| Pick | Ovr | Franchise | Selection | Date/Time | Comments |
| 1.01 | 1 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Moreno, Knowshon DEN RB | Fri Aug 21 4:32:56 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.02 | 2 | Slutbags | Brown, Donald IND RB | Sat Aug 22 7:40:04 a.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.03 | 3 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Wells, Chris ARI RB | Sat Aug 22 7:40:04 a.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 1.04 | 4 | The Nihilists | Walter, Kevin HOU WR | Sat Aug 22 11:52:06 a.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.05 | 5 | USA Fast Guys | McCoy, LeSean PHI RB | Sat Aug 22 11:52:06 a.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 1.06 | 6 | BoneCrushers | Greene, Shonn NYJ RB | Sat Aug 22 3:37:47 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.07 | 7 | earthquakephil | Harvin, Percy MIN WR | Sat Aug 22 3:41:34 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.08 | 8 | Seattle Gators | Crabtree, Michael SFO WR | Sat Aug 22 4:24:46 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.09 | 9 | Slutbags | Britt, Kenny TEN WR | Sat Aug 22 4:56:28 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.1 | 10 | Team Spuden | Avery, Donnie STL WR | Sat Aug 22 6:39:56 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.11 | 11 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Moore, Lance NOS WR | Sun Aug 23 9:08:26 a.m. PT 2009 | |
| 1.12 | 12 | J E T S | Nicks, Hakeem NYG WR | Sun Aug 23 9:08:26 a.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 1.13 | 13 | USA Fast Guys | Timmons, Lawrence PIT LB | Sun Aug 23 9:08:26 a.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 1.14 | 14 | Bloodlust | Bradshaw, Ahmad NYG RB | Sun Aug 23 9:08:26 a.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 2.01 | 15 | Bloodlust | Laurinaitis, James STL LB | Sun Aug 23 9:08:26 a.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 2.02 | 16 | USA Fast Guys | Henry, Chris CIN WR | Sun Aug 23 9:08:26 a.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 2.03 | 17 | J E T S | Breaston, Steve ARI WR | Sun Aug 23 9:53:24 a.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.04 | 18 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Peppers, Julius CAR DE | Sun Aug 23 9:55:31 a.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.05 | 19 | The Omnipotence | Shockey, Jeremy NOS TE | Sun Aug 23 11:38:29 a.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.06 | 20 | Bloodlust | Driver, Donald GBP WR | Sun Aug 23 11:51:34 a.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.07 | 21 | Seattle Gators | Maroney, Laurence NEP RB | Sun Aug 23 11:51:34 a.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 2.08 | 22 | earthquakephil | Lofton, Curtis ATL LB | Sun Aug 23 2:51:27 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.09 | 23 | BoneCrushers | Austin, Miles DAL WR | Sun Aug 23 6:00:14 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.1 | 24 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Posluszny, Paul BUF LB | Sun Aug 23 6:02:15 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.11 | 25 | The Nihilists | Washington, Leon NYJ RB | Sun Aug 23 6:02:48 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.12 | 26 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Cooper, Stephen SDC LB | Sun Aug 23 6:03:59 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.13 | 27 | Slutbags | Maclin, Jeremy PHI WR | Sun Aug 23 6:06:11 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 2.14 | 28 | Ike for 3Keeper League | McGahee, Willis BAL RB | Sun Aug 23 6:06:11 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 3.01 | 29 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Smith, Steve NYG WR | Sun Aug 23 6:06:11 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 3.02 | 30 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Garrard, David JAC QB | Sun Aug 23 6:06:42 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.03 | 31 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Coffee, Glen SFO RB | Sun Aug 23 6:07:25 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.04 | 32 | Team Spuden | Taylor, Fred NEP RB | Sun Aug 23 6:08:10 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.05 | 33 | Team Spuden | Davis, James CLE RB | Sun Aug 23 6:08:15 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.06 | 34 | BoneCrushers | Cushing, Brian HOU LB | Sun Aug 23 6:08:35 