2005 Update 6
It took me a very
long time to write all these reviews because I have been working extremely hard
in grad school (2 languages, Ph.D. seminar, and one regular master’s level
course). For this reason, I admit there
may be some errors here and there, and maybe a little repetitive language. Nevertheless, I have striven for excellence
and accuracy as always. Finally, due to
my very heavy schedule, I have little time right now to promote this website
(www.oocities.org/criticaltom_2000). I
would be very grateful to all of you who pass on the word about these
reviews. A quick list of bands reviewed
is directly below. Thanks in
advance. שׁלום!
You may notice that
where I list the CD length that some of them look like “1.1 hrs.” as opposed to
“31:12”. This is because I have changed
from using Windows Media Player to iTunes.
Featured
reviews: 1349, Age of Silence, Asguard,
Audrey Horne, Balzac, Centinex, Dark Black, Dream or
Nightmare, Epica, Grimfist,
GZR, Horna, Impaled Nazarene, Lord Belial, Lunatica, Mindgrinder, Misfits
Meet the Nutley Brass, Obituary, Redemption, Ritual Carnage, Rob Rock, Royal
Hunt, Sheavy, Sonic Syndicate, Space Odyssey, Starbreaker, Third Degree, Totalisti,
Twilight, and Wetwork.
1349 “Hellfire”
(8 tracks. 52.1
mins).
CANDLELIGHT
Rating: 7. Country of origin:
As the explosion of Norwegian acts over
the twelve years has diversified and expanded in every possible direction,
there are still those who prefer the cold, harsh aggression of Mayhem, Satyricon, and Thorns (to name a few). Formed by members of the now defunct Alvheim and incorporating Frost (Satyricon)
on drums, 1349 have kept company with the likes of Zyklon,
Gorgoroth, and My Dying Bride just to
name a few. Hellfire is pure
aggression. Cold,
dark, stark, pulsing darkness.
Musically very tight, Hellfire recalls recent Mayhem,
particularly Chimera, but with a real hint of chaos like Emperor
accomplished on “Thus Spake the Night Spirit.” Even so, 1349 aren’t clones of Mayhem and
Emperor. Their music draws comparisons
but is distinct also. The key element to
my ears is insane speed. It’s not
syncopated or off beat like Mayhem, nor is it triumphalistic
and operatic like Emperor, it’s just fast and in-your-face. I don’t have their previous two albums, so I
can’t say anything about how this latest album relates to them. But the promo sheet calls this one their most
powerful to date. It is definitely
powerful.
AGE OF SILENCE “Complications” (3 tracks.
16 mins) THE END
Rating: 9. Country of origin:
Brilliant as always, this group of
Norwegian notables treat us here to a three song concept E.P. conceived of by
vocalist Lazare’s philosophical mind. Those familiar with his Solefald
material will know exactly what I mean. Complications
is all about the blind commercialism rampant in Western society with an
apocalyptic twist: “Hell opened a new
wing on the sixth of June and expanded into the area of human, lustful
yearnings with a shopping mall the size of Canada …” It’s great—but don’t let the critique keep
you from buying this CD! Ha, ha! But seriously, the message is very timely and
I personally agree with Lazare’s evaluation (what we
biblical scholars refer to as “prophetic critique”). Musically Complications is reminiscent
of Age of Silence’s stellar debut, Acceleration. It is somewhere between progressive metal and
avante gard rock. Andy Winter plays keys, Hellhammer
is on drums, but I am not suer who the guitarists are
(Extant and Kobbergaard). Eikind plays
bass. Needless to say, these guys are
superb, but the total package is basically the brainchild of Lazare (lyrics) and Winter
(music). What’s not to like?
ASGUARD “Dreamslave” (16 tracks. 50.4 min) THIS DARK REIGN RECORDINGS.
Rating: 9.5. Country of origin:
Not long after introducing
With Dreamslave
Asguard has done more than up the ante here in
my opinion, I think they have
demonstrated a serious attitude towards both music and lyrics that make Dimmu and other “satanic” styled bands (Cradle of Filth,
etc.) seem silly by comparison. This
album isn’t about offending people, being politically incorrect, or trying to
“out-evil” the competition, it is about making a CD that is respectable and to
be taken seriously. They pull it off
wonderfully. It is a four act, sixteen
song concept masterpiece. Give a little
respect to our Eurasian metal brothers, they have definitely earned it here.
