Introduction
In 1832, creatine was discovered by Chevreul, a French scientist. Since
its discovery, creatine has fascinated scientists with its integral role
in skeletal muscle metabolism. A natural substance found in the body
that plays a powerful role in energy production and muscular
contractions. Recently, creatine supplementation exploded onto the
sports scene, showing up in lockers and gym bags in virtually every
major sport and physical activity. Athletes use creatine as a dietary
supplement to enhance athletic performance and training programs on a
daily basis. Just some of the fantastic benefits being reported by
athletes and fitness enthusiasts around the world include: more powerful
muscle contractions, increased explosiveness, faster muscle recovery,
less fatigue, increased weight gain, and increased muscle size.
But as with other substances that enhance performance, along come
concerns and criticisms. Creatine is one of the most extensively
researched nutrients in sports performance. But creatine is also one of
the most misunderstood. Designed to provide an in depth explanation of
creatine monohydrate, this booklet will outline creatine's function,
benefit, and effectiveness as a dietary supplement, as well as the
differences from one product to another.
Creatine Monohydrate-The
Early Years:
After Chevreul's discovery of creatine in 1832, another scientist -
Lieberg - confirmed that creatine was a regular constituent of flesh
extracted from mammals. His extensive research in 1847 with wild foxes
concluded that muscle work involves an accumulation of creatine. Around
this time, Researchers Heintz and Pettenkofer discovered a substance in
urine called "creatinine". It was speculated that creatinine was from
the creatine stored in muscles.
Early in the 20th century scientists were conducting numerous studies
with creatine supplementation. It was observed that not all of the
creatine ingested by both animals and humans could be recovered in the
urine, which suggested that some of the creatine was retained in the
body. Researchers Folin and Denis (1912 and 1914) determined that the
supplemental creatine had increased the creatine content of the muscle
cells. In cats, the increases in muscle tissue was observed to be up to
70% after creatine ingestion. By 1923, Hahn and Meyer had estimated the
total creatine content of a 70 kg (154 lb.) male to be approximately 140
grams.
1n 1927, Researchers Fiske and Subbarow discovered "phosphocreatine"
which was creatine and phosphate molecules chemically bound together and
stored in the muscle tissue. Free form creatine and phosphorylated
phosphocreatine are recognized as key intermediates of skeletal muscle
metabolism.
Modern research on creatine supplementation has examined the role of
creatine in muscle metabolism, the breakdown and resynthesis of
adenosine triphosphate (ATP), and phosphocreatine during exercise in
humans. It has been determined that phosphocreatine stores in muscle
tissue can be increased by more than 20% following a regimen of creatine
supplementation.
What is Creatine?
Creatine is an essential, natural substance required for energy
metabolism, muscular movement and human existence. Creatine is as
essential to life as protein, carbohydrates, fats, vitamins and
minerals. Creatine deficiencies have been associated with certain
physical-muscular disorders that can be fatal in humans and
animals.
The human body synthesizes creatine from 3 amino acids: glycine,
arginine, and methionine. These amino acids are components of protein.
In humans, the enzymes involved in the synthesis of creatine are located
in the liver, pancreas and kidneys. Creatine can be produced in any of
these organs and then transported into the muscle via the bloodstream.
Approximately 95% of the total creatine pool is stored in skeletal
muscle tissue. The remaining 5% can be found in the heart, brain and
testes. As stated earlier, it is estimated that a 70 kg (154 lbs.) male
will have a total creatine pool of approximately 140 grams in his
body.
The total creatine pool in humans refers to the combined amount of
creatine in its free form and phosphocreatine form. In skeletal muscle
tissue, phosphocreatine accounts for two-thirds of the total creatine
pool, with free form creatine making up the balance. In the absence of
exogenous (from the diet) creatine, the rate of creatine excreted in the
form of creatinine has been estimated to be around 1.6% per day in
humans. Thus, with a bodyweight of 70kg (154 lbs.) and a total creatine
pool of 140 grams, a human will lose approximately 2 grams of creatine
per day from normal everyday activity. This turnover of creatine will
increase with greater physical activity and must be replaced by the diet
or the body's own natural production.
