School of Architecture. McGill University

(301-304B) Design and Construction II

Section II. Winter 2001

Prof. Ricardo L. Castro;

Guest instructor: Ms. Rhona Richman Kenneally, Departmental Lecturer;

T.A. for all the D&C 2 Studios: Ms. Aliki Economides

Project One

Framing:

Observing the City and Building a Framing Device for the Observer

Monday, 8 January to Tuesday, 13 February 2001

5 weeks

Calendar of activities:

Date issued: Monday 08 January 2001

Due date: Tuesday 13 February 1999, at 9:00 a.m., Room TBA

Intermediate reviews: Tuesday 16 ,23, and 30 January.

Every Monday morning, starting at 9:00 a.m., we will be discussing the assigned readings most of which will be from Ignací de Sòla-Morales, Differences (Cambridge: The MIT Press, 1998), and Italo Calvino, Invisible Cities, (New York: Harcourt, 1978) both available at Paragraph Bookstore.

Objectives: The purpose of this project is multifold: first, to allow the participants to involve themselves with concepts of urban mapping in order to develop a sense of urban awareness and urban design strategies; second, to provide the participants with the opportunity of exploring the fascinating relationship of art, cinematography, literature and design and place-making activities, developing parallel related design strategies; finally, to provide participants with the opportunity and challenge to design and construct a project on a one-to-one scale that will allow a thorough exploration of construction and tectonic aspects.

Design Brief

On Calvino

Italo Calvino (1923-1985) was one of Italy's most respected writers. An author who started writing in a neo-realist strain soon after the Second World War, he developed an individualistic style, part scientific observance, part flight of fancy which places him on the literary map somewhere near Jorge Luis Borges, but still in his own, unique, place. His works include Marcovaldo, Cosmicomics and If on a Winter's Night a Traveller.

In a lecture delivered in Turin in November 1967 (Cybernetics and Ghosts 1) he comments on the nature of storytelling, and its ongoing relationship to myth which seems particularly pertinent in relation to Alan Garner's work.

Myth is the hidden part of every story, the buried part, the region that is still unexplored because there are as yet no words to enable us to get there. The narrator's voice in the daily tribal assemblies is not enough to relate the myth. One needs special times and places, exclusive meetings; the words alone are not enough, and we need a whole series of signs with many meanings, which is to say a rite. Myth is nourished by silence as well as by words. A silent myth makes its presence felt in secular narrative and everyday words; it is a language vacuum that draws words up into its vortex and bestows a form on fable[...]

To return to the storyteller of the tribe, he continues imperturbably to make his permutations of jaguars and toucans until the moment comes when one of his innocent little tales explodes into a terrible revelation: a myth, which must be recited in secret, and in a secret place[...].

Myth tends to crystallize instantly, to fall into set patterns, to pass from the phase of myth-making into ritual, and hence out of the hands of the narrator into those of the tribal institutions responsible for the preservation and celebration of myths. The tribal system of signs is arranged in relation to myth; a certain number of signs become taboo, and the 'secular' storyteller can make no direct use of them. He goes on circling around them, inventing new developments in composition, until in the course of this methodical and objective labour he suddenly gets another flash of enlightenment from the unconscious and the forbidden. And this forces the tribe to change its set of signs once more.2

Notes

1: Included in Italo Calvino (translated by Patrick Creagh): The Literature Machine (Picador, 1989)

2: ibid pp 18-23

Frame from Peter Greenaway’s The Belly of an Architect

Concepts:

Frame

Encuadramiento and encadrement respectively in Spanish and French.

The idea of frame refers to things and activities both in the real world as well in the conceptual realm. Concepts such as that of framing a buildings, or using a window to frame the landscape are familiar to any architect as well as the way in which the ideas appear in other contexts. Examples include the various ways in which frames may appear physically or conceptually in the art world and the virtual context of the internet. Framework is a concept used in many disciplines particularly in philosophy. ( Cf. Framing the Questions, a very interesting site on the web exploring some of these aspects:

(http://ls.berkeley.edu/divisions/art-hum/framing/index.html)

Etymologically the ideas of frame and framing are related to concepts in which the body, architecture, and ideas are present. See appendix 1.