AUDREY HORNE “No Hay Banda” (14 tracks.
1 hr.). CANDLELIGHT
Rating: 9. Country of origin:
I was getting bogged down in my studies
and behind in my reviewing. One day I
put this CD in my car not knowing what I was going to experience. It was great!
The info on the promo sheet says it will appeal to fans of
BALZAC
“Atom Age Vampire in 308” & “Out of the Grave and Into the Dark” (22
track CD + DVD). MISFITS.
Rating: . Country of origin:
This is very strange but interesting. I don’t feel qualified to comment on it
because punk isn’t my thing. But I will
say that the sheer length of this CD as well as the bonus DVD makes it a hefty
release. The band obviously has a sense
of humor which is evident throughout the concert and conceptual pieces. But best of all, the DVD contains a short
horror movie which I thoroughly enjoyed (including the shocking ending).
CENTINEX
“World Declension” (9
tracks. 38.7 min). CANDLELIGHT
Rating: 9. Country of origin:
Listening to a Centinex
album is like riding a runaway train off the side of a cliff. Fifteen years in the business has done
nothing to soften or mellow these guys out.
They have stuck to their principles of fast-paced, head pounding Swedish
death metal. World Declension is
no exception, present is the evil chainsaw tone of their guitars, the clever
riffs, and the full-on aggressions. If
anything, these guys have gotten tighter and more aggressive over the years,
and this new album finds them firing on all 8 cylinders. In short, World Declension is one 39
minute highly concentrated bottle of whoop-ass!
If it were any longer your ears would start bleeding.
DARK BLACK
“The Barbarian’s Hammer” (5
tracks. 31.4 min.). HOT DOG CITY RECORD.
Rating: 5. Country of origin:
I think this band fits somewhere between Bathory and Spinal Tap, maybe in the ballpark
with Motorhead. They are a step heavier than Kiss, and
less refined than Iron Maiden, but you get the picture. It is clear that these guys are aiming to
relive the “glory days” of heavy metal when it was simply called “heavy
metal”. You can tell this from their
name and the song titles too (e.g., “The Warhammer”). Dark Black are just that, classic heavy metal
with pre-thrash and thrash type riffs, blues scale soloing, and screams mixed
with singing (wailing vocals). It has
the elements of many of the type of records that arrived at the local music
stores on a weekly basis back in the 1980’s, but not everything that came out
in the “glory days” was of enduring quality.
All that said, Dark Black isn’t terrible, and I suspect there are people
out there who will actually find this album exciting. For me, I would like to see these guys hone
their talents, keep thinking in terms of the glory of heavy metal, and then
upping the notch to “11”.
DREAM OR
NIGHTMARE
“Light Burning Bright Till the Dawn” (4* tracks. 31:12).
GRIMM THIRTEEN PROD.
Rating: 7.5. Country of
origin:
Speaking
of “old dogs,” thrash veteran, Joe Sims (Reign, Axemaster,
and The Awakening) has this new project called Dream or Nightmare. This self-produced E.P. has the band looking
to get noticed by some labels. But it is
surely an E.P. more than a demo due to the good production. At first I didn’t know how to approach this
CD because it is an interesting combination of traditional and modern metal
sounds. It’s not overly heavy, nor is it
commercial; not thrashy, but certainly technical in
places. In the final analysis I must say
that it is rather genre-defying and is best described simply as “heavy
metal”. What is absolutely definable
about this disc is its dark, even sinister, tone. Not too surprising considering song titles
like “Self-Inflicted Gunshot Wound to the Head”. Especially
EPICA “We Will Take You With Us” (9
tracks. 54:00). TRANSMISSION/THE END
RECORDS.
Rating: 9.5. Country of
origin: The
Here is another unbelievable band from the
GRIMFIST “10 Steps to Hell” (10 tracks.