Dietary creatine is found mostly in meat, fish and other animal
products. Plants contain only trace amounts. The average daily diet of
meats and vegetables contains an estimated creatine level of 1 gram. As
only some of the daily requirement of creatine can be attained from
diet, the body must synthesize the rest. A vegetarian's daily
requirement for creatine can only be achieved by endogenous (from within
the body) synthesis via the enzyme GAMT.
The effect of aging on the level of free form creatine and
phosphocreatine has been studied by Moller and colleagues at the
Karolinska Institute in Stockholm. Interestingly, there were no
differences in the total creatine levels between a group of elderly
(aged 52 to 79) and young (aged 18 to 36). But the study did reveal that
the younger participants had higher phosphocreatine levels than did the
older group. Such differences can be attributed to the greater level of
activity in the younger group.
Approximate creatine leels in food (grams of creatine per 1000 grams of
food source)
How Does Creatine Work?
Creatine plays a very powerful role in energy metabolism as a muscle
fuel. The immediate energy source for a skeletal muscle contraction is
from a molecule called ATP (adenosine triphosphate). All fuel sources,
carbohydrates, fats and protein are first converted through various
chemical reactions to ATP which is then available as the only molecule
the body uses for energy. Everything must be first converted to ATP
before it can be used as fuel.
ATP is a simple chemical consisting of one molecule of adenosine and
three molecules of phosphate. When ATP releases its energy to fuel
muscle contractions, a phosphate group is split off and a new molecule
is formed called ADP (adenosine diphosphate). This reaction is
reversible by the energy-rich compound phosphocreatine. Phosphocreatine
delivers a phosphate group to ADP resynthesizing it back into an ATP
molecule, thus making it ready again to release energy to fuel continued
muscle contractions. The remaining free form creatine is accumulated in
the active muscles and then rephosphorylated back into
phosphocreatine.
During a brief period of high intensity exercise, the ATP demand in the
working muscles increases significantly to several hundred times higher
versus when at rest. High intensity exercise can totally deplete
phosphocreatine stores within 10 seconds. The depleted stores of ATP and
phosphocreatine must be steadily replenished in order for muscular
contractions to continue at peak levels of frequency and
intensity.
Creatine supplementation:
Oral supplementation of creatine monohydrate has been shown in several
studies to increase the total creatine pool. Optimum daily dosages
varied widely from individual to individual, but not significantly from
trained to untrained subjects. One study using a single dosage of 5
grams showed a rise in plasma creatine levels from 50 to 100
µmol/L to over 500 µmol/L within 1 hour after ingestion. And
recent studies have examined the administration of creatine monohydrate
in varying dosages over different periods of time.
An initial loading phase of 4 to 6 dosages of 5 grams each for 3 days
showed a significant increase in the total creatine pool. But it also
showed that there exists an upper limit of creatine which can be stored
in muscle. For most subjects, this upper limit seems to be around 160
mmol/kg (kg dm). One recent study concluded that after 6 days of
creatine administration of 0.3 grams per day per kilogram of bodyweight
maintained maximum total creatine levels for a subsequent 4-week period,
during which time the dosage was reduced to 0.03 grams per day per
kilogram of bodyweight.
For example, a 70 kg (154lb.) person loading 0.3 grams per day per kg.
(21 grams of creatine monohydrate) for six days, followed by a 4 week
maintenance phase of 0.03 grams per day per kg. (2.1 grams of creatine
monohydrate) per day, may maintain maximum total creatine levels in
muscle tissue.
It is currently unclear the mechanisms influencing creatine uptake by
the cells from the bloodstream but several factors have been noted that
effect creatine uptake. Creatine uptake in exercised muscle has been
found to be higher than in non-exercised muscle. So, it may be concluded
that a trained muscle will have a greater potential for creatine uptake
than a non-trained muscle. Creatine uptake may also be enhanced when
administered with a carbohydrate solution. The rise in blood sugar
levels causes an insulin reaction, which increases the uptake of glucose
into the muscle tissue. The increased release of insulin may also
increase the uptake of creatine into the muscle tissue along with
glucose.
