Interference with the orders - Supervisory power of the High Court - Court should certainly interfere when the reasoning of the lower authorities is perverse and is not susceptible to ordinary common sense - Economic criterion is not the guiding principle to deny a person the benefit of Scheduled Caste if he actually belongs to that caste. The remedy against the finding of scrutiny committee is a person under Art. 226. [ Haridasan vs State of Kerala. 2000 (2) KLT 913. Dr.AR.Lakshmanan & S.Sankarasubban (J&J)]
Cancellation of wrong SC/ST certificate. The person concerned is entitled to plead for estoppel merely on the ground of having enjoyed the status under such certificate for a long period. Courts have no power to give effect to the notification issued by the President specifying the Scheduled Castes and Tribes. [ Vijayalakshmi vs Tahasildar. 2000 (2) KLT 811. Chief Justice Arijit Pasayat & K.S.Radhakrishnan (J)]
Part - VII - Schedule " Kadar" community in the whole of the State of Kerala belongs to Schedule tribe. [ Kannan vs State of Kerala. 2000 (2) KLT 657. K.A.Abdul Gafoor (J)]
Art.341 - Person born of Christian Parents cannot claim to be member of
Scheduled Caste if his parents converted prior to his birth and ceased to be
members of the Scheduled Caste - His subsequent convention into a Scheduled
Caste Community also will not entitle him to claim the benefits available to
Scheduled Caste. [Ralli Brothers & Coneys v. Ashok Textiles, 2000 (1) KLT
36. M.R. Hariharan Nair (J)]