21 James Street From Northern State, take exit 42s, for Southern State take exit 39s, for Sunrise Highway take exit 40s. For all three of these roads, take the exit into Deer Park Ave. South (route 231) - Stay on Deer Park Ave. until you get James Street (Second Left after LIRR tracks in Babylon) - make a left onto James Street. The big white steeple of the Methodist Church is visible from Deer Park Ave. From Montauk Highway (Rt. 27a), make a left onto Deer Park Avenue and a right onto James Street. By Train, this is one block from the Babylon train station. Just go left to Deer Park Ave., make a right, then the next left.