We shall be using the work of the British artist and film director Peter Greenaway as a frame of reference in our inquiry. Greenaway is one of the contemporary artists who has deliberately used the notion of frame and framing as a design strategy. It is important to remember that the idea of framing and the objet itself, the frame, are tightly related to the act of visualization, and by extension, to the sensory stimuli of the body. In this context it is possible to describe acoustic, olfative, haptic, and taste frames of reference.

At another level the concept of frame and framing are the basis of many film, painting and design strategies such as collage and montage. In this context the work of a writer such as Italo Calvino or an artist as Greenaway become precious sources of inspiration.

The theoretical framework that we will attempt to address throughout this term will be informed by the explorations carried out by the Spanish architectural theoretician and critic Ignací de Sòla-Morales.

FRAMING THE ORDINARY…DESIGNING FOR THE DISCOVERY OF THE ORDINARY

Roam through known and/or unknown parts of the city’s downtown, during the day or/and night. Seek to discover its mysteries by drifting in its midst. Touch, hear, look, smell, taste and… Record. Record... and identify 3 sites that epitomize your journey.These sites should be located within a five-block radius in any direction, from the corner of Sherbrooke and St. Lawrence Streets One of them will become the site for your eventual intervention.

Bring the recordings of the three sites to class on Tuesday, 16 January. These recordings will become the first entry of your Sketchbook. It is a very important part of the design studio activities.

Concentrate on the discovery of the ordinary and its possible marvelous qualities.

This is the moment in which you will start generating idea sketches for your framing device in your sketchbook.

Websites: each member of this studio will be responsible for designing, posting, and maintaining his/her own website where pertinent parts (drawings, photographs, thoughts) from the sketchbook will be included. The website will be thus a Virtual Sketchbook

References:

BENJAMIN, Walter, Unpacking my Library: a Talk about Book Collecting, in Illuminations, 1931.

CALVINO, Italo, Invisible Cities, (Harcourt, 1978)

DE SÒLA-MORALES, Ignací, Differences. (Cambridge: The MIT press, 1997)

On Peter Greenaway:

And his relationship with OULIPO: http://www.zen.co.uk/home/page/paul.m/oulipo.html

And his stairs project in Geneva:

http://www.filmfestivalen.se/1994/Stairsone.html

And his body of work:

http://www.petergreenaway.org/artworks/

On Italo Calvino:

There is an extraordinary number of sites which each member of the studio should explore throughout the term. Calvino was a member of OULIPO.

APPENDIX (from the Perseus Digital Library: http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/)

Frame in Greek has many variations. For instance:

ka^non-is, idos, hê, acc. to Suid., = ergaleion kalligraphikon, ruler, dub. in AP6.62 (Phil.), dub. in IG22.1678.4.

II. frame with parallel cross-ledges, Aristot. Ath. Pol. 64.2; door-frame, IG22.1672.155 (pl.).

2. in pl., cross bars for strengthening an engine, Ph.Bel. 57.11.

II. pl., profile-stones running along the top of a wall, IG22.1666A16: sg., row of such stones, IBID=au=IG 1672.186. [i_ APl.c., s. v. l.] ka^non-isma, atos, to, ruler, AP6.295(Phan.).

II. grammatical rule, Eust.439.26.

harmonia, hê, (harmozô) means of joining, fastening, gomphois min . . kai harmoniêisin arêren Hom. Od. 5.248; of a ship, ophr' an . . en harmoniêisin arêrêi IBID=au=Hom. Od. 5.361=lr.

2. joint, as between a ship's planks, tas ha. en ôn epaktôsan têi bublôi caulked the joints with papyrus, Hdt. 2.96; tôn harmoniôn diachaskousôn Aristoph. Kn. 533; also in masonry, hai tôn lithôn ha. D.S.2.8, cf. Paus. 8.8.8,au=Paus. 9.33.7.

3. in Anatomy, suture, Hp. Off.25, ti=Hp. Oss.12; union of two bones by mere apposition, Gal.2.737; also in pl., adjustments, porôn Epicur.Fr.250.

