This year was important not only for visionary recordings by Wynton
Marsalis and Dave Holland but also for breakthroughs by several
Chicagoans, including singer-pianist Patricia Barber, tenor saxophonist
Von Freeman and trumpeter Orbert Davis. What follows is one listener's
choices for the best jazz CDs of 2002, though the list easily
could have been twice as long.
1. Wynton Marsalis, "All Rise"
(Sony): During the past decade and
a half, Marsalis has blossomed as a composer, the great promise
of "The Majesty of the Blues" (1988) fulfilled by such
glorious works as "In This House, On This Morning" (1993)
and the Pulitzer Prize-winning "Blood on the Fields"
(1997). With his newest piece, "All Rise," Marsalis
took a considerable risk, creating a quasi-religious work that
was more ambitious and more stylistically free-ranging than anything
he yet had attempted. For by conceiving "All Rise" for
jazz band, large chorus and symphony orchestra, Marsalis clearly
was working on an enormous canvas. Remarkably, he sustained interest
throughout this two-hour, two-CD opus, which opens with a tour
de force orchestral-choral movement and continues with explorations
of everything from American hoe-down rhythms to Argentine tango
music before closing with an upbeat, life-affirming chorale rooted
in New Orleans parade music. The combined forces of the Lincoln
Center Jazz Orchestra, the Los Angeles Philharmonic and a small
army of choristers brings Marsalis' vision vividly to life. After
this achievement, there's little doubt as to what Marsalis ought
to write next -- a jazz opera.
2. Patricia Barber: "Verse" (Blue Note/Premonition):
A risk-taker from Day One, singer-pianist Barber goesway out on
a limb with "Verse," a groundbreaking CD built not on
standard jazz tunes but entirely on her own, self-styled melodies
and lyrics. Though listeners had encountered Barber's songwriting
on earlier recordings, such as "Modern Cool" (1998),
never before had she staked an entire album on her fearlessly
idiosyncratic songwriting. But original tunes such as the slyly
erotic "I Could Eat Your Words," the hyper-literate
"Dansons La Gigue" and the wickedly comic "You
Gotta Go Home" establish Barber as a first-rate singer-songwriter
who richly deserves the large and growing public she is attracting.
Add to that the remarkably liquidity of Barber's vocals, the atmospheric
quality of her pianism and the sublimely understated accompaniment
of her band, and you have the rare jazz artist capable of intriguing
the congescenti while reaching out to everyone else.
3. Von Freeman: "The Improviser" (Premonition):
In a long and noble career, Chicago tenor saxophonist Freeman
has been tragically under-recorded, but "The Improviser"
goes a long way toward making up for lost time. Brilliantly conceived
by the Chicago-based Premonition label, "The Improviser"
capturesthe great "Vonski" at or near the height of
his powers, an impressive feat considering that Freeman turned
80 this year. Yet the high romanticism he brings to "If I
Should Lose You," the ferocious bebop playing he unspools
on "What Is This thing Called Love?" and the seemingly
telepathic communication he achieves with pianist Jason Moran
on "I Like the Sunrise" attests to the stylistic versatility,
technical mastery and competitive drive the man sustains at an
age when many musicians have hung up their horns for good.
4. Dave Holland Big Band: "What Goes Around" (ECM):
The best big band recording of the year was also one of the most
innovative. Though jazz listeners around the world had applauded
the new quintet that Holland formed in the late 1990s, one wondered
whether this group could achieve the same ethereal beauty and
seamless ensemble playing as the core of a larger ensemble. "What
Goes Around" lays to rest any doubts about the artistic viability
of Holland's big-band concept. To behold the utter transparency
of texture that Holland and friends attain on the opening cut,
"Triple Dance," and the virtuosity of Holland's writing
on "Razor's Edge" is to savor a fresh approach to the
big band repertory. Granted, Holland owes an artistic debt to
large ensembles of the past, not least to the Thad Jones-Mel Lewis
organization. But the delicate colors, elastic rhythms and original
instrumental combinations that define "What Goes Around"
affirms the value of Holland's' big-band experiment.