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.07 | 35 | earthquakephil | Williamson, Troy JAC WR | Sun Aug 23 6:08:48 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.08 | 36 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Weddle, Eric SDC S | Sun Aug 23 6:09:04 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.09 | 37 | Team Spuden | Curry, Aaron SEA LB | Sun Aug 23 6:09:17 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.1 | 38 | The Omnipotence | Curtis, Kevin PHI WR | Sun Aug 23 6:10:51 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.11 | 39 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Graham, Earnest TBB RB | Sun Aug 23 6:11:18 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.12 | 40 | Team Spuden | Atogwe, Oshiomogho STL S | Sun Aug 23 6:12:08 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 3.13 | 41 | USA Fast Guys | Wilson, Adrian ARI S | Sun Aug 23 6:12:08 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 3.14 | 42 | Bloodlust | James, Bradie DAL LB | Sun Aug 23 6:12:08 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 4.01 | 43 | Bloodlust | Scott, Bernard CIN RB | Sun Aug 23 6:12:08 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 4.02 | 44 | USA Fast Guys | Griffin, Michael TEN S | Sun Aug 23 6:13:39 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.03 | 45 | J E T S | Sanchez, Mark NYJ QB | Sun Aug 23 6:13:56 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.04 | 46 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Higgins, Johnnie Lee OAK WR | Sun Aug 23 6:16:14 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.05 | 47 | The Omnipotence | Flacco, Joe BAL QB | Sun Aug 23 6:17:27 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.06 | 48 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Bennett, Earl CHI WR | Sun Aug 23 6:17:52 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.07 | 49 | Seattle Gators | Harrison, Jerome CLE RB | Sun Aug 23 6:18:30 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.08 | 50 | earthquakephil | Pennington, Chad MIA QB | Sun Aug 23 6:25:17 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.09 | 51 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Jennings, Rashad JAC RB | Sun Aug 23 6:25:42 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.1 | 52 | Seattle Gators | Cooley, Chris WAS TE | Sun Aug 23 6:26:17 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.11 | 53 | The Nihilists | Winslow, Kellen TBB TE | Sun Aug 23 6:31:08 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.12 | 54 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Celek, Brent PHI TE | Sun Aug 23 6:31:55 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.13 | 55 | Slutbags | Bell, Yeremiah MIA S | Sun Aug 23 6:35:41 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 4.14 | 56 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Choice, Tashard DAL RB | Sun Aug 23 6:37:45 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.01 | 57 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Chambers, Chris SDC WR | Sun Aug 23 6:37:45 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 5.02 | 58 | Slutbags | Foote, Larry DET LB | Sun Aug 23 6:40:01 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.03 | 59 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Mikell, Quintin PHI S | Sun Aug 23 6:41:04 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.04 | 60 | The Nihilists | Lewis, Ray BAL LB | Sun Aug 23 6:41:45 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.05 | 61 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Greenway, Chad MIN LB | Sun Aug 23 6:42:27 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.06 | 62 | BoneCrushers | Gamble, Chris CAR CB | Sun Aug 23 6:43:03 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.07 | 63 | Bloodlust | Gage, Justin TEN WR | Sun Aug 23 6:43:03 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 5.08 | 64 | Seattle Gators | Hawk, A.J. GBP LB | Sun Aug 23 6:46:17 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.09 | 65 | The Nihilists | Wilson, Gibril MIA S | Sun Aug 23 6:47:25 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.1 | 66 | The Omnipotence | Meriweather, Brandon NEP S | Sun Aug 23 6:47:54 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.11 | 67 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Polamalu, Troy PIT S | Sun Aug 23 6:48:02 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.12 | 68 | J E T S | Collins, Nick