4. framework, rhêgnus harmonian . . luras S.Fr.244; boos Philostr.Im.1.16; esp. of the human frame, harmoniên analuemen anthrôpoio Ps.-Phoc.102; neurôn kai kôlôn eklutos ha. AP7.383 (Phil.); tas ha. diachalai tou sômatos Epicr.2.19.

b. of the mind, dustropos gunaikôn ha. women's perverse temperament, Eur. Hipp. 162 (lyr.).

c. framework of the universe, Corp.Herm. 1.14.

II. covenant, agreement, in pl., marturoi . . kai episkopoi harmoniaôn Hom. Il. 22.255.

III. settled government, order, tan Dios ha. Aesch. PB 551 (lyr.).

IV. in Music, stringing, ha. toxou kai luras Heraclit.51, cf. Plat. Sym. 187a: hence, method of stringing, musical scale, Philol.6, etc., Nicom.Harm.9; esp. octave, ek pasôn oktô ousôn [phônôn] mian ha. sumphônein Plat. Rep. 617b; hepta chordai hê ha. Aristot. Met. 1093a14, cf. ti=Arist. Pr.919b21; of the planetary spheres, in Pythag. theory, Cael.290b13, ti=Pythag. Mu.399a12, etc.

2. generally, music, autôi de tôi rhuthmôi mimountai chôris ha. IDEM=Pythag.Po.1447a26.

3. special type of scale, mode, ha. Ludia Pind. N. 4.46; Aiolis or -êïs Pratin.Lyr.au=Pind. N. 4.5=lr, Lasus I, cf. Plat. Rep. 398e, al., Aristot. Pol. 1276b8, au=Aristot. Pol. 1341b35, etc.

b. esp. the enharmonic scale, Aristox.Harm.p.I M., Plu.2.1135a, al.

4. harmonian logôn labôn a due arrangement of words, fit to be set to music, Plat. Theaet. 175e.

5. intonation or pitch of the voice, Aristot. Rh. 1403b31.

6. metaph. of persons and things, harmony, concord, Plat. Rep. 431e, etc.

V. personified, as a mythical figure, HH 3.195, Hes. Th. 937, etc.; Philos., like philotês, principle of Union, opp. Neikos, Emp.122.2, cf. au=Emp. 27.3.

VI. Pythag. name for three, Theol. Ar.au=Pythag. 27.16=lr.

VII. name of a remedy, Gal.13.61; of a plaster, Paul. Aeg.au=Gal. 3.62.

In Latin the concept is very rich as well:

corpus, oris, n. [cf. Sanscr. kar-, to make; Lat. creo], any object composed of materials perceptible by the senses, body, substance (opp. anima and animus; cf. the definition in Dig. 41, 3, 30 pr.).

I. Lit. (very frequent in every period and species of composition).

A. In gen., a body, whether living or lifeless: tangere aut tangi nisi corpus nulla potest res, Lucr. 1, 305: animi voluptates et dolores nasci fatemur e corporis voluptatibus et doloribus, etc., Cic. Fin. 1, 17, 55; cf. id. Tusc. 4, 10, 23: vita, quae corpore et spiritu continetur, id. Marcell. 9.28: parvissima quaeque Corpora constabunt ex partibus infinitis, Lucr. 1, 617: ignea rerum, id. 1, 680: terraï, id. 5, 236: acerbum Neptuni, id. 2, 472: aquae, id. 2, 232 et saep.--Poet., plur. for sing.: nudabant corpora (nymphae) venti, Ov. M. 1.527; Tib. 1, 8, 52 (cf. sômata, Soph. Elec. 1232).--

B. In partic.

1. The flesh of animal bodies: ossa subjecta corpori, Cic. N. D. 2, 55, 139; cf. Quint. 1, prooem. § 24; 12, 10, 5: amittere, to become poor, lean, Lucr. 1, 1038; Cic. Fam. 7, 26, 2 fin.; cf.: abiit corpusque colorque, Ov. H. 3, 141; and the opp. facere, to become fat, to thrive, Cels. 7, 3 fin.; cf.: quo cibo fecisti tantum corporis, Phaedr. 3, 7, 5.--In a play upon words: inque omni nusquam corpore corpus erat, Mart. Spect. 7, 6.--

b. Transf., the wood under the bark of a tree, Plin. 17, 24, 37, § 234.--Of discourse: nervis illis, quibus causa continetur, adiciunt superinducti corporis speciem, the covering, integument, Quint. 5, 8, 2; 2, 10, 5: corpus eloquentiae facere, the substance, the most essential part, id. 10, 1, 87; cf.: corpus orationis enervatur, Petr. 2.--

