence, made colloidal solutions, made temperature changes, and determined the acidity of solutions before I knew what any of the changes meant.Shortly thereafter, my father acquired a compound microscope from government surplus that allowed me to see things differently. The pursuit of new and different insights and eventually basic understanding that accompanied them about the world around me dogged me until I went to college. But it wasn't until I took my first course in plant biology that I realized I wanted to know more about the organisms that underpin life on land.
I still use basic chemistry and microscopy on a daily basis, though I like to think that the sophistication of the things I see, the changes I detect, and my understanding of the perceptions they offer are greater than when I was 8.
Bruce Benz is an ethnobotanist at Texas Wesleyan University in Fort Worth. He studies the origin of maize cultivation.
View to the moon
Like many kids growing up in the '60s, I was entranced by the space program and astronomy. So when I was 10 I finally got the one present I had wanted for years: a telescope. It was a little 2 ½ -inch reflector from Sears, and the cool thing in the catalog was that it had a second viewer at the back end where you could see images from a little View-Master-like slide projector. Those images turned out to be pretty bad, but I was more interested in what I could see for real from my back yard in Fort Worth.So the first night I got it out and looked at the moon and was blown away at the clear image. Next, I went looking for the nebula in Orion's sword (easy to find when you're having to point by sighting along the barrel). My reaction was the same as my college astronomy students 20 years later: "That's it? Why doesn't it look as cool as the color pictures in my books?" But just when I was about to give up, I pointed it toward Saturn. While it was too small a telescope to see the rings distinctly, I could clearly see a small football-shaped blob in the eyepiece. So while it wasn't a spectacularly powerful telescope, it still captured my imagination, and I continued to use it for stargazing until I left for college.
Marc Hairston is a space physicist at the University of Texas at Dallas.
Eves of destruction
A chemistry set. It had far more chemicals than are presently permitted. In my childhood, lots could be done with the chemicals included in the set. I had little interest in the prescribed experiments. The stinky smells, burning-induced clouds, and explosions were the order of the day.I then graduated to more potent exploding systems, always chemical based, that I often inserted into model cars and toys. They were detonated thermally with a fuse or electronic resistive heating from a distance. I even devised a launch system from an air gun that could accurately propel a small chemical-covered piece of wood which exploded into a flame when it hit a hard object.
I had many enjoyable hours all alone with my chemical experiments and thoroughly enjoyed watching models (sometimes containing insects) get blown to flaming bits. All models were built with the intent of destroying them, as I recall. I never remember my parents scolding me or worrying about my safety. Nowadays we are so prone to protect our little ones that I think we stifle their creativity, although we accordingly fend off the natural selection process that used to weed out some of our little companions.
James Tour is a chemist at Rice University.
Mother's instinct
The June day after school let out when I was 15 years old, my mother asked me what my plans were for the summer. I told her I hoped to slouch on the couch and watch television. "That," she announced, "isn't good enough." She showed me a piece in our newspaper about an archaeological excavation that was beginning in a week's time in the nearby Shenandoah Valley. "Would you like to join the group?" "Sure," I said, figuring at that late date the university's plans must already be set and they couldn't possibly want to take some snotty high school kid. I went back to My Favorite Martian.Never underestimate your mother.
A day later she'd made fast friends with the administrative assistant at the office, who then talked the project director into taking me on. He wasn't keen on my being there, either! That was 30 years ago. I've been doing archaeology ever since.
I'm not sure why that newspaper story caught my mother's eye, or why she thought her son would enjoy the experience. And I'm certain she didn't imagine it would set me on a career. But I guess that's just a mother's gift, now, isn't it?
David Meltzer is an archaeologist at Southern Methodist University who studies North American Paleoindian groups.