| Name | Age | Location | Website | Fave BsB | Fave BsB Song |
| Lee, Lindsay | 17 | Edmonton, AB | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | Hey Mr. DJ (Keep Playin' This Song) |
| Munroe, Shanalee R. | 16 | Morinville, AB | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | All Of Them |
| Comeault, Raine | 14 | British Columbia | N/A | All | That's What She Said |
| Carter, Liz | 19 | Winnipeg, MB | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Crystal | 17 | Winnipeg, MB | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | I'll Never Find Someone Like You |
| Sarah Gene | 16 | Winnipeg, MB | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Heaven In Your Eyes |
| Taylor, Angela | 27 | Winnipeg, MB | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | That's What She Said |
| Foster, Sarah | 19 | Dartmouth, NS | N/A | All | All |
| Suffron, Shelley | 18 | Nova Scotia | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Heaven In Your Eyes |
| Whitehorne, Louise | 18 | Nova Scotia | N/A | Howie | All I Have To Give |
| Ho, Nicki | 17 | Ancaster, ON | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Quit Playing Games (With My Heart) |
| Clare, Meagan | 15 | Brantford, ON | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | 10,000 Promises; I'll Never Break Your Heart |
| Travis, Jenn | 17 | London, ON | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Anywhere For You |
| Hopper, Julie Lynn | 15 | Lucknow, ON | My World | AJ aKa Bone | Heaven In Your Eyes |
| Johnson, Amanda | 14 | Newcastle, Ontario | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | As Long As You Love Me |
| Feeney, Colleen Erin | 21 | Newmarket, ON | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | As Long As You Love Me |
| Alicia | 15 | Oakville, ON | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Brock, Connie | 18 | Sarnia, ON | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | All I Have To Give |
| Andricciola, Rosie | 22 | Thunder Bay, ON | N/A | Kevin aKa Train | I'll Never Break Your Heart |
| Agostino, Stefanie | 15 | Toronto, ON | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | All |
| Marchese, Stephanie | 18 | Toronto, ON | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | All |
| Quon, Karen | 15 | Toronto, ON | Karen's UnOfficial Backstreet Boys Website | Brian aKa Frick | All |
| Tatum | 18 | Toronto, ON | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All I Have To Give |
| Watanabe, Ainslie Yumi Rae | 14 | Toronto, ON | N/A | All | All |
| Katie | 15 | Ontario | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All |
| Lavell, Heather | 16 | Ontario | N/A | Brian aKa Frick; AJ aKa Bone | Let's Have A Party |
| Littrell, Krystal | 14 | Ontario | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | Let's Have A Party |
| McAllister, Laura | 16 | Ontario | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | Hey Mr. DJ (Keep Playin' This Song) |
| Summer | 11 | Ontario | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | That's What She Said |
| Alicia | 15 | Canada | Brian Littrell World | Brian aKa Frick | Anywhere For You; That's What She Said |
| Carter, Nicki | 15 | Canada | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All |
| CJ | 12 | Canada | CJ's Backstreet Boys Heaven | Nick aKa Frack | Quit Playin' Games (With My Heart) |
| McLean, Sara | 18 | Canada | Backstreet Boys' Club House | AJ aKa Bone | Like A Child |
| Mia | 13 | Canada | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Let's Have A Party |
| Siobhan | 13 | Canada | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Quit Playin' Games (With My Heart) |
| Vanessa | 14 | Canada | Untitled | Brian aKa Frick | I'll Never Break Your Heart; Let's Have A Party |