5. Matthew Shipp: "Nu Bop" (Thirsty Ear): Many
young jazz musicians have dabbled with "scratching,"
computer-generated sound, contemporary dance beats and the like,
but few have done so as organically or as persuasively as pianist-bandleader
Shipp. In a bold statement about the importance of bringing new
ideas into the jazz vernacular, Shipp uses acoustic and electronic
instrumentation to produce some of the most coherent sonic experimentation
of the year. Assisted by bassist William Parker, a longtime partner,
Shipp revels in dance-club rhythms on "Space Shipp,"
out-of-this-world sound effects on "Nu Bop" and lushly
exotic scales on "D's Choice." Every track, in fact,
opens up a new world of sound, and Shipp's listeners have come
to expect nothing less from him.
6. Bob Brookmeyer: "Waltzing With Zoe" (Challenge):
His recordings may not benefit from the publicity blitz that accompanies
the work of younger, less accomplished artists, but Brookmeyer
continues to expand the meaning and vocabulary of the big band
repertory. "Waltzing With Zoe" proves the point, with
Brookmeyer leading the New Art Orchestra in original compositions
that are at once intellectually provocative and instantly alluring.
Who could resist the tremendous rhythmic drive that Brookmeyer
and the band produce on the finale of "Seesaw" or the
playful dissonance and puckish spirit the musicians articulate
on "Child at Play." It may take a generation or more
before Brookmeyer's orchestral writing wins the recognition it
deserves, but it's consoling to note that his ideas have been
so beautifully documented on CD.
7. The Dutch Jazz Orchestra: "Strayhorn and Standards:
You Go to My Head" (Challenge): Slowly but inexorably,
the world is beginning to realize that Billy Strayhorn was more
than Duke Ellington's musical alter ego, and recordings such as
this one have helped to make the case. The Dutch Jazz Orchestra
sheds welcome light on Strayhorn's achievements as arranger by
featuring standard tunes that were transformed via Strayhorn's
pen. Listen to the translucent orchestral shadings Strayhorn penned
for his version of "The Man I Love" or the remarkably
sensual voicings he produced on "You Go to My Head"
or the plush instrumental choirs he arranged in "Where or
When," and it's clear that Strayhorn ranks among the great
orchestrators of the 20th Century. Both the composer and his fans
are fortunate that the Dutch Jazz Orchestra took up Strayhorn's
cause, for few ensembles could dispatch this repertoire with half
as much finesse and grace.
8. Orbert Davis: "Priority" (3Sixteen Records):
Anyone who regularly attends jazz performances in Chicago sooner
or later encounters trumpeter Davis, who has reached a new artistic
high point with this release. Liberated from both the early-jazz
genres in which he is expert and the commercial demands that face
any jazz musician trying to make a living, Davis lets his own
voice permeate every track of "Priority." The result
is one of the most eloquently composed, brilliantly executed small-ensemble
recordings of the year. For starters, one has to marvel at the
expressive power of Davis' compositions, from the hard-bop energy
of the title track to the exquisite melodic arc of "Block
Party." To their credit, Davis' sidemen match the fire and
fury of the trumpeter's playing, with particularly scorching playing
from tenor saxophonist Ari Brown. If they were smart, the executives
at one of the major labels would waste no time picking up this
sterling CD.
9. Mayra Caridad Valdes: "La Diosa del Mar" (Jazzheads):
Great jazz voices do not come along very often, despite the heavy
promotional push that has catapulted the likes of Diana Krall
and Jane Monheit. Yet this release affirmed that a major talent
has arrived, Valdes claiming a place among the masters of Afro-Caribbean
improvisation. Though Valdes' art has many attractive facets,
the most immediately recognizable is the quality and size of her
instrument, a thrilling voice that produces plush, throaty notes
toward the bottom of her range and equally appealing, technically
unerring pitches up on top. As jazz improviser, Valdes can hold
her own against the most accomplished sidemen, as she demonstrates
by trading rapid-fire phrases with the horns on tunes such as
"Mambo Influenciado" and "Billie's Bounce."
10. Jean-Michel Pilc: "Welcome Home" (Dreyfus
Jazz): He may not be widely known to American listeners, but Pilc
-- who's French -- ranks among the mighttier pianists in jazz today,
and not only because of his Herculean technique. For all the heaven-storming
virtuosity he has brought to bear on a variety of American jazz
standards, Pilc has achieved his greatest distinction through
brains, not brawn. By sabotaging rhythmic expectations on Miles
Davis' "So What" and exploring rarefied chord changes
barely implied by Duke Ellington's "Solitude," Pilc
established himself as a master of the musical materials at hand.
It is the overwhelming presence of Pilc's sound and the intellectual
depth of his improvisations that distinguish this disc and make
one long for the day when Pilc swings through Chicago.