43.4 mins). CANDLELIGHT
Rating: . Country of origin:
10 Steps to Hell is aggressive,
brutal as you might expect from and band named “Grimfist”
and with such an album title as 10 Steps to Hell. At the same time the band displays a real
knack for the classic thrash/death riff, some well-placed slower parts
(especially the doomy section in track one, “Power”),
and some traditional metal stylings. You could say that it is brutal, but not
oppressive. It gives you a sense of
satisfaction from simultaneously wanting to smash your furniture while smiling
at your co-listeners, banging your head, and give the goat-horn salute Beavis
and Butthead style. As before, the
production is spot-on. This CD would
make a great companion to Mindgrinder (also
reviewed here). Both bands should tour
together.
GZR “Ohmwork” (10 tracks. 43.6 min).
SANCTUARY.
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
Respect!
Geezer
HORNA “Envaaatnags Eflos Solf Esgantaavne” (8
tracks). WOODCUT/THE END.
Rating: 6.5. Country of origin:
I don’t think this is Horna’s
first recording, but it is my first time to hear them. They basically sound like early Mayhem,
Darkthrone, and obscure acts like Armagedda, Judas Iscariot, and maybe Burzum minus the keyboards. You can even hear on the tracks at times
where they have layered one guitar over another (there are only two of them after
all). The appeal of this kind of music
is not its complexity or its having been well-thought out or planned, but
rather its rawness, energy, and atmosphere.
Or to put it another way, it is all about the black metal attitude.
IMPALED NAZARENE “Death Comes in 26 Carefully Selected
Pieces” (26 tracks. 1.1
hrs.). Osmose/The
End.
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
Impaled Nazarene are
one of the most chaotic bands to hail from
LORD BELIAL “The Seal of Belial” (8 tracks. 47.5 mins.). CANDLELIGHT
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
Lord Belial’s brand of Swedish death has a
very old school feel. It is not the
hyper-fast, blastbeat style so prominent today. Rather, it is heavy and sinister with
emphasis on atmosphere. Fans of Dimmu Borgir and Old
Man’s Child will appreciate this sound, though it is typically slower paced
and missing the keyboards. There are blastbeats, of course, and some of the songs are rather
fast; but again, the accent is on atmosphere.
Often while listening to this CD I was reminded of Antestor’s
atmospheric flair and Bathory’s sense of
darkness. It’s a good combination. The name and subject matter earn the band the
added designation of “black metal.” For
the first time a Lord Belial album will be released domestically thanks to
Candlelight
LUNATICA “Fables & Dreams” (10 tracks. 51.6 mins). LOCOMOTIVE.
Rating: 8. Country of origin: ?
Release date: Available now.
The fact that Sasha
Paeth was involved in the production of this CD is
enough to make me want to buy it. Like
many of his other projects—Rhapsody, Epica,
Aina—Lunatica is a
dazzling symphonic classical metal opera with female vocals, choirs, orchestra,
and a lot of class. Not quite as
ostentatious as Rhapsody and Aina, Lunatica more resembles Epica’s
focus on the total package rather than individual talent within the band. As opposed to the more bombastic bands in
this field, Lunatica’s music maintains a more
artistic even keel. As the album title
suggests, the storyline is certainly reminiscent of fantasy epics like Aina and Rhapsody are known for, perhaps also a little Blind
Guardian influence as well. I do not
have names for the band members, but the vocalist, whoever she is, has a lovely
voice. She of course can take her side
by the other female vocalists in her genre, but I would also have to point out
that at times she has a bit of a twang which makes me wonder if she listens to
some of the younger female country vocalists.
MINDGRINDER “Riot Detonator” (9 tracks. 36.1 mins). CANDLELIGHT
Rating: 9.5. Country of
origin: . Release date: July 26.
What do you get when a Norwegian death
metal outfit has contributing members hailing from bands like Zyklon, Scum, and Windir? You get some talented musicians refocusing
their talents into a slightly different genre—and doing it very nicely! Every listen to this CD makes you want to
listen to it more. And I predict that
with Zamoth’s already established reputation
in the metal world, Mindgrinder will go far. All that said, these guys have reached beyond
themselves to create one of the most memorable (an important word in this
genre) albums of recent memory. There’s
a lot here to recommend itself to the discriminating death metal
enthusiast. First, there is the classic
sound. Second, the exceptionally fine
riffs. Third, marvelous execution. Fourth repeatability, that is, you want to go
back and listen to it over and over again.
