What Is Stride Piano?
by Irwin Schwartz
The
term stride comes from the action of the left hand, which
supplies a constant beat against a melodious right hand.
The left hand jumps from strong upbeats (either single-note,
octaves or tenths) to chord and downbeats (usually triads
or tetrads, but sometimes single notes). Variety is given
to the left-hand accompaniment through a walking-bass pattern,
melodic episodes, arpeggiation and other techniques).
Although people associate stride music with tour-de-force presentation,
stride can also be played slowly and introspectively (listen
to "Blueberry Rhyme," for example). However, the music is,
in fact, generally played at a fast pace.
Like
ragtime, there are three giants of stride piano: James P.
Johnson, Thomas Wright "Fats" Waller and Willie "The Lion"
Smith. Of this trio, Johnson (1891 - 1955) is recognized
as the seminal influence; some students of the subject credit
him with creating stride piano (originally called "shout"
piano). He was Fats Waller's mentor. Fats (1904 - 1943),
of course, went on to compose dozens of tunes, many of which
have become standards. However, he never lost his enthusiasm
for stride. He was also the most "commercial" of the Big
Three. William Henry Joseph Bonaparte Berthloff (Willie
"The Lion") Smith (1897 - 1973) was a classically-trained
musician who claimed to have developed his left hand by
playing Bach.
All three pianists (as well
as many other stride artists) would play at "rent parties,"
that is, parties given for the sake of raising money to
pay the monthly due to the landlord. Very often, contests
were held among the pianists to see which of them could
"cut" the others by playing the most difficult passages
or by playing the most involved "tricks." I am not aware
of any recordings of such cutting contests, but they must
have been something to hear.
A
note from Dick Hyman in Riccardo Scivales' folio of Dick
Wellstood transcriptions, Hyman quotes from Wellstood's
liner notes for an LP collection of Donald Lambert performances.
It is the best and most succinct description of stride piano
that I have yet found.
"I
would say, first, that I don't like the term 'Stride' any
more than I like the term 'Jazz.' When I was a kid, the
old-timers used to call stride piano 'shout piano,' an agreeably
expressive description, and when once I mentioned stride
to Eubie Blake, he replied, 'My God, what won't they call
ragtime next?'
May
I say that stride is indeed a sort of ragtime, looser than
Joplin's 'classic rag,' but sharing with it the march-like
structures and oom-pah bass. Conventional wisdom has it
that striding is largely a matter of playing a heavy oom-pah
in the left hand, but conventional wisdom is mistaken, as
usual. Franz Liszt, Scott Joplin, Jelly Roll Morton, Earl
'Fatha' Hines, Teddy Wilson, Erroll Garner, and Pauline
Alpert all monger a good many oom-pahs, and whatever their
other many virtues, none of them play[s] stride.
To
begin with, stride playing requires a certain characteristic
rhythmic articulation, for the nature of which I can only
refer you to recordings by such as Eubie Blake, Luckey Roberts,
James P. Johnson, Fats Waller, Willie 'The Lion' Smith and
Donald Lambert. The feel of stride is a kind of soft-shoe
12/8 rather than the 8/8 of ragtime, and, although the left
hand often plays oom-pahs, the total feeling is frequently
an accented four-beat rather than the two-beat you might
expect. . . . By pulling and tugging at the (steady) rhythms
of the left hand, the right hand provides the swing.
Today,
stride piano is in the capable hands of such people as Dick
Hyman, Judy Carmichael, Mike Lipskin, Jay McShann, Ralph
Sutton and John Gill. See John Roache's Page for more information
about and some real-time performances by Gill, who is an
Australian pianist often appearing at ragtime festivals
throughout the United States.