Health Seeking Behaviour of Rajbanshi ethnic group in Katahari and Baijanathpur villages of Morang, Nepal (Part-1)
Summary
Introduction
Methodology
Instruments
Presentation and discussion
Population and Land distribution
Population and Education
Education and Sickness
Sex and Sickness reported
Morbidity in Rajbanshi
Access of PHC services
Medical Practices: Modern Medication, Self Medication
Alternative Medication
Medications and Economic condition
Medication and Education status
Conclusion
Summary
Objective: The objective of the study was to assess the health seeking
behaviors in Rajbanshi community. Specific objective of the study was to assess
the practices of using traditional and modern medicine on the basis of economic
and education status. Design: Descriptive, Quantitative as well as Focus
Group Discussion (FGD) and Observation for Qualitative information. Setting:
This study was conducted in two different Villages, Katahari and Baijanathpur of
Morang district, selected purposively based on thick settlement. Subjects:
175 households of two VDCs were selected from the VDCs rosters using random
number table for convenience and to cover the expected households. Main
outcome measures: Demographic information, and medication practices on the
basis of economic and education status. Results: Katahari and
Baijanathpur VDCs had literacy rate 65% in the taken sample. Principal
occupation was agriculture. Majority of people falls in the category of having
zero (no land) to less then 2 bigahs. Average family size is 5.76 persons. There
were 61% male and 39% female reported sick. Common types of diseases/ symptoms
were reported as headache, bodyache, weakness (50.8) and then ARI (44), fever
(30.8), Eye/ ENT (18.8), diarrhoea (13.7) respectively. Distribution of reported
illness was highest among the age group of 66 year and above. People were
getting service through private clinics (72.0%), hospital (33.3%) Sub-health
post (15.4%). Economically Poor and medium people were adopting self-medication
significantly higher than rich (P=0.0160). Similarly the use of self-medication
by uneducated was significantly higher than those educated (P= 0.0000063). On
the other hand rich was adopting alternative medication significantly higher
than other (P= 0.0000). It was also found that there was no difference in the
use of modern medication between educated and uneducated people(P=0.3753).Conclusions:
There is a relationship between economic, education status and health seeking
behaviour in Rajbanshi community.
Introduction
Rajbanshi is one of the 61 ethnic groups7 in Nepal. Ethnic or
Indigenous people are having low health status in the world.8 Health
Seeking Behaviour is a usual habit of a people or a community that is resulted
by the interaction and balance between health needs, health resources,
socio-economic and cultural as well as national/ international contextual
factors 1. It is behaviour of using health services within existing
health system or treatment seeking behaviour of the latest illness as reported
by them. This was categorized as (a) Modern medication such as Hospital, HP/SHP
and private clinic (b) Alternative medication such as Ayurvedic and Homeopathic
system of medication; and (c) Self-medication such as Dhami/Jhakri (Shaman
healers), drug retailers, grocery keepers, drug peddlers, household medicine and
other than modern and alternative medication. Kafle and Gartoulla 2
(1993) and Gartaula 3 (1998) have categorized self medication as
Shamanism, Priest, Dhami-Jhakri, herbal, drug retailers, grocery, kit-bag, drug
peddler, neighbour, following old medicine prescriptions etc and except the
present prescription by a qualified medical practitioners. WSMI 4
(2001) has indicated as "Self-medication is the use of specifically
designed, labelled and authorized medicines available legally without
prescription for the treatment or prevention of common illnesses, which can be
recognized by the people. Traditional medicine is not included in the national
health system. If traditional medicines are legally available without a doctor's
prescription, then they are included in what we call self-medication.
Alternative medicine is medicine which is outside the regular allopathic
medicine 5. Sometimes it is accepted by national health plans for
coverage and sometimes it is not 6. This would cover for example,
acupuncture, Ayurved, naturopathy, and homeopathic medicine etc.
Methodology and materials.
1.The households were visited on the basis of random number table. They were
asked relevant questions with the history of illness/ disease within three
months from interview date. Of those who were ill / sick person of the above
criteria were consulted for detailed information otherwise only demography was
taken for the rest. 2. Roster analysis of VDC, DDC. 3. Secondary Sources. 4.
Instruments. 5. Consent-Verbal 6. Interview. 7. Focus Group Discussion. The
participants for FGD were requested to have one and half an hour’s sessions
for the reason of their self-medication during household visits. Personal
contacts with self-medicated population within three months of study period were
made to have 8 persons in one FGD and attempted total ten FGD with 80 persons.
Instrumentation. (Development of
tools).
Structured and in-depth questionnaire was prepared to interview the target
people having disease or not; So, the interview would explore their
health-seeking behavior. 1. Individual Interview. 2. Observation of medicines if
any. 3. Focus Group Discussion guidelines.