MISFITS MEET
Rating: 7.5. Country of
origin:
Imagine being at a lounge in
OBITUARY
“Frozen in Time” (10 tracks. 34:12).
ROADRUNNER.
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
Obituary returns after another hiatus
(remember Back from the Dead?) to deliver a solid example of what
Floridian death metal is. As suggested
by the album title, Frozen in Time, Obituary have not tried to “move
forward” or “progress”. While other
bands and trends come and go quickly, Obituary has decided to stay the
course. And they imply in the CD
cover that they are still around because their type of metal—death metal!—has
more staying power than the trendy stuff.
They refer to it as “natural selection” at work in the metal world. Thus the dinosaur becomes the predator. Tough talk, eh? What can I say? These guys know their craft and stick to
it. The album begins with a real mosher’s anthem, “Redneck Stomp” which sets much of the
tone for the album. Track 6, “Mindset”,
reveals a little Celtic Frost influence—no, make that a lot of CF. Think Morbid Tales. Also one might speculate that these guys may
have been kicking back a little Motorhead in
their time off. And so the majority of
the tracks on this album don’t seem to be as technical as some of their older
material, (“Lockjaw” being one notable exception), but they are all about heavy
metal in its classic form. In a word,
“classic”.
RAM-ZET “Intra”
(9 tracks. 53.5
mins.).
CANDLELIGHT
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
As
always, the interesting band with a strange name delivers a third helping of
their unique blend of beauty and brutality.
As the old saying goes, “third time’s a charm,” I find that Intra
is the strongest and most accessible album by Ram-Zet
to date. On their previous two albums
one could see their potential budding, but the first was largely a solo project
(if memory serves) and the second album was the first with a full band. Here we see the full band with some real
chemistry clicking on all eight cylinders.
It is tempting to lump Ram-Zet into a category
between Dimmu Borgir
and Ein Soph—especially
since Ein Soph has that
sort of chaotic element. Members of the
band also have gigs in The Kovenant, Asmegin, and For My Pain, fine bands
all. But that is only half the
story. The chaos and brutality are set
off with lovely female vocals, violins, etc. reminiscent of Sanctum
(Swedish ind. Band on Cold Meat
REDEMPTION “The Fullness of Time” (8 tracks. 57.4 min).
SENSORY.
Rating: 9. Country of origin:
This album demanded I do more and just
listen to the music. It has a story that
compelled me to read the lyrics and be inspired. Like NovAct
a few months ago, Redemption is a band that shows how metal can be mature and
deep while still making you want to bang your head. It is both musically muscular and deeply
emotional. Redemption features members
of Fates Warning, Steel Prophet, and Symphony X and is
produced by none other than Tommy Newton.
To me they sound similar to their respective bands, but also a lot like Savatage meets Green Carnation. But I especially like the youthful vigor that
comes across in their music. Though they
are seasoned and respectable musicians, they know how to sound fresh and
exciting. This is a great
combination.
RITUAL CARNAGE “I,
Infidel” (12 tracks. 35:00).
OSMOSE/THE END.
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
Now this is a band that has kept the faith
with thrash in its true form. After
twelve years in the business RC sound as fresh as 1984. (1984 is my personal reference point to
thrash). Other thrash bands like Annihilator
and Flotsam and Jetsam have endured and kept the faith in a much more
pristine form than the recent metalcore bands have,
but I think I, Infidel is probably the best example of pure thrash
that I have heard in a long time. If I
didn’t know that this band is from
ROB ROCK “Holy Hell” (10 tracks. 46.6 mins.). CANDLELIGHTUSA.
Rating: 8.5. Country of
origin:
After establishing a solid resume as a
vocalist/session vocalist for a number of impressive bands like Impelliteri, Warrior, Angelica (oh
yes, Rob, I know about this one!), and others, Rob Rock set out to create an
entity of his own choosing and further established his credibility with Rage
of Creation. Now he returns with a
second solo release which shows no signs of slowing down, weakening, or
commercializing; Holy Hell has its own set of sanctified steel
balls. Of course “I’ll Be Waiting for
You” and “Move On” may have their places among the more commercial power metal
acts, they stand as a ballads on an otherwise
destructive album (this is a typical feature on albums by religious
musicians). And while “Calling Angels”
may have the power metal anthem quality, it still demonstrates an aggressive
intensity that would make Bon Jovi crap his
pants. Other songs like “Slayer of
Souls,” “Holy Hell,” and “Lion of Judah,” among others will crush your skull. Like Narnia
and other bands that do not hide their theological convictions, Rob Rock
conveys a positive message lyrically that is apocalyptic (which is quite normal
in all forms of heavy metal) without being obnoxious or preachy. With this latest CD Rock has brought to bear
his faith and all of his musical influences in a very powerful way.
