LONG TERM
PSYCHOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF CIRCUMCISION
Although men may be unaware
of the effects of circumcision, the fear that their penis is somehow deficient
is reported to be widespread in American culture. Commercial interests
have responded to this fear by advertising various methods of penile enlargement
in men's magazines. Male preoccupation with the penis is also reflected
in a survey of what men think women find attractive in men. The data showed
that men greatly exaggerated the importance of penis size as a physical
attribute that attracts women. The effect of circumcision on this result
is not known.
The link between adult circumcision,
loss of sensitivity and impotence has been noted in the medical literature.
Since infant circumcision also decreases sexual sensitivity, it is likely
than circumcision is an unrecognized factor in the high rates of impotence
in American men and by association, is also detrimental to male psychological
health. According to a randomized study of 1290 men aged 40-70 years, 52%
reported some degree of impotence, ranging from minimal to complete. This
rate varied from ~40% at age 40 to 67% at age 70. (A literature search
yielded no comparable European study.) Higher rates of impotence were associated
with increased levels of anger and depression. Self-esteem was also lower
in impotent men. The psychological response to impotence would compound
any pre-existing psychological symptoms that have already been discussed.
-
A circumcised boy who matches
others may nevertheless have negative feelings about being circumcised.
These feelings can last for a lifetime.
-
It is not possible to predict
before circumcision how a boy will feel about it later.
-
Even though intact men are in
the minority in the USA, there is no evidence that many of them are dissatisfied
with being intact.
-
An intact male who is unhappy
about it can choose to be circumcised, but this is rarely done. The estimated
rate of adult circumcision in the USA is 3 in 1000.
-
An intact male who is unhappy
about his status may feel different after learning more about circumcision
and the important functions of the foreskin.
The social factor is much
less of an issue for boys born in the USA today because of the lower circumcision
rate (60% nationally, under 40% in some states).