Table I. Population distribution by Land |
|
Table II Population distribution by Education |
||||
Land (Economic Status) |
Number (n=175) |
Percentage |
Educational Status |
Number (n=175) |
Percentage |
|
0-2 Bgahas (Poor) |
107 |
61.1 |
Uneducated |
130 |
74.3 |
|
2-4 Bigahas (Med) |
22 |
12.6 |
Educated |
45 |
25.7 |
|
4-above (Rich) |
46 |
23.3 |
Total |
175 |
100 |
In table No. I. In accordance to the peoples' existing perception, people were economically classified as: Poor - people having no land to having land up to 2 bigahas, Medium - people having 2.1 to 4 bigahas and Rich - 4.1 to above for the study purpose. Similarly, People were educationally classified as: Uneducated - illiterate to literate only and SLC passed and above were considered as Educated for the study purpose that is shown in table No. II.
Education |
Sickness (n) |
Percentage |
Educated |
45 |
26.0 |
Uneducated |
130 |
74.0 |
Total |
175 |
100.0 |
Table III indicates that uneducated (74%) were getting more sickness than educated (26%)
Sex |
Number |
Percentage |
Male |
107 |
61.1 |
Female |
68 |
38.9 |
Total |
175 |
100 |
Table IV presents as males were found to be reported sick by 61.1% and female 38.9%. This might be due to the gender bias in opportunity to report illness and problems.
Table V. Illness condition encountered in Rajbanshi community.
S.No. |
Diseases |
Frequency |
Proportion Percentage |
1 |
Headache,bodyache,weakness |
89 |
50.8 |
2 |
Acute Respiratory Infection (ARI) |
77 |
44.0 |
3 |
Fever |
54 |
30.8 |
4 |
Eye/ENT/Oral Problems |
33 |
18.8 |
5 |
Diarrhoea/Dysentry |
24 |
13.7 |
6 |
Gastritis(APD) |
24 |
13.7 |
7 |
Skin diseases |
13 |
7.4 |
8 |
Tuberculosis |
10 |
5.7 |
9 |
Rheumatoid Arthritis |
9 |
5.1 |
10 |
Asthma (COPD) |
7 |
4.0 |
11 |
Dogbite |
5 |
2.4 |
12 |
Typhoid |
4 |
2.2 |
13 |
Paralysis |
4 |
2.2 |
14 |
Accident/Fracture |
3 |
1.7 |
15 |
Diabetes |
3 |
1.7 |
16 |
Jaundice |
2 |
1.1 |
17 |
Gynae/Obs. |
2 |
1.1 |
18 |
Kala-azar |
1 |
0.5 |
They reported that the nature of illness changes as the weather changes. Diseases such as ARI, TB, Kalazar, Asthma were mentioned clearly in the prescription by health care providers when the old prescription at their home were analyzed. The researcher observed some cases himself. Headache/ bodyache/ weakness was reported by 50.8%, ARI by 44.0%, Fever by 30.8%, Eye/ENT/Oral by 18.8%, Diarrhoea by 13.7%, Gastritis by 13.7%, skin diseases by 7.4% respectively.
Table VI. Use of PHC services by any member of the households during last 3 months.
PHC Services |
Service takers (n=175) |
Proportion Percentage |
EPI Camp |
139 |
79.4 |
FCHV |
88 |
50.2 |
VHW |
50 |
28.5 |
MCHW |
19 |
10.8 |
PHC-ORC |
16 |
9.1 |
TBA |
10 |
5.7 |
Majority of the people were found using EPI-camp (79.4%) for immunizing their children. Half of the people have taken service from FCHV (50.2). But TBA, PHC-ORC and MCHW were of relatively low access.
Medication Practices: Figure I. presents the pattern of health care
practices. 96% people were adopting modern medication as an alternative after
self care. Alternative medication was adopted by 22.8% either in Homeopathic or
in Ayurvedic one. This indicates that poly-practices in poly-pharmacy and or in
polyclinics/HP/SHP/PHC/Hospital were the indicators of Rajbanshi health seeking
behaviour.
|
Table-VIII Self-medication |
|||||
Category |
Number (n=168) |
Proportional Percent |
Category |
Number (n=100) |
Proportional Percent |
|
Private Clinic |
121 |
72.0 |
Dhami/Jhakri |
60 |
66 |
|
Hospital |
56 |
33.3 |
Retailer |
40 |
40 |
|
SHP/ HP |
23 |
15.4 |
Herbal |
22 |
22 |
|
|
|
|
Old medicine |
1 |
1 |
(a) Modern medication i.e. allopathic medication through health care providers followed usually after self and alternative-medication. In the community out of 168 people private clinics were used by 72.0%, hospital by 33.3% and SHP/HP by 15.4%. In other words, people often went to the private clinics rather than hospital and health post/ sub-health post.