ROYAL HUNT
“Paper Blood” (12 tracks. 1.1 hrs.) MAGNA CARTA.
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
This band deserves more recognition. They are an incredibly talented and
well-seasoned band. I prefer to think of
them as neo-classical prog. Metal, but I have to say,
that they are among the more exciting prog. Metal
bands in my opinion. The label compares
them to Queensryche and Deep Purple. I agree, but
SHEAVY
“Republic?” (11 tracks. 50.9 min).
CANDLELIGHT
Rating: 7.5. Country of
origin: . Release date: Available now.
I can’t think of a stoner doom rock/metal
outfit that deserves the Black Sabbath comparisons more than sHeavy. Vocalist
Steve Hennessey sounds so much like Ozzy that even
Sharon Osbourne may be fooled. The lyrics and structure of the songs also
are highly suggestive of Sabbath.
However, while the band and vocals clearly embody the “Sabbath ethic” so
to speak, guitarist Dan Moore really has a style of his own which may get
overlooked because of the Sabbath comparisons.
To me his style is a bit more modern and blue collar than Tony Iommi’s. sHeavy was first recognized by Lee Dorrian
and signed to *** Records, but now Candlelight has signed them and has
delivered Republic? which is their third, and perhaps their strongest
record to date. Look for these guys to
expand their fan base with this new release.
SONIC
SYNDICATE “
Rating: 7.5. Country of
origin:
The oldest guy in this band was born in
1983 (I was a freshman in high school!), and the ages of this band range from
17-22. This is a significant fact when
you listen to this band, because they sound like they have it together in ways
that 17-22 year-olds rarely do. This CD
is a collection of three E.P.’s the band previously recorded and marks their record
label debut to the metal world. It
sounds like they have been taking in heavy doses of Swedish death metal in the
vein of In Flames, Dark Tranquility. And they have really made that style their
own. I would not at this stage give them
points for creativity—not that much older bands automatically get creativity
points either—but I would say that they have done an excellent job of emulating
their influences. The music and the
production are excellent and you might fool some of your friends into thinking
they are In Flames. Pivotal Recordings
label founder Leevan Macomeau
believed in them so much that he launched said record label in order to make
this music available to the rest of the world.
I think it was a good choice.
SPACE ODYSSEY “The Astral Episode” (8 tracks. 53.4).
CANDLELIGHT
Rating: 8.5. Country of
origin: . Release date: Available now.
The Astral Episode is the
second release of Richard Andersson’s Space
Odyssey. It features Richard Andersson (obviously!) whose resume includes work with
members of Royal Hunt, Yngwe Malmsteen, Translatlantic,
and work as touring keyboardist for Symphony X. I know that says a lot, but believe me, he is
awesome. Guitarist Magnuss
Nilsson is an excellent choice to compliment Andersson. Anyone who is into Warmen
and Rhapsody and any band that has a strong guitarist/keyboardist team will
certainly want to gravitate to this.
Vocalist Nils Patrik
Johansson the band a Dio-styled vocal
delivery. And the intensity is
maintained by a very competent 17 year-old drummer named Andreas Brobjer; no bassist is mentioned. From the sound of things I think it is safe
to surmise that Andersson put a great deal of time
into selecting band members, and also in crafting these songs. It’s good stuff.
STARBREAKER s/t (13 tracks. 56.5 mins). LOCOMOTIVE
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
I am at least old enough to remember the
80’s/90’s pop metal band, TNT. So
when I read that Starbreaker features TNT vocalist
Tony Harnell I wondered if this CD was going to be
one of those “we still like glam metal” type albums. The answer is that Starbreaker
sounds more like a young melodic Swedish band doing their 21st
century rendering of classic metal. This
is not surprising since Harnell recruited a young
Swede named Magnus Karlsson (Last Tribe, Lande/Allen).
