Juxtaposition
"A dream itself is but a shadow."
Juxtaposition is the literary term that describes the comparison of two items by placing them side by side in order to accomplish a desired effect. And for some time now there's been that constant comparison between the love stories in FFVII and VIII, with some similarities being more obvious than others.
So not focusing on appearances alone, how close do both tales actually come to each other? Here's the basic run-down.
First we'll take a look at the beginning FMV since it's the first impression of the game. The first person made known to the player, but not introduced, is the heroine/love interest, alone in a secluded area.
She is holding her main symbol, which will become of greater significance later in the game. In Aeris' case, it's the "holy" materia, and for Rinoa, a feather.
Directly afterwards, we meet our protagonists (respectively), Cloud and Squall. Both are the withdrawn, insensitive, silent type and will be our reluctant anti-heroes. They are fueled by their own personal grudge and weld large heavy swords (Squall uses a "gunblade" in combat).
Neither of them truly cares about saving the world and are cold to their friends and allies as the game begins. They continue to be this way until they are given a reason to think otherwise.
Squall nor Cloud knew their fathers as children and could be described as growing up without having much of a real family.
It is after their first mission that they meet the two girls from the introduction, in the least likely of places and which will become a very memorable scene.
You (as the player) are able to interact with the girls for that brief meeting, but little, if anything about themselves or their purpose is revealed.
But before then, there is the inclusion of another woman and the second love interest for the hero, Tifa and Quistis. Both are portrayed early on as having secret amorous feelings for the hero which both have difficulty expressing. Also, both girls are physically stronger than the heroine, and are better equipped for battle.
The first time they meet the heroine, both girls are apprehensive around them, and at times curt. However, during the course of events, they put aside their differences and become good friends instead. Also, before being placed alongside the hero, both girls had their own careers to attend to. Tifa was a bartender and Quistis was a SeeD instructor.
Most people have noted a physical resemblance between Tifa and Rinoa. Both have dark hair in almost the same style and dark eyes. Aeris and Quistis are also compared for being the more fair-haired female with bangs, a pony-tail, colored eyes, and dressed in shades of pink. Thus, since Rinoa is Squall's love interest, Tifa must therefore be Cloud's. However, it's the personality and the character's role that is of the most importance here. Remember it's "more than the dress and the voice" that counts.
Tifa is presented as Cloud's childhood friend in the beginning, and Quistis, as the story progresses, is also discovered to be a friend from Squall's childhood.
However, it's proven, that both men have had no real close bond with either of the girls as presumed and were instead both loners without any real friends.
Both girls also share that "special" late night chat that could easily be interpreted as romantic. Yet, both of their advances are ultimately rejected during that event.
Coincidently, after another mission, both heroes are reunited once again with that unnamed, mystery girl they met a while back. This time the player is finally introduced, and are immediately "hired" by both as a guardian figure.
Upon meeting, both girls are openly and overly "friendly" to the men, a trait that is common to both, as neither conceals their obvious adoration for the hero.
Astrologically speaking, Cloud's zodiac sign is a Leo and Aeris?sign is an Aquarius, the direct opposite. By the same token, Squall is a Virgo, while, Rinoa is a Pisces. Again, opposites attract.
Both are cheerful, talkative, vibrant individuals who are the only ones able to change the hero's perception. They will be the ones to make the hero begin to care about protecting the planet and appreciate his fellow comrades.
Strangely enough, both Aeris and Rinoa have surnames that are not their own. Aeris Gainsborough should be Gast, and Rinoa Heartilly, should be Caraway. Their fathers were/are both men with government posts and their mothers were both uniquely talented women who passed away while the girls were at a young age.
Concerning their abilities in battle, both are more magically-inclined and each has their own special skills that they have inherited from a non-human source. In actuality, both are the successors of a special and ancient race. Aeris is the last remaining Cetra, and Rinoa is a witch. It's their strength in magic that makes up for their physical weakness and incidentally, makes them susceptible to precarious situations in which they then need the occasional rescue.
As the plot thickens and the hero and heroine become better acquainted, their relationship begin to deepen as well. Although the choice in the date sequence in FFVII is optional, it's the Aeris date that is the default and the one that makes the most sense in the storyline, since the deal for Cloud's services was one date.
Cloud's height, in the customary units of measurement, is 5' 7", while Aeris is 5' 3". A difference of 4 inches. Squall is 1 inch taller than Cloud, and Rinoa, at 5' 3.5" (5' 4" if rounded), could also be regarded as being 1 inch taller than Aeris. A difference of about 4 inches.
Both heroes are in their sleeping quarters when they are approached and propositioned, and both seem to be coerced into playing along. In FFVIII, it's referred to as a "walk" rather than a date, however, the intention is still there, especially after Squall is asked if Rinoa is his girlfriend.
Cloud's mother suggested that he should have an older girlfriend to take care of him. Aeris is older than Cloud by one year. Although Quistis is one year older than Squall, Rinoa is also older than him by a couple of months.
At one point even, both heroines take it upon their own accord to hinder their foe's plans through their own courageous actions. They are the only ones, it seems, that are capable of doing so.
Yet for all their efforts, it's not quite enough to defeat the enemy completely. Their noble acts fall short for the time being, but they will be an integral part in the villain�s downfall.
Halfway through the game, Rinoa, like Aeris, becomes unable to continue assisting the group. Yet unlike Aeris, she only becomes unconscious and does not suffer the same tragic fate. She will eventually regain consciousness.
In their absence, it can be said that both men become more aware of their feelings for the girls and vow to reunite with them again.
However it can not be forgotten that included in all of this, are two other very important characters. Not only do the men have secondary love interests, but so do the women. They are Zack and Seifer, both of whom were the past loves of the girls and bear a striking resemblance to the hero. Both girls still have lingering feelings for these two at first, but it's clear they now have their attention focused in on the hero.
The difference between both these characters, however, is their relationship to the hero. Zack was a loyal and good friend to Cloud and died protecting him. While Seifer is Squall's main rival and seeks to destroy him rather than help. And this time around, it's Squall who made it into a higher rank, unlike Cloud who failed, while Zack prospered and Seifer didn't.
It's said that originally Cloud was meant to fall in love with Aeris making FFVII a romance, but because of certain circumstances, that idea was scraped and FFVIII became the love story of the series. This is probably the reason for so many of the similarities mentioned above and why FFVII became the "story of a love that could never be".