GBP S | Sun Aug 23 6:49:26 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.13 | 69 | USA Fast Guys | Urlacher, Brian CHI LB | Sun Aug 23 6:49:37 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 5.14 | 70 | Team Spuden | Boss, Kevin NYG TE | Sun Aug 23 6:50:12 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.01 | 71 | Bloodlust | Tatupu, Lofa SEA LB | Sun Aug 23 6:50:12 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 6.02 | 72 | USA Fast Guys | Stafford, Matthew DET QB | Sun Aug 23 6:50:35 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.03 | 73 | J E T S | Bulger, Marc STL QB | Sun Aug 23 6:52:30 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.04 | 74 | The Omnipotence | Fargas, Justin OAK RB | Sun Aug 23 6:52:41 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.05 | 75 | The Omnipotence | Meachem, Robert NOS WR | Sun Aug 23 6:52:48 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.06 | 76 | Seattle Gators | Favre, Brett MIN QB | Sun Aug 23 6:53:46 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.07 | 77 | Seattle Gators | Burleson, Nate SEA WR | Sun Aug 23 6:54:21 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.08 | 78 | earthquakephil | Ware, Danny NYG RB | Sun Aug 23 6:54:35 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.09 | 79 | BoneCrushers | Bess, Davone MIA WR | Sun Aug 23 6:54:57 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.1 | 80 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Howard, Thomas OAK LB | Sun Aug 23 6:55:15 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.11 | 81 | The Nihilists | Washington, Nate TEN WR | Sun Aug 23 6:55:51 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.12 | 82 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Heyward-Bey, Darrius OAK WR | Sun Aug 23 6:56:44 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.13 | 83 | Slutbags | Anderson, Derek CLE QB | Sun Aug 23 7:05:09 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 6.14 | 84 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Clayton, Mark BAL WR | Sun Aug 23 7:05:09 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 7.01 | 85 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Crayton, Patrick DAL WR | Sun Aug 23 7:05:09 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 7.02 | 86 | Team Spuden | Barnett, Nick GBP LB | Sun Aug 23 7:05:38 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.03 | 87 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Robiskie, Brian CLE WR | Sun Aug 23 7:07:12 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.04 | 88 | The Nihilists | Woodley, LaMarr PIT LB | Sun Aug 23 7:07:41 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.05 | 89 | Team Spuden | Cole, Trent PHI DE | Sun Aug 23 7:10:18 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.06 | 90 | BoneCrushers | Session, Clint IND LB | Sun Aug 23 7:10:25 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.07 | 91 | Team Spuden | Galloway, Joey NEP WR | Sun Aug 23 7:11:01 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.08 | 92 | Seattle Gators | Garcon, Pierre IND WR | Sun Aug 23 7:11:34 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.09 | 93 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Crowder, Channing MIA LB | Sun Aug 23 7:12:31 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.1 | 94 | The Omnipotence | Collins, Kerry TEN QB | Sun Aug 23 7:13:21 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.11 | 95 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Rice, Sidney MIN WR | Sun Aug 23 7:13:49 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.12 | 96 | J E T S | Jones, Kevin CHI RB | Sun Aug 23 7:13:57 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.13 | 97 | USA Fast Guys | Gostkowski, Stephen NEP PK | Sun Aug 23 7:14:57 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 7.14 | 98 | Bloodlust | Jones, James GBP WR | Sun Aug 23 7:14:57 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 8.01 | 99 | Bloodlust | Vick, Michael PHI QB | Sun Aug 23 7:14:57 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 8.02 | 100 | USA Fast Guys | Schobel, Aaron BUF DE | Sun Aug 23 7:17:42 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.03 | 101 | J E T S | Mathis, Robert IND DE | Sun Aug 23 7:19:00 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.04 | 102 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Sims, Ernie DET LB | Sun Aug 23 7:19:13 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.05 | 103 | The Omnipotence | Kaeding, Nate SDC PK | Sun Aug 23 7:19:23 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.06 | 104 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Smith, Justin SFO DE | Sun Aug 23 7:21:18 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.07 | 105 | Seattle Gators | Vinatieri, Adam IND PK | Sun Aug 23 7:21:43 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.08 | 106 | earthquakephil | Peterson, Julian DET LB | Sun Aug 23 7:23:55 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.09 | 107 | Bloodlust | Robinson, Laurent STL WR | Sun Aug 23 7:23:55 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 8.1 | 108 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Johnson, Derrick KCC LB | Sun Aug 23 7:24:17 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.11 | 109 | The Nihilists | Abraham, John ATL DE | Sun Aug 23 7:24:48 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.12 | 110 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Long, Chris STL DE | Sun Aug 23 7:25:15 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.13 | 111 | Slutbags | Brown, Josh STL PK | Sun Aug 23 7:28:15 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 8.14 | 112 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Reed, Edward BAL S | Sun Aug 23 7:28:15 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 9.01 | 113 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Adams, Gaines TBB DE | Sun Aug 23 7:28:15 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 9.02 | 114 | Slutbags | Vanden Bosch, Kyle TEN DE | Sun Aug 23 7:29:01 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.03 | 115 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Cook, Jared TEN TE | Sun Aug 23 7:29:55 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.04 | 116 | The Nihilists | Porter, Joey MIA LB | Sun Aug 23 7:30:20 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.05 | 117 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Williams, Ricky MIA RB | Sun Aug 23 7:30:51 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.06 | 118 | BoneCrushers | Clowney, David NYJ WR | Sun Aug 23 7:31:18 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.07 | 119 | earthquakephil | Hall, Deangelo WAS CB | Sun Aug 23 7:31:34 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.08 | 120 | Seattle Gators | Bulluck, Keith TEN LB | Sun Aug 23 7:31:47 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.09 | 121 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Duckett, T.J. SEA RB | Sun Aug 23 7:32:32 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.1 | 122 | The Omnipotence | Schilens, Chaz OAK WR | Sun Aug 23 7:32:39 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.11 | 123 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Tillman, Charles CHI CB | Sun Aug 23 7:33:13 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.12 | 124 | J E T S | Scheffler, Tony DEN TE | Sun Aug 23 7:33:48 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.13 | 125 | USA Fast Guys | Leinart, Matt ARI QB | Sun Aug 23 7:34:06 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 9.14 | 126 | Bloodlust | Durant, Justin JAC LB | Sun Aug 23 7:34:06 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 10.01 | 127 | Bloodlust | Harper, Roman NOS S | Sun Aug 23 7:34:06 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on Pre-Draft List |
| 10.02 | 128 | USA Fast Guys | Baker, Chris NEP TE | Sun Aug 23 7:36:56 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.03 | 129 | J E T S | Scott, Bart NYJ LB | Sun Aug 23 7:37:14 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.04 | 130 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Freeney, Dwight IND DE | Sun Aug 23 7:37:25 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.05 | 131 | The Omnipotence | Pierce, Antonio NYG LB | Sun Aug 23 7:37:37 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.06 | 132 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Griffin, Cedric MIN CB | Sun Aug 23 7:37:51 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.07 | 133 | Seattle Gators | Kerney, Patrick SEA DE | Sun Aug 23 7:38:04 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.08 | 134 | earthquakephil | Brown, Kris HOU PK | Sun Aug 23 7:38:11 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.09 | 135 | BoneCrushers | Collie, Austin IND WR | Sun Aug 23 7:38:24 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.1 | 136 | Clovis Skullkrushers | Walker, Mike JAC WR | Sun Aug 23 7:38:36 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.11 | 137 | The Nihilists | Jackson, Brandon GBP RB | Sun Aug 23 7:38:36 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on My Draft List |
