| Year | Player | Club |
| 1948 | Stanley Matthews | Blackpool |
| 1949 | Johnny Carey | Manchester United |
| 1950 | Joe Mercer | Arsenal |
| 1951 | Harry Johnston | Blackpool |
| 1952 | Billy Wright | Wolverhampton Wanderers |
| 1953 | Nat Lofthouse | Bolton Wanderers |
| 1954 | Tom Finney | Preston North End |
| 1955 | Don Revie | Manchester City |
| 1956 | Bert Trautmann | Manchester City |
| 1957 | Tom Finney | Preston North End |
| 1958 | Danny Blanchflower | Tottenham Hotspur |
| 1959 | Syd Owen | Luton Town |
| 1960 | Bill Slater | Wolverhampton Wanderers |
| 1961 | Danny Blanchflower | Tottenham Hotspur |
| 1962 | Jimmy Adamson | Burnley |
| 1963 | Stanley Matthews | Stoke City |
| 1964 | Bobby Moore | West Ham United |
| 1965 | Bobby Collins | Leeds United |
| 1966 | Bobby Charlton | Manchester United |
| 1967 | Jackie Charlton | Leeds United |
| 1968 | George Best | Manchester United |
| 1969 | Dave Mackay
Tony Book |
Derby County
Manchester City |
| 1970 | Billy Bremner | Leeds United |
| 1971 | Frank McLintock | Arsenal |
| 1972 | Gordon Banks | Stoke City |
| 1973 | Pat Jennings | Tottenham Hotspur |
| 1974 | Ian Callaghan | Liverpool |
| 1975 | Alan Mullery | Fulham |
| 1976 | Kevin Keegan | Liverpool |
| 1977 | Emlyn Hughes | Liverpool |
| 1978 | Kenny Burns | Nottingham Forest |
| 1979 | Kenny Dalglish | Liverpool |
| 1980 | Terry McDermott | Liverpool |
| 1981 | Frans Thijssen | Ipswich Town |
| 1982 | Steve Perryman | Tottenham Hotspur |
| 1983 | Kenny Dalglish | Liverpool |
| 1984 | Ian Rush | Liverpool |
| 1985 | Neville Southall | Everton |
| 1986 | Gary Lineker | Everton |
| 1987 | Clive Allen | Tottenham Hotspur |
| 1988 | John Barnes | Liverpool |
| 1989 | Steve Nicol | Liverpool |
| 1990 | John Barnes | Liverpool |
| 1991 | Gordon Strachan | Leeds United |
| 1992 | Gary Lineker | Tottenham Hotspur |
| 1993 | Chris Waddle | Sheffield Wednesday |
| 1994 | Alan Shearer | Blackburn Rovers |
| 1995 | Jurgen Klinsmann | Tottenham Hotspur |
| 1996 | Eric Cantona | Manchester United |
| 1997 | Gianfranco Zola | Chelsea |
| 1998 | Dennis Bergkamp | Arsenal |
| 1999 | David Ginola | Tottenham Hotspur |
| 2000 | Roy Keane | Manchester United |
| 2001 | Teddy Sheringham | Manchester United |