|
Click on each photo to see enlarged view
Can you see only the face or also the letters?
How many points are there in this prong and where is the middle one?
Is the bottom half vertical or horizontal?
The two black posts are of the same size, though the nearer one looks smaller
Is it a bird or a bunny?
Are the three circles in the inner surface or outer surface?
How many legs does this elephant have?
Which way is this figure facing?
Are the dots black or white?
Look at the dot. The outer portion will seem to fade?
Look at the black portion. The filament will seem to glow
SOME ILLUSIONS
Most of us take vision for granted. We seem to do it so effortlessly; however, perceiving images,
objects, color, and motion is a very complicated process.
Take a moment to observe the world around you. For example, if you tilt your head, the world
doesn't tilt. If you shut one eye, you don't immediately lose depth perception. Look at what
happens to color under varying types of illumination. Move around an object: The shape you see
changes, yet the object remains stable. Look at some of the illusions on this page. Even
though you may intellectually know that you are being fooled, it does not stop the effect from
continuing to trick you. This indicates a split between your perception of something and your
conception of it. In many cases your higher order cognitive abilities can not influence your
lower order perceptions.
Only in the last one hundred years, and especially in the last twenty years, have scientists
started to make some progress in understanding vision and perception. Illusions can be a
wonderful window into this process. And they are fun too! Because they combine both the element
of joy with the element of surprise.
The late, great physicist Richard Feynman wrote, "It's quite wonderful that we can 'see,' or
figure it out so easily. Someone who's standing at my left can see somebody who's standing at my
right - that is, the light can be going this way across, or that way across, or this way up, or
that way down; it's a complete network. Some quantity is shaking about, in a combination of
motions so elaborate and complicated the net result is to produce an influence which makes me
see you, completely undisturbed by the fact that at the same time there are influences that
represent the guy on my left side seeing the guy on my right side. The light's there
anyway....it bounces off this, and it bounces off that - all this is going on, and yet we can
sort it out with this instrument, our eye."
This is not the end of this wonderful process. Light waves enter your eye and then enter
photoreceptive cells on your retina. The image that forms on your retina is flat, yet you
perceive a world of shape, color, depth, and motion.
How does our visual system recover three-dimensional information? This is an important question.
Our retinal images, whether from a two-dimensional image or from the three-dimensional world,
are flat representations on a curved surface. Yet, for the most part, we perceive an accurate
world of depth, surfaces and objects.
A closely related problem is that any one aspect of a visual scene is spatially ambiguous. There
is an innate ambiguity in the retinal input (many to many mapping between objects and retinal
images). In other words, for any given retinal image, there are an infinite variety of possible
three-dimensional structures that can give rise to it. Our visual system, however, usually
settles for the correct interpretation. When a mistake is made, an illusion occurs.
The fact that we can recover accurate three-dimensional information from a visually ambiguous
two-dimensional representation means that some very powerful constraints must be imposed on our
interpretations of two-dimensional images.
These constraints must also account for many illusions. In fact, illusions are a powerful and
fun tool for revealing constraints that mediate vision and perception. In some cases, illusions
take place because the constraints for interpreting an image are ambiguous. Your visual system
can interpret the scene in more than one way. Even though the image on your retina remains
constant, you never see an odd mixture of the two perceptions - it is always one or the other,
although they may perceptually flip back and forth. Normally, this does not happen in the real
world, as your visual system has evolved many different ways to resolve ambiguity. Visual
perception is essentially an ambiguity-solving process. This process is called "inverse optics."
The early visual process behaves intelligently, but mostly in a bottom-up fashion (separated from
cognitive processes). The visual system is also highly adaptive, e.g., visual adaptation is not
merely fatique. It should be understood that both evolution and learning contribute to visual
capabilities.
Artists have also been trying to understand how we perceive, and much of our understanding of
vision comes from learning how artists manipulate images into meaningful and realistic scenes.
Artists have always created illusions. That's their business.
Artists and scientists over the years have experimented with these rules to produce illusions
either by reducing the number of visual cues for interpreting images or by deliberately setting
up situations where the rules come into conflict.
|