| 10.12 | 138 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Crosby, Mason GBP PK | Sun Aug 23 7:38:36 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on My Draft List |
| 10.13 | 139 | Slutbags | Davis, Vernon SFO TE | Sun Aug 23 7:38:56 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 10.14 | 140 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Sanders, Bob IND S | Sun Aug 23 7:38:56 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 11.01 | 141 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Bironas, Rob TEN PK | Sun Aug 23 7:38:56 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 11.02 | 142 | Slutbags | Jenkins, Michael ATL WR | Sun Aug 23 7:40:13 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.03 | 143 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Maualuga, Rey CIN LB | Sun Aug 23 7:40:13 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on My Draft List |
| 11.04 | 144 | The Nihilists | Elam, Jason ATL PK | Sun Aug 23 7:40:13 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on My Draft List |
| 11.05 | 145 | Team Spuden | Forsett, Justin SEA RB | Sun Aug 23 7:41:24 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.06 | 146 | BoneCrushers | Ringer, Javon TEN RB | Sun Aug 23 7:41:36 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.07 | 147 | earthquakephil | Delmas, Louis DET CB | Sun Aug 23 7:42:53 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.08 | 148 | Seattle Gators | Pollard, Bernard KCC S | Sun Aug 23 7:43:50 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.09 | 149 | Clovis Skullkrushers | No Pick Made | Sun Aug 23 7:45:14 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick Skipped By Commissioner |
| 11.1 | 150 | The Omnipotence | Bennett, Martellus DAL TE | Sun Aug 23 7:46:53 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.11 | 151 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Miller, Zach OAK TE | Sun Aug 23 7:49:13 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.12 | 152 | J E T S | Rivers, Keith CIN LB | Sun Aug 23 7:49:18 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.13 | 153 | USA Fast Guys | Rhodes, Kerry NYJ S | Sun Aug 23 7:50:09 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 11.14 | 154 | BoneCrushers | Massaquoi, Mohamed CLE WR | Sun Aug 23 7:50:40 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 12.01 | 155 | Bloodlust | Timer Expired | Sun Aug 23 7:53:41 p.m. PT 2009 | No players available based on current ADP Rank results |
| 12.02 | 156 | Clovis Skullkrushers | No Pick Made | Sun Aug 23 7:53:51 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick Skipped By Commissioner |
| 12.03 | 157 | J E T S | Stuckey, Chansi NYJ WR | Sun Aug 23 7:53:58 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 12.04 | 158 | Teeny Weeny String Bikini | Johnson, Gartrell SDC RB | Sun Aug 23 7:55:55 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 12.05 | 159 | The Omnipotence | Delhomme, Jake CAR QB | Sun Aug 23 7:56:03 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 12.06 | 160 | J E T S | Carney, John NOS PK | Sun Aug 23 7:56:08 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 12.07 | 161 | BoneCrushers | Akers, David PHI PK | Sun Aug 23 7:58:41 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 12.08 | 162 | earthquakephil | Ellis, Shaun NYJ DE | Sun Aug 23 7:58:58 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 12.09 | 163 | BoneCrushers | Muhammad, Muhsin CAR WR | Sun Aug 23 8:01:41 p.m. PT 2009 | |
| 12.1 | 164 | Clovis Skullkrushers | No Pick Made | Sun Aug 23 8:02:51 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick Skipped By Commissioner |
| 12.11 | 165 | The Nihilists | Ogunleye, Adewale CHI DE | Sun Aug 23 8:02:51 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made based on My Draft List |
| 12.12 | 166 | Dumbledores Army PIK | Timer Expired | Sun Aug 23 8:05:53 p.m. PT 2009 | No players available based on current ADP Rank results |
| 12.13 | 167 | Slutbags | Tripplett, Larry FA DT | Sun Aug 23 8:07:24 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |
| 12.14 | 168 | Ike for 3Keeper League | Bradley, Stewart PHI LB | Sun Aug 23 8:07:24 p.m. PT 2009 | Pick made by ADP Rank |