(b) Self-medication
Table- IX. Category of DJ Practices |
||
Category |
Number (n=168) |
Proportional Percent |
Phukphak |
61 |
62.4 |
Worship |
53 |
80.3 |
Sacrifices |
25 |
14.2 |
As presented in the table IX people were found using DJ by 51%(66), retailer by 31%(40) and herbal by 17%(22) and following old prescription by 1%. (1). Self-medication was adopted commonly by poor and medium economic classes in community. Dhami/Jhakris were doing Phukphak, Worship and Sacrifice. People used to go to Dhami/Jhakri /Shaman and were found still having strong belief upon their healing power. They regard DJ as a part of life that need in every ritual and without them their lives become incomplete. They were also familiar with the retailer's shop and used to buy drugs and preparing herbal medicine at home conventionally.
Table- X. Alternative medication |
||
Category |
Number (n=100) |
Proportional Percent |
Ayurvedic |
28 |
70.0 |
Homeopathic |
12 |
30.0 |
Table X. Illustrates that out of the total 175 respondents 22.8% (40) were adopting alternative medication and among them 70.0% (28) had adopted Ayurvedic and by 30.0% (12) patients had adopted Homeopathic medication.
Table-XI. Economic condition and medications.
Medication |
Poor (n=107) |
Medium (n=22) |
Rich (n=46) |
P - Value. |
Modern Medication |
104 (97.2) |
20 (90.9) |
44 (95.6) |
0.3871 |
Self-Medication |
68 (63.6) |
14 (63.6) |
18 (39.1) |
0.0160 |
Alternative Med. |
19 (17.7) |
7 (31.8) |
40 (87.0) |
0.0000 |
Table XI presents that 97.2% poor, 90.9% medium and 95.6% rich people were adopting modern medication. Poor 63.6%, medium 63.6% and rich 39.1% people were adopting Self-medication respectively. Similarly Poor 17.7%, medium 31.8% and rich 87.0% people were adopting Alternative medication respectively. There was no difference in the use of modern medication among different economic level people that is statistically insignificant (P= 0.3871). It was found that there was highly significant practice of self-medication being adopted by poor (P=0.0160). Likewise, rich were found largely adopting the alternative medication than others which was statistically highly significant (P= 0.0000).
Table XII. Education and medication.
Medications |
Uneducated (n=130) |
Educated (n=45) |
P - Value |
Modern Medication |
126 (96.9) |
42 (93.3) |
0.3753 |
Self-Medication |
85 (65.4) |
14 (31.1) |
0.0000063 |
Alternative Med. |
27 (20.8) |
13 (28.8) |
0.2635 |
It was found that there was no difference in the use of modern medication between educated and uneducated (P=0.3753). But use of self-medication by uneducated was significantly higher than those educated (P= 0.0000063). And there was also no difference in the use of alternative medication between educated and uneducated (P= 0.2635).
Conclusion: There was no difference in the use of modern medication among different economic levels (P= 0.3871). Likewise there was no difference in the use of alternative medication between educated and uneducated (P= 0.2635). But Poor and medium people were adopting self-medications significantly higher than rich (P=0.0160). Similarly the use of self-medication by uneducated was significantly higher than those who were educated (P= 0.0000063). On the other hand rich were adopting alternative medication significantly higher than others (P= 0.0000). People were found using the EPI-Camp (79.4%) and FCHV (50.2%) but 89.2% population was still unknown to MCHW, TBA and PHC-ORC and its services.
References:
1. M.Corlien, et.al (1991), Designing and conducting Health
System Research Projects,Heath system research training series, WHO/ IDRC.
2. Kafle, K.K.,Gartoulla,R.P., (1993), Self-medication and its impact on
essential drugs Scheme in Nepal, W.H.O. DAP -
10.
3. Gartoulla, R.P. (1998), An introduction to medical sociology and medical
anthropology, RECID, Kathmandu, Nepal.
4. Reinstein, J. (2001), World Self Medication Industry (WSMI), UK, www.wsmi.org
5. Agarwal S.K., (n.d.), A guide to Alternative medicine, Indian board of
Alternative medicine (IBAM), Calcutta, India.
6. Gartoulla,R.P., (1998), Therapy pattern of conventional medicine with other
alternative Medicine, RECID, Kathmandu, Nepal.
7. Prospectus (2000) of HMG, MLD, National Committee for Development of
Nationalities,.
8. Mabuhang, B.K., (2000),"Policy Approaches to Indigenous People Health
Issues"
Population and Development in Nepal Journal, TU
CDoPS, Vol.7, Kathmandu.
©2002. Nawaraj Subba, nrsubba@hotpop.com