Creatine supplementation
and Athletic Performance
Creatine supplementation has been shown to enhance the ability to
maintain power output during repeated periods of high intensity
exercise. Athletes in virtually every sport have reported improved
athletic performance. For instance, greater home run production by
baseball players, increased strength and power by football players,
faster times by sprinters, and longer lasting energy by basketball
players. When used properly, most athletes will experience a significant
increase in strength and power.
Creatine supplementation in controlled scientific studies in amounts as
high as 20 grams per day have been shown to enhance the body's ability
to maintain power output during frequent and intense exercise. Sports
involving short bursts of energy - like multiple sprint sports - seem to
experience the greatest benefit of improved athletic performance.
Another benefit of creatine supplementation for athletes may be when
high intensity exercise is combined with lower intensity exercise or
rest. Team sports such as baseball, basketball, football, hockey and
individual sports like wrestling, tennis, track and field and sprinting
all consist of short explosive muscle contractions followed by short
periods of rest or recovery periods. ATP stores are depleted and
replenished by the utilization of the phosphocreatine and creatine
stores in the muscle. The greater the total creatine pool, the greater
the efficiency of the ATP/CP energy cycle.
Creatine supplementation
and Muscle Building
Creatine supplementation can help the athlete train harder for a longer
period of time. Therefore, increased intensity of muscle training will
generate faster muscle growth and strength. An example of increased
intensity of muscle training can be found in a study done by Conrad
Earnest and co-workers. The study was conducted on weight trainers at
Texas Southwestern Medical Center and The Cooper Clinic in Dallas,
Texas. Creatine supplementation and maximum strength was measured in
experienced athletes who consumed 20 grams of creatine per day for 28
days. The average increase in bench press strength was 18 lbs. The
average bench press repetitions each athlete could perform at a weight
equaling 70% of their 1-rep. maximum increased from 11 reps to 15 reps.
The subjects in this study also increased lean mass an average of 3.5
lbs over the 28 day period. Increases in lean muscle tissue verses water
retention was observed and attributed to increased muscle overload and
greater muscle tissue growth stimulation.
At what age can a person
start using creatine monohydrate?
Generally, there is no age limitation for safe creatine
supplementation. In fact, there are some children who suffer from an
inborn gene defect called GAMT deficiency. These children are treated
with dietary creatine supplementation. The question of safe creatine
supplementation for children should be answered by the parent
considering creatine. The question of healthy competition and pressure
placed on children to improve their athletic performance needs to remain
in healthy balance with the spirit of sport and the self confidence the
child achieves. The second consideration is in the physical development
of the young individual. It is our recommendation that unless prescribed
by a medical doctor, creatine supplementation should only be used by
adults. Athletes should understand that creatine supplementation is
only a part of a training and diet routine, and not a substitute for
proper training and dietary habits.
Creatine
supplementation-Dosages
While there have been many creatine supplementation studies done with
various dosage amounts, there has not been an exact amount determined to
be optimum. Generally the dosage of creatine monohydrate should be as
high as necessary, but as low as possible to be effective. The
scientific studies with dosages of 5 to 10 grams per day are effective,
but many athletes have taken greater than 10 grams per day with no
adverse side effects. The body has an upper limit as to how much
creatine can be stored in the muscle tissue. Therefore, an initial
loading phase is used to fill the creatine pool, followed by a
maintenance phase to replenish the lost creatine. A period of no
supplementation would allow the body to readjust to synthesizing
creatine again after supplementation.
As for general guidelines we recommend for strength athletes the
following:
- 20 grams per day for 3 days
- 5 grams per day for the next 8 weeks
- followed by 4 weeks off with no supplementation
- then repeat the cycle again
The above dosage amounts are offered as a guideline to loading and
maintenance procedures. Until more scientific research is conducted on
the varying dosages pertaining to lean body weight and the specific
activity performed by the athlete, we do not recommend exceeding the
amounts recommended above. Athletes may start a creatine supplementation
program with lower dosages and monitor improvements in performance.