2. A lifeless body, a corpse, Caes. B. G. 2.10; 2.27; Liv. 32, 13, 8 et saep.; Ov. M. 7.548; id. F. 2, 835 al.--In a double sense, Cic. Sull. 31.89 Halm.--Poet., the souls of the dead, the shades or departed spirits, Verg. A. 6.303; 6.306.--

3. As opposed to the head, the trunk, Ov. M. 11.794.--

4. In mal. part., the body, person: usuram ejus corporis cepit sibi, Plaut. Am. prol. 108: illa quae corpus puplicat volgo suum, id. Bacch. 4.8.22; id. Cist. 2.3.21; cf.: corpore quaestum facere, id. Poen. 5.3.21 al.; v. quaestus.-- Hence also, the testicles, Phaedr. 3, 11, 3; Hor. S. 1, 2, 43.--

5. Periphrastically for the individual, the person (esp. poet., to suggest that which is physically admirable or excellent; also freq. in the histt.): delecta virum corpora, Verg. A. 2.18; cf.: lectissima matrum, id. ib. 9.272: quo pulchrior alter non fuit, excepto corpore Turni, id. ib. 7.650; 11, 690: septena quot annis Corpora natorum, id. ib. 6.22: ultor vestrae, fidissima corpora, mortis, Ov. M. 3.58; 7.655: sororum, Sil. 14, 105; Val. Fl. 2, 653: conjugum vestraque ac liberorum vestrorum, Liv. 21, 13, 7; Tac. A. 4, 72 et saep.: uti corpora nostra ab injuriâ tuta forent, Sall. C. 33, 2; Liv. 9.8.5; 31.46.16: qui liberum corpus (sc. Virginiam) in servitutem addixissent, id. 3.56.8; so, liberum, Sall. C. 33, 2; Liv. 5.22.1; 29.21.6; Plin. Pan. 33, 1.--Of animals: corpora magna boum, heads, Verg. G. 3.369: seu quis Pascit equos ... Corpora praecipue matrum legat, id. ib. 3.51; id. A. 1.193: pro tribus corporibus triginta milia talentum auri precatur accipias, Curt. 4, 11, 6.--

II. Meton., a whole composed of parts united, a body, frame, system, structure, community, corporation, etc.; of ships, the framework, Caes. B. C. 1, 54.--Of fortifications: totum corpus coronâ militum cingere, Caes. B. G. 7.72.--Of a land: Sicilia dirempta velut a corpore majore, Just. 4, 1, 1.--Of the state: alterum (praeceptum Platonis), ut totum corpus rei publicae curent, nec dum partem aliquam tuentur, reliquas deserant, Cic. Off. 1, 25, 85: quae (multitudo) coalescere in populi unius corpus poterat, Liv. 1.8.1; cf. id. 34, 9, 3; and: nullum civitatis, a political body, id. 26, 16, 9; 38, 9, 12; Tac. G. 39; Just. 3, 2, 2: totum corpus Macedoniae, id. 7, 1, 12; Liv. 26, 16, 9: sui corporis regem creari, id. 1.17.2: corpus mercatorum, guild, Ambros. Ep. 20, 6: corpori valido caput deerat (sc. exercitui dux), Liv. 5.46.5: oriundi ab Sabinis sui corporis creari regem volebant, id. 1.17.2; cf. id. 4.9.4; 6.34.5 al.: fabrorum et naviculariorum, Dig. 50, 6, 5: utros ejus habueris libros ... duo enim sunt corpora ... an utrosque, nescio, Cic. Q. Fr. 2, 11 (13), 4; so of a book, id. Fam. 5, 12, 4; Sen. Tranq. 9, 6; Suet. Gram. 6; Dig. 32, 50 al.; cf.: corpus omnis Romani juris, Liv. 3.34.7; hence, Corpus Juris, title of a Roman collection of laws, Cod. Just. 5, 13: rationum, Dig. 40, 5, 37: patrimonii, ib. 4, 2, 20: omnia maternae hereditatis, ib. 4, 31, 79.a

 

RLC/D&C2.01