Karlsson’s musicianship lives up to the
expectations one has for a Swedish guitarist, and nowhere is this more apparent
than on the killer instrumental, “Dragonfly”.
Harnell still sings like a pop/metal singer
with his gritty metal voice which sounds really good. True to his roots, his vocals allow for easy
attainment of the lyrics, which are more substantive than TNT’s and reflect the
process of maturation (nothing is more disturbing than a late 30’s/early 40’s
aged rocker singing party songs). The
combination of Harnell’s experience, Karlsson’s modern Swedish guitar approach, and the rest of
the band makes for a very solid classic/melodic metal album.
THIRD DEGREE
“Outstay” (13 tracks. 34.9 min).
SELFMADEGOD RECORDS.
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
I could have told you that this was a
brutal death metal CD before ever popping it in because it is from
TOTALISTI “Slave to None” (12 tracks.
). MAGNA CARTA.
Rating: 7. Country of origin:
Just like the promo sheet claims, Totalisti is a hybrid of modern groove and classic prog. Metal. One
could simply call it modern progressive metalcore,
but that would probably lend the wrong impression. In my own words, I would say that they are
like a heavier version of the Stone Temple Pilots with perhaps a Pacific
Northwestern take on metalcore, which is lighter than
the
TWILIGHT
“Twilight” (9 tracks. 44:12).
SOUTHERN LORD
Rating: 8. Country of origin:
The ultra-dedicated fans of obscure
American underground black metal will have an orgy over this album. Twilight is composed of five American black
metal hermits: Wrest of Leviathan and Lurker of Chalice, Malefic
of Xasthur, Hildof
of Draguar, Imperial of Krieg, and Azentrius
of Nachtmystium. Each of these five miscreants have until now
been known for their solo work much like Burzum
and Judas Iscariot. But now they
have pooled their “talents” and created a very interesting, haunting, creepy,
fuzzy, obscure, and altogether intriguing mixture of their styles. It is practically impossible to separate
their individual contributions, and one wonders if these are
collaborations, or a collection of individual tracks drawn together. One thing is for certain: Twilight recalls the darkest days of black
metal’s primitive beginnings complete with tortured dungeon vocals, atmospheric
keyboards (in place), Bathory type riffs (in places),
and all the other perks you would expect from such a collaboration. Euronymous would
have signed them back in the day.
WETWORK “Synod” (9 tracks. 38.5 mins.). KRANKENHAUS.
Rating:
9.5. Country of Origin:
Here is another great surprise for
2005. Wetwork
in my opinion are a band that has taken what might be called the “classic death
metal sound” and brought it forward.
This CD is a combination of killer classic death metal riffs and a
sinister atmosphere. Their music is
intense and powerful. Many times the
driving, double bass
and the chunky riffing is too intense for you to simply sit and
listen. At the very least you will have
to bob your head intensely. On the other
hand, the band knows how to compliment their aggressive style with some
well-placed melodic and progressive asides.
These are not “thrown in” for variety’s sake, they are legitimate and
suggest the members of the band have either some sort of formal training in
music, or are just exceptionally gifted composers. In terms of music alone, I like this CD so
much that I saved it to my hard drive so that I could keep it close. But wait, that’s not all. I’ve been saving the best for last. Wetwork have the
coolest vocalist. Anybody remember
Leather from Chastain? Well Wetwork has her death metal equivalent. I don’t know her name, but she is
awesome. On the spoken parts (Latin
magical incantations, for instance) she sounds wicked, on the guttural death
metal parts, she crushes. Arch Enemy
should be jealous. This girl rocks! If you don’t check out any other death metal
album this year, make sure you check out Wetwork’s Synod. You will not regret it.
I can’t end this
page of reviews without saying how much I enjoy Opeth’s
latest masterpiece, Ghost Reveries.
I am not on Roadrunner’s promo list, thus I had to buy it. As usual it was worth every penny. I think it is more like Still Life
than the last three albums have been, but it is yet different and in a way
their most mature release. At the same
time, can anyone find fault with Orchid or Mourningrise? NO!
These guys can do no wrong in my opinion.
NEW LINKS:
Holy Steel Webzine at
www.holysteel.com.