Remember, more is not necessarily better. Too much creatine will only be
excreted in the urine.
Are there Side Effects
There have been no indications of adverse side effects from long term
creatine usage in existing creatine literature. Currently, long term
studies are under way to try and measure the effects of long term
chronic use. Until these studies are completed, excessive creatine
supplementation should not occur.
Creatine that is not stored in the total creatine pool, as either
creatine or phosphocreatine, is processed out of the body by the kidneys
as creatinine. Creatinine is a natural by-product of creatine production
and considered a waste product by the body. Creatine supplementation in
excess of the required amount needed to saturate the creatine pool is
processed out of the body through the kidneys in the same manner.
What about muscle cramps?
There has been a great deal of attention to the issue of muscle cramps
and creatine usage. It has been proposed by some athletes and sports
professionals that there may exist a possible association of creatine
supplementation and the increased incidence of muscle cramps. To date,
research has not shown association between pure creatine monohydrate
supplementation and muscle cramps. The main cause of muscle cramps is an
imbalance of the electrolytes, calcium and magnesium in the blood or the
muscle tissue stemming from insufficient fluid intake. Thus, creatine
monohydrate users should use only creatine monohydrate free of
impurities while also consuming a minimum of 2 liters of water per day
up to as much as 5 liters per day depending on the duration and
intensity of the exercise.
It is possible to prevent muscle cramping by consuming sufficient
amounts of fluids and isotonic electrolyte drinks prior to, during, and
after exercise. A balanced diet will also contribute trace elements,
vitamins and minerals which are key to efficient metabolism and
electrolyte balance. The bottom line is that lack of sufficient fluid
intake and/or nutritional deficiencies cause cramping, and not creatine
at reasonable doses.
Other Medical Uses for
Creatine:
Creatine is a critical energy intermediary to the production of ATP and
muscular energy. It is essential to life because abnormalities or
deficiencies may lead to related health problems. Creatine has been
researched in several ways that are not sports orientated. Under medical
supervision, creatine monohydrate supplementation has been utilized to
treat certain physiological and physical disorders as well as being used
to help special populations with special needs. For example:
- Creatine supplementation has shown a positive effect
on the reduction of plasma total cholesterol, triacylglycerois and
VLDL.
- Creatine has been found to possess anti-inflammatory
activity on acute inflammation, local irritancy and chronic inflammation
conditions (i.e. arthritic conditions).
- The creatine/phosphocreatine system seems to have a
protective effect on the nervous system and central nervous system under
ischemic and hypoxic conditions.
- An inborn birth defect call
guanidinoacetate-methyltranferase (GAMT) which leads to a creatine
deficiency in the brain and correlated to mental and muscular
retardation is treated through oral creatine supplementation.
- Creatine supplementation is used to treat diseases
that involve muscle atrophy, creatine depletion and neuro-muscular
disorders.
- Creatine has been used to improve the symptoms of
gyrate atrophy, a hereditary and very complex dystrophic eye disease
that causes an enzyme inhibition of the creatine bio-synthesis.
- Creatine is being researched for its possible
benefits in inhibiting the growth of certain types of tumors in
mammals.
- Creatine supplementation has been shown to positively
effect athletic performance of vegetarians.
- During chronic heart failure cardiac creatine levels
are depressed. Creatine supplementation to patients with chronic heart
failure increases skeletal muscle energy-rich phosphocreatine and
performance in regards to strength and endurance.
Conclusion:
Essential to life, health, and well-being, creatine is a unique and
somewhat miraculous substance. Scientific studies support the anecdotal
testimonials to the improvements in sports performance and overall
energy levels. Proper usage can lead to positive effects. The important
considerations for all consumers is the safe and proper dosage of a high
quality source of creatine. Creatine is a great addition to an athletes
training regime and, as researchers may soon show, beneficial for the
non-athletes health as well.